Judge rejects Chauvin’s request for new trial in Floyd death

Judge Peter Cahill denied the request Friday, saying defense attorney Eric Nelson has not shown that abused its discretion and denied Chauvin the right to a fair trial.

News 12 Staff

Jun 25, 2021, 3:33 PM

Updated 1,026 days ago

Share:

Judge rejects Chauvin’s request for new trial in Floyd death
A judge has rejected former Minneapolis police Officer Derek Chauvin’s request for a new trial in George Floyd’s death.
Judge Peter Cahill denied the request Friday, saying defense attorney Eric Nelson has not shown that abused its discretion and denied Chauvin the right to a fair trial.
Chauvin, 45, pinned Floyd to a Minneapolis street for about 9 1/2 minutes on May 25, 2020, ignoring the Black man’s cries of “I can’t breathe” and the shouts of onlookers. Bystander video of Floyd’s death sparked protests in Minneapolis, some violent, and quickly spread around the world.
THe former officer is set to be sentenced Friday.
Chauvin faces decades in prison, with several legal experts predicting a sentence of 20 to 25 years. He also still faces trial on federal civil rights charges, along with three other fired officers who have yet to have their state trials.
The concrete barricades, razor wire and National Guard patrols that shrouded the county courthouse for Chauvin's three-week trial are gone, and so is most of the tension in the city as it awaited a verdict in April. Still, there's a recognition that Chauvin's sentencing will be another major step forward for a city that has been on edge since Floyd's death on May 25, 2020.
“Between the incident, the video, the riots, the trial - this is the pinnacle of it,” Mike Brandt, a local defense attorney who has closely followed Chauvin's case, said. “The verdict was huge too, but this is where the justice comes down.”
Chauvin was convicted of second-degree unintentional murder, third-degree murder and second-degree manslaughter for pressing his knee against Floyd’s neck for about 9 1/2 minutes as the Black man said he couldn’t breathe and went limp. Bystander video of Floyd's arrest for suspicion of passing a counterfeit $20 bill prompted protests around the world and a nationwide reckoning on race and police brutality.
Under Minnesota statutes, Chauvin will be sentenced only on the most serious charge, which has a maximum sentence of 40 years. But case law dictates that a 30-year sentence would be the practical maximum sentence Judge Peter Cahill could impose without risk of being overturned on appeal.
Prosecutors asked for 30 years, saying Chauvin’s actions were egregious and “shocked the nation’s conscience.” Defense attorney Eric Nelson requested probation, saying Chauvin was the product of a “broken” system and “believed he was doing his job.”
Cahill has already found that aggravating factors in Floyd’s death warrant going higher than the 12 1/2-year sentence recommended by the state's sentencing guidelines. The judge found Chauvin abused his position of authority, treated Floyd with particular cruelty, and that the crime was seen by several children. He also wrote that Chauvin knew the restraint of Floyd was dangerous.
“The prolonged use of this technique was particularly egregious in that George Floyd made it clear he was unable to breathe and expressed the view that he was dying as a result of the officers’ restraint,” Cahill wrote last month.
Attorneys on both sides are expected to make brief arguments Friday. Floyd's family members - including his brother Philonise, his brother Terrence and his nephew Brandon Williams - will give statements in court.
Ben Crump, an attorney who has represented Floyd’s family, said family members were feeling “anxious and tense” ahead of the sentencing.
“To us, George Floyd is a cause. He’s a case; he’s a hashtag. To them -- that’s their flesh and blood. You know, that that’s their brother,” Crump said.
Chauvin can also make a statement, but it’s not clear if he will. Experts say it could be tricky for Chauvin to talk without implicating himself in the pending federal case accusing him of violating Floyd’s civil rights.
Chauvin chose not to testify at his trial. The only explanation the public has heard from him came from body-camera footage in which he told a bystander at the scene: “We got to control this guy ’cause he’s a sizable guy ... and it looks like he’s probably on something.”
Several experts said they doubted Chauvin would take the risk and speak, but Brandt thought he would. He said Chauvin could say a few words without getting himself into legal trouble.
“I think it's his chance to tell the world, 'I didn't intend to kill him,'” Brandt said. "If I was him, I think I would want to try and let people know that I’m not a monster.”
Several people interviewed in Minneapolis days before Chauvin's sentencing said they want to see a tough sentence.
Thirty years “doesn't seem like long enough to me,” said Andrew Harer, a retail worker who is white. “I would be fine if he was in jail for the rest of his life.”
Joseph Allen, 31, who is Black, said he thinks Chauvin should receive “at least” 30 years, and said he'd prefer a life sentence. He cited nearly 20 complaints filed against the now-fired officer during his career.
Allen said he hopes other police officers can learn “not to do what Derek Chauvin did.”
Nekima Levy Armstrong, a civil rights attorney and activist, called for Chauvin to be sentenced “to the fullest extent of the law." She called Floyd's death “a modern day lynching” and predicted community outrage if Chauvin is sentenced lightly.
When asked if she would like to hear Chauvin speak, Levy Armstrong said: “For me as a Black woman living in this community, there’s really nothing that he could say that would alleviate the pain and trauma that he caused ... I think that if he spoke it would be disingenuous and could cause more trauma."
Crump also said he wanted to see a sentence above what is typically given for a second-degree murder conviction.
“There was nothing typical about what Derek Chauvin did in torturing George Floyd to death,” Crump said. “So we don’t expect it to be a typical sentence. It needs to be a sentence that sets a new precedent for holding police officers accountable for the unjustifiable killings of Black people in America.”
No matter what sentence Chauvin gets, he's likely to serve only about two-thirds behind bars presuming good behavior. The rest would be on supervised release.
He's been held since his conviction at the state's only maximum security prison, in Oak Park Heights. The former officer is held away from the general population for his safety, in a 10-by-10-foot cell, with meals brought to his room. He is allowed out for solitary exercise for an hour a day.
It's not clear if Chauvin will remain there. State prisons officials said that decision wouldn't be made until after Cahill's formal sentencing order.
Chauvin and the three other officers involved in Floyd’s arrest are awaiting trial in federal court on charges of violating Floyd’s civil rights. No trial date has been set.
The three other officers are also scheduled for trial in March on state charges of aiding and abetting both murder and manslaughter.
(Written by Associated Press writers Amy Forlitti and Steve Karnowski. Associate Press writers Stephen Groves and Mohamed Ibrahim contributed to the report.)


