HEAT ALERT

Excessive heat watch issued for New Jersey with sizzling temps in the 90s this week

Preston Taylor sentenced to 18 years for role in Sarah Stern's murder

A Monmouth County man will serve at least 13 years in prison for his admitted role in the murder of a former high school classmate.

News 12 Staff

Jun 28, 2019, 11:57 AM

Updated 1,817 days ago

Share:

A Monmouth County man will serve at least 13 years in prison for his admitted role in the murder of a former high school classmate.
Preston Taylor was sentenced to 18 years in prison Friday after he admitted to helping his friend and roommate Liam McAtasney dispose of the body of Sarah Stern – their friend since childhood.
Taylor pleaded guilty to his role in the crime as part of a plea deal and testified for the prosecution in McAtasney’s trial. Taylor admitted to helping McAtasney throw Stern’s body off the Route 35 Bridge in Belmar after McAtasney killed Stern in order to steal money she recently found. The two men left Stern’s car on the bridge to stage her disappearance to look like a suicide.
McAtasney was convicted of the murder and sentenced to life in prison without parole.
Taylor spoke at his sentencing hearing and apologized to the Stern’s family.
“I should have known better and done something to stop this. I wish I had. I’m sorry,” he said.
But Stern’s father, Michael Stern, did not wish to hear Taylor’s words and walked out of the courtroom.
“I don’t want to hear anything from him. He had the opportunity – he had many opportunities…to stop it. He had the opportunity not to participate. There's nothing good there. It's evil, just evil,” said Michael Stern.
Taylor was to receive no more than 20 years in prison as part of the deal to testify against McAtasney. He received 18 with the possibility of parole in 13 years.
Michael Stern said that he wished the sentenced was longer.
“That’s part of the justice system, tough to deal with. It doesn’t bring Sarah back,” he said.
Michael Stern says that he is now focusing on setting up a scholarship in his daughter’s name to keep her memory alive.


More from News 12
2:32
HEAT ALERT: Heat advisory in effect for New Jersey with extreme highs expected all week

HEAT ALERT: Heat advisory in effect for New Jersey with extreme highs expected all week

2:32
Historic Glimmer Glass Bridge closed between Brielle and Manasquan until July 1 for safety repairs

Historic Glimmer Glass Bridge closed between Brielle and Manasquan until July 1 for safety repairs

2:46
‘People have worked so hard.’ Woman who helped make Juneteenth a national holiday visits New Jersey

‘People have worked so hard.’ Woman who helped make Juneteenth a national holiday visits New Jersey

2:10
NJ Transit: Service into and out of NY Penn Station on schedule following disruptions

NJ Transit: Service into and out of NY Penn Station on schedule following disruptions

0:31
Dollar Tree left lead-tainted applesauce pouches on store shelves for weeks after recall, FDA says

Dollar Tree left lead-tainted applesauce pouches on store shelves for weeks after recall, FDA says

2:06
Doctors highlight the importance of using sunscreen, particularly for people of color

Doctors highlight the importance of using sunscreen, particularly for people of color

0:53
‘He’s a coward.’ Norcross calls out Platkin for filing racketeering indictment against him

‘He’s a coward.’ Norcross calls out Platkin for filing racketeering indictment against him

1:27
Jersey Shore towns open cooling centers to help residents deal with extreme heat

Jersey Shore towns open cooling centers to help residents deal with extreme heat

0:52
Jersey Proud: 4 men bike 217 miles from NY to Cape May to raise money for childhood cancer

Jersey Proud: 4 men bike 217 miles from NY to Cape May to raise money for childhood cancer

0:26
Police: Bloomfield man shot at vehicle in Montclair road rage incident

Police: Bloomfield man shot at vehicle in Montclair road rage incident

2:17
NJ Hall of Fame Entertainment & Learning Center to open this month at American Dream

NJ Hall of Fame Entertainment & Learning Center to open this month at American Dream

0:27
New Jersey AG investigates death during police encounter at Route 9 gas station in Woodbridge

New Jersey AG investigates death during police encounter at Route 9 gas station in Woodbridge

0:26
Officials: Wildfire in Berkeley Township temporarily closes portion of the Garden State Parkway

Officials: Wildfire in Berkeley Township temporarily closes portion of the Garden State Parkway

Prosecutors try to link alleged bribes of Sen. Bob Menendez to appointment of federal prosecutor

Prosecutors try to link alleged bribes of Sen. Bob Menendez to appointment of federal prosecutor

1:42
Animal experts urge pet owners to keep an eye on their animals during extreme heat

Animal experts urge pet owners to keep an eye on their animals during extreme heat

1:23
Doctors warn people with diabetes to be extra cautious during periods of extreme heat

Doctors warn people with diabetes to be extra cautious during periods of extreme heat

1:27
Police chase from Roxbury to Parsippany ends in fiery car crash; 3 burglary suspects hospitalized

Police chase from Roxbury to Parsippany ends in fiery car crash; 3 burglary suspects hospitalized

0:33
Some NJ schools announce early dismissals as state braces for heat wave

Some NJ schools announce early dismissals as state braces for heat wave

1:32
Landscaping care, tips for your lawn during extreme heat

Landscaping care, tips for your lawn during extreme heat

0:30
Newark police: Delivery driver assaulted, robbed last month; suspects sought

Newark police: Delivery driver assaulted, robbed last month; suspects sought