Toll of Commuting
News12 New York
Where to Watch
Download the App
Local
Crime
Weather
beWell
The East End
Crime Files
FIFA World Cup

Family of man killed by Elizabeth police officer holds rally outside headquarters

Estiben Alegria-Hurtado, 42, was shot and killed by police during a disturbance at an Amity Street home.

Matt Trapani

and

Eliecer Marte

Aug 3, 2023, 10:19 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

The family of an Elizabeth man shot and killed during a police encounter says that the officers did not have to kill their loved one.

Estiben Alegria-Hurtado, 42, died on July 30, one day after being shot. Authorities say that Elizabeth police were called to a home on Amity Street in Elizabeth for reports of a disturbance. It was during this call that Officer Steven Lazo shot and killed Alegria-Hurtado. They say that a knife was recovered at the scene.

Alegria-Hurtado’s family says that he had no intention of using that knife. They say that the police did not need to shoot Alegria-Hurtado because the family members had the situation under control.

Family members held a rally in front of Elizabeth Police Headquarters Thursday evening. The family says that Alegria-Hurtado got into an argument with his brother’s ex-girlfriend after showing up drunk at her home.

The family says that when Alegria-Hurtado got intoxicated, he would act erratically. They say that the argument between the woman and Alegria-Hurtado escalated. She grabbed a bat, and he had a knife, which one of the brothers says he never used because two cousins were allegedly holding him and calming both down. 

The family says they don’t know the reason behind the argument or who called the police. Based on a preliminary investigation it was around 8 a.m. when officers arrived and encountered Alegria-Hurtado. The family wonders why a Taser was not used instead.

Alegria-Hurtado was rushed to University Hospital but died a day later. News 12 has learned he was a father of two teenagers that live in Colombia. He had just moved to the United States last year. His family says his dream was to bring his children to live with him in New Jersey. 

A vigil for Alegria-Hurtado will be held on Saturday. The New Jersey Office of the Attorney General is investigating the case.

More Stories

Top Stories

01:33
CRIME SCENE TN

Freehold library shooting investigation continues after victim shot inside building

02:09
RizzoSM2

A pleasant weekend is expected with more clouds on Saturday than Sunday.

01:42
GAS STATION GENERIC

NJ gas prices hit four-year high as global conflict and seasonal demand surge

Commuters

Daily drive from Union to Newark named one of nation’s top burnout commutes

00:21
Taco Bell lawsuit

Woman sues Passaic Taco Bell after breaking teeth on metal screw inside burrito

00:23
Forrod Bonsu Blur

Hackensack police officer falsified Marine Corps records to get paid leave, prosecutor says

airport travel

Trenton‑Mercer Airport ranks first in U.S. for easiest walk to your gate

02:08
FreeholdShooting1

Man shot on East Main Street in Freehold Borough, authorities say

01:51
Screenshot 2026-05-01 053316

Middletown school closures put on hold as district works to finalize long‑term plan

00:27
keyport

State to test water near former Keyport Sanitary Landfill amid cancer concerns

01:45
Screenshot 2026-04-30 071955

"Old school and I like it." Fans camp out for Foo Fighters pop‑up show at Starland Ballroom

02:58
PawsAndPals0501NJTA_2026-05-01-08-48-23

Paws and Pals: Gentle Willow needs a 'furever' home

00:28
School Aid chardged

School bus aide charged with sexually assaulting teens with autism in Roselle

02:05
512026NJautomimmune_2026-05-01-07-26-50

Breakthrough cancer treatment studied as possible one‑time therapy for autoimmune disease

00:27
Former Mayoral candidate charged

Former Plainfield mayoral candidate pleads guilty to voter registration forgery

00:28
RoadRageNJTA_2026-05-01-06-22-08

NJ man arrested for attempted murder in Illinois road rage crash

ICE THEATRE OF NEW YORK

Ice Theatre of New York announces spring benefit performances; Olympians to participate

AP26121033021158

Knicks crush Hawks in record-setting 140-89 Game 6 rout to end Atlanta’s season

01:54
X FullMoon Calendar

May kicks off with a full moon and a meteor shower

01:56
Screenshot 2026-04-30 221418

Hundreds flock to NJ Film Expo as state incentives draw major productions

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices