News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Toll of Commuting
Sunny
75°
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Toll of Commuting

Middletown parents want answers about plan to close schools

The district says the gap this year is $3.2 million and gets bigger down the line.

Tom Krosnowski

Mar 25, 2026, 5:10 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

Parents in Middletown want more answers as two schools are set to close.

The school board voted last month to close two elementary schools - Leonardo and Navesink - and repurpose Bayshore Middle into an elementary school. Students all over the district would be impacted.

Last year, residents paid a 10% increase in school property taxes to help close a multi-million-dollar budget gap. One year later, the district says that was a “temporary bridge” and that more cuts are needed.

The budget presentation calls for a 2% tax levy increase - the maximum allowed most years. There's also a staff reduction of 40, largely from attrition, the presentation says.

The district says the gap this year is $3.2 million and gets bigger down the line. They say closing the schools will save more than $3.5 million yearly.

But parents have concerns. They staged a protest earlier this month.

“One of the things why we moved to this area was the small school vibe," said parent Vanessa Bannon. "It's unfortunate what's been happening without the consideration of the children.”

“When you've been given no details, it feels very much rushed through," said Jeff, a Middletown parent. "The reality is, this is what they tried to do last year.”

“There's really not enough room for all the middle schoolers in those schools," said parent Kristin Rooney.

Rooney is one of the parents who filed an appeal to the Department of Education, arguing the plan broke policy, would lead to overcrowding and could enhance school segregation.

Top Stories

00:26
Screenshot 2026-09-14 121625

Data center fuel leak sends diesel into creek connected to Hackensack River

01:40
RizzoSM3

A fresh and fall-like week is expected with cooler high temperatures.

00:47
mobilelab

Mobile science lab visits Middlesex County students

NJSP COLD CASE FRONT

NJ State Police seek help identifying woman killed in East Orange 42 years ago

02:01
Screenshot 2026-09-14 073614

Made in New Jersey: Toms River couple turns family guacamole recipe into thriving business

00:14
Screenshot 2026-09-14 121545

Hackensack firefighters respond to numerous calls during Sunday flooding

00:26
Screenshot 2026-09-14 123719

New Jersey ranks among top states where workers could face AI-related job disruption

00:16
PatersonPolice

Police officer hit by vehicle during Dominican parade in Paterson, driver arrested

01:46
Screenshot 2026-09-14 072023

Aging Long Branch bridge carrying 23,000 vehicles a day closes until spring 2027

00:21
fi-lidl

Which major grocery chain is cheapest in NJ? New analysis compares prices

00:18
fatal motorcycle crash

Motorcyclist killed in collision with car in South Plainfield

AP26225489678818

NJ property tax relief: How to get ANCHOR, Stay NJ and Senior Freeze benefits

02:12
9142026WCkane_2026-09-14-05-28-54

Your donated clothes may not go directly to people in need, experts warn

00:56
Screenshot 2026-09-12 121232

Turtle rescued after spending nearly 50 years confined to kitchen floor

01:25
Screenshot 2026-09-14 084958

Tony Danza returns to the stage at Café Carlyle

01:51
Screenshot 2026-09-14 053735

Toll Of Commuting: Some Passaic crossing guards can now write parking tickets

00:24
9142026NJtennis_2026-09-14-06-29-57

Summit 11-year-old gets moment in spotlight during US Open men's final

02:00
PatersonFloodingTn

Paterson mayor renews call for federal help after flooding slams city again

02:04
RTNJParamusMarathonFloodCQueally10pm_2026-09-13-22-16-01

'I had to hold myself to a rail.' Runners wade through waist-high floodwaters during Paramus half marathon

00:51
BayonneLLParadeTn

'They made us proud.' Bayonne honors Little League team with parade celebration

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices