Kinnelon man could be out $1.4 million after neighbor cuts down 32 of his trees

Samih Shinway says that all that is left are broken branches and stumps. He says that his neighbor allegedly hired landscapers to cut down the trees so that he could have a better view.

Matt Trapani and Amanda Lee

Jul 1, 2023, 1:23 AM

Updated 392 days ago

Share:

A man in Kinnelon has been getting national attention after his neighbors cut down 32 trees on his property. It is estimated that replanting all the trees could cost upward of $1 million.
Homeowner Samih Shinway says that all that is left are broken branches and stumps. He says that his neighbor allegedly hired landscapers to cut down the trees so that he could have a better view. But Shinway says that for the landscapers to do that, they had to hop a gate and come onto his private property.
“I would never imagine that somebody would hire people to come over their fence to destroy somebody else's property. I feel violated, it angers me, and it breaks my heart and I just want it fixed,” Shinway says.
Shinway says that his neighbor apparently thought that the property was his own. He says that he hasn’t seen his neighbor. He says that the neighbor dropped off a note about the situation.
“He stated that he wasn't a bad neighbor and that he moved up here because he loves nature,” Shinway says.
Officials say that the neighbor could be fined up to $32,000, which is $1,000 for each tree.
But Shinway says that this is nothing compared to the estimate he got from contractors on how much it will cost to replant all of the trees. He says it could cost $1.4 million.
“The reason why it’s going to cost so much money is that there’s no easy way to access it. As you guys witnessed coming up here, you’d have to knock a couple of trees down and build a road,” Shinway says. “You’d have to add soil, you’d have to water the trees, they’d have to establish their roots for at least two years.”
The township is investigating the situation. But Shinway also shared his story on social media and found that incidents like this are happening across the country.
“I think there should be some sort of legislation protecting these trees because if you were to scale it out over the span of the entire country, it’s a lot more than these protected areas that end up getting wildfires,” Shinway says.
A court hearing is scheduled for mid-July.


More from News 12
2:16
Fire at Fair Lawn strip mall destroys multiple businesses, including popular Zadies Bakery

Fire at Fair Lawn strip mall destroys multiple businesses, including popular Zadies Bakery

2:11
Beautiful weekend ahead for New Jersey with sunny skies and warm temperatures

Beautiful weekend ahead for New Jersey with sunny skies and warm temperatures

1:54
Boar’s Head deli meat recalled for potential listeria contamination

Boar’s Head deli meat recalled for potential listeria contamination

0:46
New Jersey to receive more than $72M to help coastal communities prevent flooding

New Jersey to receive more than $72M to help coastal communities prevent flooding

1:43
Officials: Lead found on Keyport beach not ‘urgent risk’ to public health, no need to close beach

Officials: Lead found on Keyport beach not ‘urgent risk’ to public health, no need to close beach

0:44
Jersey Proud: Goya Gives Day collects 100,000 pounds of food donations

Jersey Proud: Goya Gives Day collects 100,000 pounds of food donations

1:01
‘It’s a beautiful sport.’ New pickleball courts open in Howell Township

‘It’s a beautiful sport.’ New pickleball courts open in Howell Township

0:29
Man who pleaded guilty to attacking Jewish men sentenced to 30 years on terror charges

Man who pleaded guilty to attacking Jewish men sentenced to 30 years on terror charges

0:55
EPA completes Phase 1 of Superfund site cleanup at Unimatic Manufacturing site in Fairfield

EPA completes Phase 1 of Superfund site cleanup at Unimatic Manufacturing site in Fairfield

0:20
West New York school named for Sen. Menendez to revert to original name

West New York school named for Sen. Menendez to revert to original name

0:30
Attorney general: NJ state trooper ‘inexcusably crossed the line,’ admits to punching handcuffed woman in the face in 2022

Attorney general: NJ state trooper ‘inexcusably crossed the line,’ admits to punching handcuffed woman in the face in 2022

0:15
East Brunswick police: Bicyclist killed in Route 18 crash

East Brunswick police: Bicyclist killed in Route 18 crash

0:30
No one injured in Kenilworth house fire

No one injured in Kenilworth house fire

1:04
Attorney general releases body camera footage of fatal Hamilton police-involved shooting

Attorney general releases body camera footage of fatal Hamilton police-involved shooting

0:15
Part of Manchester’s Harry Wright Lake closed due to high levels of fecal bacteria

Part of Manchester’s Harry Wright Lake closed due to high levels of fecal bacteria

0:23
2 dead in Maine plane crash after leaving New Jersey airport

2 dead in Maine plane crash after leaving New Jersey airport

0:18
$1 million lottery ticket won from $20 scratch-off at North Wildwood Wawa

$1 million lottery ticket won from $20 scratch-off at North Wildwood Wawa

1:59
Paws & Pals: Felicity now up for adoption at Associated Humane Societies

Paws & Pals: Felicity now up for adoption at Associated Humane Societies

1:17
Gov. Murphy discusses potential Menendez replacement on ‘Ask Gov. Murphy’

Gov. Murphy discusses potential Menendez replacement on ‘Ask Gov. Murphy’

0:40
State, federal lawmakers introduce legislation to shorten funding gap for World Trade Center Health Program

State, federal lawmakers introduce legislation to shorten funding gap for World Trade Center Health Program