West Orange mayor: Bagels by Jarrett owner ‘riled up an entire community’ after citation for covered windows

Mayor Susan McCartney says the town tried to work with restaurant owner Jarrett Seltzer and come up with a compromise but when that didn't work, a citation was issued for the covered windows.

Jim Murdoch and Lanette Espy

Aug 24, 2023, 11:56 AM

Updated 304 days ago

Share:

A battle between West Orange and a takeout restaurant owner over shaded windows has garnered a reaction from the mayor of the township, who's accusing the owner of going back on a deal.
Mayor Susan McCartney says the town tried to work with restaurant owner Jarrett Seltzer and come up with a compromise but when that didn't work, a citation was issued for the covered windows in July.
Jarrett Seltzer opened his Bagels by Jarrett store weeks before the COVID-19 lockdown in 2020, and refocused his store to curbside takeout only. According to a township ordinance, signage must not cover more than a third of the window and windows cannot be opaque. Two court dates later, and still no agreement was reached.
Mayor Susan McCartney told News 12 New Jersey the town and Seltzer had an agreement that the blinds would be closed only when the sun is glaring through the windows and decided four of the windows and the doors could stay covered - an exception to the code. Instead, she says Seltzer made no changes.
"He has riled up an entire community in really an outstanding way, basically blaming the town, and our position is he didn't comply with the town ordinance,” McCartney said.
News 12 asked McCartney if there’s any chance of a compromise that can be worked out before the next court date. She said it's not likely.
Seltzer says he is prepared to take this to trial. The next court date is scheduled for Oct. 17.


More from News 12
1:35
Officials: Dozens displaced, firefighter hurt in overnight Passaic fire

Officials: Dozens displaced, firefighter hurt in overnight Passaic fire

1:20
Cooler, breezy conditions and mostly sunny skies in New Jersey

Cooler, breezy conditions and mostly sunny skies in New Jersey

2:24
Middletown residents deal with damages, power outages from severe storms

Middletown residents deal with damages, power outages from severe storms

0:45
Police: Woman resists disorderly conduct arrest at Wildwood Crest motel, bites officer’s hand

Police: Woman resists disorderly conduct arrest at Wildwood Crest motel, bites officer’s hand

0:31
Prosecutor: Newark man sentenced to 22 years in prison for fatally stabbing roommate at homeless shelter

Prosecutor: Newark man sentenced to 22 years in prison for fatally stabbing roommate at homeless shelter

0:18
Police: 4 people shot in Trenton, 2 in critical condition

Police: 4 people shot in Trenton, 2 in critical condition

1:45
Sunday storms cap wild weather week across New Jersey

Sunday storms cap wild weather week across New Jersey

2:17
Township of Verona proposes creation of public safety complex

Township of Verona proposes creation of public safety complex

1:52
‘A welcome relief.’ Trenton opens swimming pools day early amid intense heat

‘A welcome relief.’ Trenton opens swimming pools day early amid intense heat

0:35
Manchester police: Howell Township man drowns in Crystal Lake

Manchester police: Howell Township man drowns in Crystal Lake

1:27
Summer storm brings damaging hail and winds to North Jersey

Summer storm brings damaging hail and winds to North Jersey

2:06
Study: Walking regularly can help alleviate recurring back pain

Study: Walking regularly can help alleviate recurring back pain

2:13
Doctors say exercising outside in hot weather can be dangerous

Doctors say exercising outside in hot weather can be dangerous

1:06
Beachgoers find solace from the sun at the Jersey Shore

Beachgoers find solace from the sun at the Jersey Shore

1:57
Newark native and rapper ‘Rah Digga’ discusses her music program ahead of North to Shore Festival

Newark native and rapper ‘Rah Digga’ discusses her music program ahead of North to Shore Festival

1:55
‘Paterson is Picking Up’ initiative aims to keep streets litter free

‘Paterson is Picking Up’ initiative aims to keep streets litter free

0:31
Authorities: 2 marked police cars crash while responding to Atlantic City robbery

Authorities: 2 marked police cars crash while responding to Atlantic City robbery

0:17
Police: Suspect wanted for armed robbery of Middletown jewelry store

Police: Suspect wanted for armed robbery of Middletown jewelry store

3:04
State lawmakers call on Gov. Murphy, President Biden to address Amtrak, NJ Transit issues

State lawmakers call on Gov. Murphy, President Biden to address Amtrak, NJ Transit issues

1:49
New Jersey residents enjoy outdoor dining on first summer Friday of the season

New Jersey residents enjoy outdoor dining on first summer Friday of the season