KIYC: Woman out thousands after mechanic fixes wrong car

Imagine paying thousands of dollars for a transmission repair, only to learn the car you fixed wasn't yours? A Morris County woman says it happened to her, and she could not resolve the issue until she

News 12 Staff

Apr 1, 2015, 3:37 AM

Updated 3,301 days ago

Share:

KIYC: Woman out thousands after mechanic fixes wrong car
Imagine paying thousands of dollars for a transmission repair, only to learn the car you fixed wasn't yours? A Morris County woman says it happened to her, and she could not resolve the issue until she got Kane in her Corner.
For the past couple of months, Stephanie Fox has been dependent on friends to drive her to and from work, pick up her son from school and run errands. "The inconvenience of having to have rides or borrow cars and be at somebody else's behest every time I need to go somewhere with two children is ridiculous," she says.
The problem started when the transmission failed on her black 2008 Ford Edge. She took it to Performance Ford in Randolph, but decided the price of a new transmission was too high, so she arranged to have the vehicle towed to a repair shop, which could rebuild the transmission for less. Fox says when she showed up to claim her vehicle once the repair was complete, she noticed a problem: the vehicle wasn't hers, it was a different black Ford Edge.
Her friend, who used his flatbed truck to transport Fox's vehicle, says the dealership gave him the wrong vehicle; the dealership says it handed the friend the keys to the vehicle he picked out. Either way, Fox says she paid $2,900 to repair the transmission on a car she did not own.
The owner of Performance Ford, Kevin DiPiano, was happy to sit down with Kane In Your Corner to explain his side of the story. He says Fox should simply have refused to pay the transmission shop for the repair, letting that business and the dealership sort things out. "He hasn't done anything to her car, so why would she owe him money?" he says.
DiPiano admits his employees gave the flatbed truck driver keys to the wrong car, but points out that there's plenty of blame to go around. He says the truck driver failed to cross-check the car's VIN or even its license plate number to make sure he was taking the correct vehicle. He also says the repair shop never confirmed it had the right car before performing the repair, and never checked the transmission on the car he was given before replacing it. "This could have been stopped right then and there," DiPiano says. "If you're given a car that supposedly needs a transmission (but it doesn't), then either our diagnosis was wrong...or you have the wrong car."
Because of the inconvenience Fox suffered, DiPiano was willing to make her an offer. Performance Ford will settle the original repair bill with the transmission shop, essentially splitting the cost. And for the $2,900 Fox planned to spend on a rebuilt transmission, the dealership will install a brand new one with a 100,000 mile warranty, a $6,000 value.
All of which means Stephanie Fox should not have to stand around waiting for rides much longer.


More from News 12
0:44
NJ Attorney General announces heightened safety measures amid tensions in Middle East

NJ Attorney General announces heightened safety measures amid tensions in Middle East

1:06
Scattered severe storms possible Sunday night in New Jersey

Scattered severe storms possible Sunday night in New Jersey

2:36
'She was the glue.' Loved ones call for justice for Passaic woman killed in hit-and-run

'She was the glue.' Loved ones call for justice for Passaic woman killed in hit-and-run

0:32
Prosecutors: Howell woman indicted in Monmouth County crash that killed 3-year-old

Prosecutors: Howell woman indicted in Monmouth County crash that killed 3-year-old

0:28
Israel hails ‘success’ in blocking Iran’s unprecedented attack. Biden now seeks diplomatic response

Israel hails ‘success’ in blocking Iran’s unprecedented attack. Biden now seeks diplomatic response

0:54
Clean Ocean Action hosts 39th Spring Beach Sweep in Sandy Hook

Clean Ocean Action hosts 39th Spring Beach Sweep in Sandy Hook

0:30
Out in the street: Bruce Springsteen makes it to Mohegan Sun show after flat tire in Jersey

Out in the street: Bruce Springsteen makes it to Mohegan Sun show after flat tire in Jersey

0:16
Police: Elizabeth man charged with sexually assaulting 2 children

Police: Elizabeth man charged with sexually assaulting 2 children

2:39
Police: 3 people in van on way to adult day care center killed in crash in South Brunswick

Police: 3 people in van on way to adult day care center killed in crash in South Brunswick

Police: Truck driver, toll booth attendant seriously injured in crash at Barnegat Toll Plaza

Police: Truck driver, toll booth attendant seriously injured in crash at Barnegat Toll Plaza

1:35
CDC: Measles could lose 'elimination status' amid uptick across the U.S.

CDC: Measles could lose 'elimination status' amid uptick across the U.S.

0:51
IRS warns public about potential tax scams as Tax Day deadline approaches

IRS warns public about potential tax scams as Tax Day deadline approaches

2:27
Congress investigates rise in antisemitism at Rutgers, including incident involving student 2 weeks ago

Congress investigates rise in antisemitism at Rutgers, including incident involving student 2 weeks ago

0:22
Elizabeth man sentenced to 25 years in prison for road rage rampage

Elizabeth man sentenced to 25 years in prison for road rage rampage

0:56
Jersey Proud: Miracle League of Mercer County to hold first game of season

Jersey Proud: Miracle League of Mercer County to hold first game of season

0:18
Prosecutor: 4th person charged in New Brunswick shooting that injured 2 Rutgers students

Prosecutor: 4th person charged in New Brunswick shooting that injured 2 Rutgers students

0:20
Newark officials postpone plans for overnight curfew for minors

Newark officials postpone plans for overnight curfew for minors

1:52
New York Red Bulls to hold annual Autism Acceptance match for families with autism

New York Red Bulls to hold annual Autism Acceptance match for families with autism

1:59
Fire destroys iconic restaurant DP’s Pub and Seafood Grill in Garfield

Fire destroys iconic restaurant DP’s Pub and Seafood Grill in Garfield

0:29
Officials: More than 70 lab mice at Seton Hall euthanized due to neglect

Officials: More than 70 lab mice at Seton Hall euthanized due to neglect