News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Toll of Commuting
FIFA World Cup

'It's mind-boggling.' What potential charges in Rutgers hazing incident could look like

Anyone responsible for what happened could be looking at hefty charges, especially because of a fairly new law named after a different victim of hazing.

Christine Queally

Oct 24, 2025, 10:14 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

A national fraternity shut down its Rutgers University chapter for hazing on Friday after a student was sent to the hospital with critical injuries.

The student was injured on Oct. 15, allegedly inside the now-condemned Alpha Sigma Phi fraternity house.

Anyone responsible for what happened could be looking at hefty charges, especially because of a fairly new law named after a different victim of hazing.

"You send your kid off to college, and you never think that their so-called friend is going to hurt them, and then not call for help to take care of them. It's just - it's mind-boggling," said Evelyn Piazza, the mother of Timothy Piazza, who died from a hazing incident at Penn State University in 2017.

That's why Evelyn and her husband, Jim, of Spring Lake, New Jersey, have become advocates to stop hazing.

They help other families who are going through the same thing they did eight years ago.

RELATED: Alpha Sigma Phi at Rutgers closed down after learning student critically injured was hazed

RELATED: Rutgers student injured at fraternity house now in stable condition

"We kind of knew it was hazing. We had talked to the dad last week, actually, after it happened. It was pretty clear to me that it was a hazing incident. It's just people were trying to create a different narrative about it," said Jim Piazza, referencing the family of the victim in the Rutgers incident.

In 2024, the Piazzas got a law passed, named in memory of their son.

"The Timothy Piazza law is a felony hazing law, but it has different levels. There's aggravated hazing for instances of serious injury or death, which this would apply to," said Evelyn.

If those responsible are prosecuted for the Rutgers incident, the case would be the first time the Piazzas have seen their law used in practice.

Experts say these cases can be tricky, though, not impossible.

"It's very, very difficult to codify a behavior like this when you're dealing with an organization. The prosecutor's office is going to have - they'll most likely pick the prosecutable cases," New Jersey attorney John Fabriele said. "They'd have to be directly involved. You're talking about witnesses. They're going to interview people and get names. Whoever they can find enough evidence by witness testimony, that's who they'll prosecute."

The Middlesex County Prosecutor's Office declined to comment on this case because the investigation is active and ongoing.

More Stories

Top Stories

01:36
Image (3)

Auto shop fire in New Brunswick destroys building and and spreads to nearby home

02:00
REjimbeach5pm_2026-06-12-17-26-13

Asbury Park installs lightning detection system and sirens along its beaches

02:53
Screenshot 2026-06-12 152836

Storms have passed and it's smooth sailing into the weekend. Or is it?

00:37
REbridgewater_2026-06-12-17-33-10

Boil water advisory issued for part of Bridgewater after water main break

NYNJStadium

FIFA World Cup 2026: What you need to know ahead of the big event

01:50
REedisonchristine5pm_2026-06-12-17-29-43

Edison launches shuttle program for World Cup game days

AP26160195910157

Spielberg film spent $34M in New Jersey during production, state says

00:24
FIFA World Cup

Airbnb donation pushes New Jersey’s free World Cup ticket total past 1,000

00:19
Handcuffs

Keansburg woman charged for leaving baby, dog in vehicle, police say

01:50
Screenshot 2026-06-12 123551

Volunteers brave extreme heat in Asbury Park to clean up beaches and protect coastline

agency-140-wysiwyg-image-5xRfRAlf

Georgia man charged in Facebook Marketplace watch robbery in New Jersey

Sebastian Nino-Lopez Blur

Bergen County man charged after alleged attempted sexual assault of juvenile, prosecutors say

Justice Castro Blur

Philadelphia man pleads guilty to eluding police, drug distribution charges in Atlantic City

bear sighting

Ramsey police warn of 'possibly aggressive bear'

fraud charges

Former youth football and cheer treasurer charged with misusing organization funds in Lawrence Township

Homicide investigation generic

Egg Harbor Township man indicted in fatal 2025 head-on crash

00:24
manslaughter

Atlantic City teenager pleads guilty in fatal 2024 shooting

assault arrest

Daughter of reality star arrested: Milania Giudice charged with assault in Montville

02:49
PawsAndPals0612NJTA_2026-06-12-09-16-23

Paws and Pals: Percy is prepared to be your ‘furver’ friend

00:24
ATVSuspect0612NJTA_2026-06-12-09-00-23

Police arrest man who ‘drove over’ Ewing police officer

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices