Kane in Your Corner: Mechanics duping drivers on oil quality

When you get an oil change, you trust the mechanic to give you the right stuff. But a Kane In Your Corner investigation finds you may get the wrong oil, or oil that may potentially damage your engine.

News 12 Staff

Apr 23, 2015, 3:14 AM

Updated 3,318 days ago

Share:

Kane in Your Corner: Mechanics duping drivers on oil quality
When you get an oil change, you trust the mechanic to give you the right stuff. But a Kane In Your Corner investigation finds you may get the wrong oil, or oil that may potentially damage your engine.
Kane In Your Corner went undercover to seven mechanics and quick lubes. Test results indicate six of the seven sold motor oil that was not 5W-30, according to the Petroleum Quality Institute of America, which assisted with the investigation. The vehicle manufacturer specifies 5W-30 oil only.
In addition, the PQIA says two of the garages provided oil that could cause engine damage if used long-term. Tests show those oils were not only far off in viscosity, but also low on anti-wear additives, which the PQIA says makes them unsuitable for most cars. "If they put that oil in my car, knowing what I know about oil, I would be close to livid," PQIA president Tom Glenn says.
One of those two businesses, a Meineke franchise on Woodbridge Avenue in Edison, declined to discuss the oil they sell. An employee who identified himself as "Steve" initially questioned Kane In Your Corner's honesty, saying, "I was here that day and we didn't give (your producer) an extra quart of oil so I don't know what oil you tested." Informed News 12 New Jersey had video indicating the business had provided the extra oil, "Steve" declined to comment further, saying he was not the store manager and "I don't anything about where (the oil) comes from, exactly." The manager did not return messages.
The President of Meineke Car Care Centers LLC, Daniel R. Rivera, says: "We are looking into this situation and will take the appropriate steps to make sure this center and the rest of the Meineke system is operating according to industry, state and federal regulations."
At the other garage selling potentially harmful oil, a BP station in Metuchen, the investigation took a twist. The owner told Kane In Your Corner he had just fired his supplier because of concerns about the oil he was getting. "We think we're buying a product that's reputable on the market," he says. "Then find out later it's not." He also produced invoices proving he had switched suppliers. Industry sources say the new supplier has a reputation for selling a quality product.
Darren Wall, manager of Quality Auto Center in Colonia, the garage the lab says provided the right grade of oil, says there's no excuse for getting it wrong, since garages use computerized databases to tell them what oil to use. He says, "If you don't have that technology, you really shouldn't be in this business."
Even without a computer, finding the right oil for Kane In Your Corner's undercover vehicle was absurdly simple. It was literally printed on the oil cap, which technicians had to remove before adding new oil.


More from News 12
1:08
Water main break in Hackensack sends water shooting up into the air

Water main break in Hackensack sends water shooting up into the air

2:29
Weather improves overnight; sunny and warm Friday ahead to start the holiday weekend

Weather improves overnight; sunny and warm Friday ahead to start the holiday weekend

2:59
Fallen trees cause widespread damage as powerful storm tears through West Milford

Fallen trees cause widespread damage as powerful storm tears through West Milford

0:23
Two charged in fatal Jersey City shooting

Two charged in fatal Jersey City shooting

1:23
Floodwater running ‘over the train track bridge like a waterfall’ traps driver in Avenel

Floodwater running ‘over the train track bridge like a waterfall’ traps driver in Avenel

1:32
Gov. Murphy calls out Amtrak for system failures, says it ‘disrupts quality of life’ for NJ residents

Gov. Murphy calls out Amtrak for system failures, says it ‘disrupts quality of life’ for NJ residents

1:17
Rutgers University president defends making deals with pro-Palestinian protesters

Rutgers University president defends making deals with pro-Palestinian protesters

0:21
Police seek public’s help identifying man who robbed Lopatcong credit union

Police seek public’s help identifying man who robbed Lopatcong credit union

0:19
Police: 1 person injured, 1 arrested following incident in Wall Township

Police: 1 person injured, 1 arrested following incident in Wall Township

0:57
Officer who arrested Scottie Scheffler disciplined for not having bodycam activated

Officer who arrested Scottie Scheffler disciplined for not having bodycam activated

1:50
Jersey Shore towns kick off summer pedestrian safety campaign ahead of Memorial Day

Jersey Shore towns kick off summer pedestrian safety campaign ahead of Memorial Day

News 12 Book Club

News 12 Book Club

1:41
Best Beaches: We are kicking off the unofficial start to summer at Jenkinson's in Point Pleasant Beach

Best Beaches: We are kicking off the unofficial start to summer at Jenkinson's in Point Pleasant Beach

0:20
Car carrier truck breaks out in fire on New Jersey Turnpike in Kearny

Car carrier truck breaks out in fire on New Jersey Turnpike in Kearny

0:43
Traveling for Memorial Day weekend? Here are the best and worst times to travel

Traveling for Memorial Day weekend? Here are the best and worst times to travel

0:24
Prosecutors: Homeless man accused of sexually assaulting child at Morristown park

Prosecutors: Homeless man accused of sexually assaulting child at Morristown park

2:44
News 12 gets a sneak preview of Savannah Sunset Resort & Spa at Six Flags Great Adventure

News 12 gets a sneak preview of Savannah Sunset Resort & Spa at Six Flags Great Adventure

0:20
Rangers held scoreless for the first time this postseason in a 3-0 loss to the Panthers in Game 1

Rangers held scoreless for the first time this postseason in a 3-0 loss to the Panthers in Game 1

2:38
Shamong woman says she won $2M jackpot from Atlantic City slot machine but casino won’t pay

Shamong woman says she won $2M jackpot from Atlantic City slot machine but casino won’t pay