More from News 12
2:36
Boonton passes ordinance on what flags are allowed to be flown outside town hall

Boonton passes ordinance on what flags are allowed to be flown outside town hall

1:44
Scattered showers expected this afternoon in New Jersey; weather trends cooler rest of the week

Scattered showers expected this afternoon in New Jersey; weather trends cooler rest of the week

0:34
New Jersey man accused of stealing nearly $10,000 worth of lottery tickets in Franklin Township

New Jersey man accused of stealing nearly $10,000 worth of lottery tickets in Franklin Township

0:24
Upper Saddle River police warn of fake law enforcement scam involving gift cards

Upper Saddle River police warn of fake law enforcement scam involving gift cards

0:53
New Jersey man charged with manslaughter one year after fatal Palisades Parkway crash

New Jersey man charged with manslaughter one year after fatal Palisades Parkway crash

0:25
Police: Manchester crash involving van carrying students sends 13 to hospital

Police: Manchester crash involving van carrying students sends 13 to hospital

0:39
Newark mayor responds to claims his team failed to report over $700,000 campaign funds

Newark mayor responds to claims his team failed to report over $700,000 campaign funds

0:21
Police: Man punched in face, stabbed in leg after getting off bus in Montclair

Police: Man punched in face, stabbed in leg after getting off bus in Montclair

2:34
Sorry New Jersey, you can’t have a Buc-ee’s and have your gas pumped too

Sorry New Jersey, you can’t have a Buc-ee’s and have your gas pumped too

Guide: Stay safe while traveling through work zones with these 6 tips

Guide: Stay safe while traveling through work zones with these 6 tips

2:48
Toll worker with ‘premonition’ called out of work before truck crashed into booth

Toll worker with ‘premonition’ called out of work before truck crashed into booth

0:21
Prosecutor: Montclair officer injured in shootout released from hospital, suspect charged

Prosecutor: Montclair officer injured in shootout released from hospital, suspect charged

Detective says daughter's boyfriend, disliked by Atlantic City mayor, recorded abuse in video call

Detective says daughter's boyfriend, disliked by Atlantic City mayor, recorded abuse in video call

0:27
Toms River police chief suspended for 2 days amid feud with town’s mayor

Toms River police chief suspended for 2 days amid feud with town’s mayor

0:53
Jersey Proud: Artwork featured in Newark Liberty’s Terminal A done by NJ artists

Jersey Proud: Artwork featured in Newark Liberty’s Terminal A done by NJ artists

0:44
Dozens of residents escape 4-alarm fire in Paterson that damaged 3 homes

Dozens of residents escape 4-alarm fire in Paterson that damaged 3 homes

0:21
FAA: Cessna 150 plane crashes at Sussex Airport in Wantage

FAA: Cessna 150 plane crashes at Sussex Airport in Wantage

Another record for New Jersey internet gambling revenue as in-person winnings struggle

Another record for New Jersey internet gambling revenue as in-person winnings struggle

2:02
Middletown mayor proposes reducing parking fees to offset NJ Transit fare hike

Middletown mayor proposes reducing parking fees to offset NJ Transit fare hike

1:48
Look up! Lyrid meteor shower returns to the tri-state area

Look up! Lyrid meteor shower returns to the tri-state area