News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Weather
Crime
Politics
Toll of Commuting
56°
Local
Weather
Crime
Politics
Toll of Commuting

Disturbing discovery of headless birds sparks investigation in Putnam County

Putnam County authorities looking for who's responsible for latest round of mutilated birds for new reservoir.

Ben Nandy

•

May 25, 2026, 1:45 PM

•

Updated

Share:

More Stories

The Putnam County SPCA is investigating yet another case of decapitated animals that might have been sacrificed.

The birds — two roosters and two doves — were found Sunday evening by the Sodom Reservoir off Milltown Road in Brewster.

Their heads were cut off and their blood was drained from their bodies.

Officials with the SPCA said Monday the bird mutilation might have been part of a ritual.

SPCA investigators said it seems the doves and roosters were killed and beheaded somewhere else before being placed by the water.

People who live and hike in the scenic area are appalled and curious.

"It weirded me out because around here, you don't have livestock," said Jessica Binns, of North Salem. "I didn't know if something had just died and someone just dumped it, but to hear there was mutilation involved is definitely disturbing."

Putnam County SPCA Law Enforcement Chief Ken Ross told News 12 his team dealt with four similar incidents last year and another last month: animals decapitated, blood drained and placed by a body of water.

In one case last year, he said a goat's head was found in a bag along with some coconuts and literature about animal sacrifice.

Past incidents are informing how Ross approaches this most recent one.

"We just don't have enough to point the finger and say that's exactly what this is," Ross said, "but appearances are that it was a ritualistic killing."

Ross said that since the animals are likely only left by the reservoir, not killed there, there is no crime scene.

He said that makes cases like this one difficult. He adds that he hopes someone who knows about the mutilations or someone with expertise in sacrifice rituals can help his team solve these cases.

Anyone with information that might be helpful to the investigations of any of the mutilation incidents is asked to call the Putnam County SPCA at 845-520-6915.

Top Stories

01:57
TownCrierCompetition

Fair Lawn brings centuries old tradition back with first-ever Junior Town crier competition

01:36
F Gust GRAF 4k

Chilly, breezy Monday ushers back in a fall feel across New Jersey

01:37
RTNJRailingCollapseBergenCatholicCQueally10pm_2026-10-04-22-21-58

4 students injured following railing collapse at Bergen Catholic High School

00:21
UpperFreeholdPedestriansHit_2026-10-04-22-05-34

Child killed, woman seriously injured in Upper Freehold Township crash

01:52
NOREASTER STORM FOLO RAW TN

Jersey Shore businesses still dealing with storm damage a week after powerful nor'easter

00:21
FlorenceTwpScam_2026-10-04-17-08-36

Florence Township police warn of bank fraud scam

00:14
PEDESTRIAN KILLED mon copy

50-year-old woman dies after being struck by vehicle in Paterson

02:06
RTNJMontgomeryTwpHomicideProbeCQueally10pm_2026-10-03-22-15-27

2 women found fatally shot, man with apparent self-inflicted gunshot wound found dead in Montgomery Township home

00:15
news12

14-year-old boy dies after apparent skateboard fall in Pequannock, police say

New Jersey State House 2017

NJ group home camera bill draws renewed push ahead of State House rally

Vintage Radithor Apothecary Bottle

Historic East Orange company once sold radioactive water as medicine

00:17
ASSAULT INVESTIGATION POLICE LIGHTS

Rutgers police investigate early morning assault in New Brunswick; 1 injured

00:19
Newark Home Invasion Suspects Raw TN

Man arrested, 3 others sought in Newark home invasion involving fake FBI agents

00:18
FranklinTwpArsonArrest - 10PM_2026-10-04-06-59-49

Man charged with arson after Franklin Township apartment fire displaces 15, kills 2 pets

00:17
VinelandGFConviction - 9AM_2026-10-04-09-07-27

Vineland woman convicted of murder for intentionally running over girlfriend in Millville

00:18
Handcuffs

19-year-old charged with vehicular homicide in deadly Cape May County crash

00:14
trenton shooting

Police: 4 people injured in overnight Trenton shooting

00:43
APCornellRapeCaseSat10032026SG001

Cornell president calls alleged gang rape ‘deeply disturbing,’ pledges greater transparency

00:41
Andover Flight TN Raw

Lawmakers push back against planned evictions at Sussex County airport

02:00
REAsbury Zombies Walk_2026-10-03-17-28-28

Asbury Park Zombie Walk kicks off spooky season at the Jersey Shore

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices