Man on trial for killing of classmate driven to tears during testimony

A man on trial for the murder of a former high school classmate and childhood friend appeared to be driven to tears during testimony.

News 12 Staff

Jan 24, 2019, 10:21 PM

Updated 1,947 days ago

Share:

A man on trial for the murder of a former high school classmate and childhood friend appeared to be driven to tears during testimony.
Liam McAtasney is on trial for allegedly strangling Sarah Stern, his former high school classmate, in order to steal money she had inherited.
McAtasney’s former coworker, a waitress at Brennan's Steakhouse in Neptune City, testified that McAtasney left work for a time on the night that Stern was last seen in December 2016. The defendant appeared to be wiping away tears during the testimony.
Jurors also continued to hear testimony from Preston Taylor, one of the prosecutor’s star witnesses. Taylor admitted to helping McAtasney dispose of Stern’s body after she was killed. Taylor pleaded guilty as part of an agreement to testify at the trial.
McAtasney’s defense attorney Carlos Diaz-Cobo spent less than an hour cross-examining Taylor, and attempted to paint a picture of Taylor as a liar and someone that jurors should not believe.
"And you testified yesterday that the cooperation agreement [with prosecutors] called for truthfulness right? But you don't always tell the truth?” Cobo asked.
“I haven’t in the past,” Taylor replied.
But on redirect, Assistant Monmouth Prosecutor Chris Decker made it clear that Taylor knew that if he lied on the stand, his plea agreement would be null and he could face 30 years to life in prison.
Jurors also heard testimony about how Taylor and McAtasney bought walkie-talkies, allegedly used to communicate plans to kill Stern without leaving evidence on a cellphone.
Family and friends of Stern testified that, although her relationship with her father may have been strained at times, and she said she wanted to move to Canada, she made no indications she wanted to kill herself.
Jurors are expected to soon hear from another prosecutorial witness – another classmate of McAtasney who secretly recorded McAtasney allegedly confessing to the murder and the cover-up.


More from News 12
1:11
Thousands participate in 46th annual Spring Lake 5-mile run

Thousands participate in 46th annual Spring Lake 5-mile run

2:45
Warm temperatures with mostly sunny skies in New Jersey

Warm temperatures with mostly sunny skies in New Jersey

1:34
'This is unbelievable traffic.’ Memorial Day travelers share road trip blues

'This is unbelievable traffic.’ Memorial Day travelers share road trip blues

0:18
Prosecutor: Man accused of killing man in Roselle park turns himself in

Prosecutor: Man accused of killing man in Roselle park turns himself in

Guide: 2024 Memorial Day Parades in New Jersey

Guide: 2024 Memorial Day Parades in New Jersey

2:50
Police: 1 person injured in explosion at Sayreville power station; hundreds without power

Police: 1 person injured in explosion at Sayreville power station; hundreds without power

0:24
Newark man convicted of robbing poker player in Atlantic City

Newark man convicted of robbing poker player in Atlantic City

1:34
Fire at commercial building in Secaucus sends plumes of smoke into the air

Fire at commercial building in Secaucus sends plumes of smoke into the air

0:51
Jersey Proud: Ashley Lauren Foundation helps provide pool to boy with brain cancer

Jersey Proud: Ashley Lauren Foundation helps provide pool to boy with brain cancer

0:44
Gov. Murphy announces $100M Boardwalk Preservation Fund for the Jersey Shore

Gov. Murphy announces $100M Boardwalk Preservation Fund for the Jersey Shore

2:10
Jersey Shore business owners hope for successful Memorial Day, despite Route 71 bridge repairs

Jersey Shore business owners hope for successful Memorial Day, despite Route 71 bridge repairs

2:07
‘It was like a nightmare. Very scary.’ Thursday’s severe storm creates chaos for West Milford residents

‘It was like a nightmare. Very scary.’ Thursday’s severe storm creates chaos for West Milford residents

6:13
EXCLUSIVE: Donald Trump one-on-one interview with News 12

EXCLUSIVE: Donald Trump one-on-one interview with News 12

1:01
2.9 magnitude aftershock hits Tewksbury, USGS says; 177th aftershock since April earthquake

2.9 magnitude aftershock hits Tewksbury, USGS says; 177th aftershock since April earthquake

Water main break forces Middlesex Borough schools to close Friday

Water main break forces Middlesex Borough schools to close Friday

1:05
Trump floats possible VP picks in News 12 interview

Trump floats possible VP picks in News 12 interview

2:10
2024 Atlantic hurricane season expected to be above-normal, NOAA predicts

2024 Atlantic hurricane season expected to be above-normal, NOAA predicts

0:35
Police: New Brunswick councilwoman charged with reckless, intoxicated driving

Police: New Brunswick councilwoman charged with reckless, intoxicated driving

0:39
Federal Election Commission: Sen. Menendez's campaign spends over $2 million on legal fees

Federal Election Commission: Sen. Menendez's campaign spends over $2 million on legal fees

0:19
Sunken tombstone of veteran rescued in Nutley

Sunken tombstone of veteran rescued in Nutley