NJ officials voice strong opposition to New York’s congestion pricing plan

Democratic Congressmen Josh Gottheimer calls the congestion pricing plan “an anti-environment proposal.”

Matt Trapani

May 9, 2023, 5:12 PM

Updated 365 days ago

Share:

New Jersey is preparing to fight back against New York City’s congestion pricing plan.
State and federal officials are weighing options after the federal government gave the green light for the initiative this weekend. Gov. Phil Murphy says all options are still on the table – from lawsuits to procedural roadblocks through the Port Authority.
And the move also has New Jersey officials rethinking just how much they want to pay up for transportation projects that cross the Hudson River.
“I’m sure I won’t make a lot of friends from New York after you broadcast this, but that’s not my purpose. My purpose is to be honest,” says New Jersey Transportation Commissioner Diane Gutierrez-Scaccetti.
The commissioner says that New Jersey could scale back the money it sends to joint transportation projects with New York. She says that this is one of the options the governor is mulling over as to how to respond to looming congestion pricing.
Democratic Reps. Rob Menendez, Jr. and Josh Gottheimer met outside the Holland Tunnel on Tuesday to also address the issue. They said that they are looking to cut $2 billion worth of funding to the MTA and want to provide tax credits to offset a possible $23 toll increase for commuters.
“Put alone all the other arguments about sticking it to Jersey families with an extra $5,000 per year tax. Put all that aside, we’re just looking at the environmental impacts of that,” Gottheimer says.
Gottheimer says congestion pricing will actually make the air outside Manhattan less clean.
"There will be increases in traffic, pollutants and mobile air toxins through 2045 in the Bronx, Staten Island, Nassau County and Bergen County," Gottheimer says.
But Danny Pearlstein, with the Riders Alliance, a non-profit representing New York City bus and subway riders, disagrees with Gottheimer’s assessment.
“Jersey drivers deserve much more than lies from pandering politicians,” he says. “I don’t believe there’s a congressman in Bergen County who cares what my kids breathe. I’m not buying that for a minute.”
The Riders Alliance disputes that congestion pricing will lead to dirtier air on our side of the Hudson.
Even though the feds have weighed in, it still will take at least a year for New York to implement its new plan.


More from News 12
2:16
Security upgrades at Newark Liberty International Airport are underway. What travelers need to know.

Security upgrades at Newark Liberty International Airport are underway. What travelers need to know.

2:11
Dry, cloudy morning for New Jersey; rain showers tonight into Friday

Dry, cloudy morning for New Jersey; rain showers tonight into Friday

2:29
New Sea Girt ordinance bans digging large holes at beach for safety reasons

New Sea Girt ordinance bans digging large holes at beach for safety reasons

0:44
Dover councilman called to step down following harassment allegations

Dover councilman called to step down following harassment allegations

0:34
Meeting alpacas and more at Ocean Township animal park

Meeting alpacas and more at Ocean Township animal park

0:40
Knicks defeat Pacers for 2-0 lead in East semifinals

Knicks defeat Pacers for 2-0 lead in East semifinals

2:40
KIYC: Is New Jersey’s treatment of rape victims violating their human rights?

KIYC: Is New Jersey’s treatment of rape victims violating their human rights?

How to report anti-Asian hate crimes in the tri-state

How to report anti-Asian hate crimes in the tri-state

1:13
The East End: Sag Harbor Honey

The East End: Sag Harbor Honey

2:54
4 Keyport businesses indefinitely shut down after construction incident condemns building

4 Keyport businesses indefinitely shut down after construction incident condemns building

1:52
Prosecutor: Mount Olive day care teacher accused of assaulting 16-month-old girl

Prosecutor: Mount Olive day care teacher accused of assaulting 16-month-old girl

2:46
Educators gather at FDU for program to learn how to teach Asian American and Pacific Islander history

Educators gather at FDU for program to learn how to teach Asian American and Pacific Islander history

0:23
Police issue safety warning after black bear spotted in Hawthorne neighborhood

Police issue safety warning after black bear spotted in Hawthorne neighborhood

0:36
Jersey Proud: Red Cross volunteers make sure Mount Holly residents have smoke detectors

Jersey Proud: Red Cross volunteers make sure Mount Holly residents have smoke detectors

0:29
Police: Multiple fights inside East Brunswick High School lead to lockdown, shelter-in-place

Police: Multiple fights inside East Brunswick High School lead to lockdown, shelter-in-place

0:20
Police: 2 men assault, rob victim walking alone in Montclair

Police: 2 men assault, rob victim walking alone in Montclair

2:14
State monitor assigned to Nutley Public School District to assist with finances

State monitor assigned to Nutley Public School District to assist with finances

1:34
ExxonMobil's Research and Engineering closing Clinton Township facility, relocating to Houston

ExxonMobil's Research and Engineering closing Clinton Township facility, relocating to Houston

0:17
Authorities: Man dies following Sunday shooting in Paterson

Authorities: Man dies following Sunday shooting in Paterson

0:27
Clayton police: Man, woman found dead inside apartment in reported murder-suicide

Clayton police: Man, woman found dead inside apartment in reported murder-suicide