News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Toll of Commuting
FIFA World Cup

Disturbing discovery of headless birds sparks investigation in Putnam County

Putnam County authorities looking for who's responsible for latest round of mutilated birds for new reservoir.

Ben Nandy

May 25, 2026, 1:45 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

The Putnam County SPCA is investigating yet another case of decapitated animals that might have been sacrificed.

The birds — two roosters and two doves — were found Sunday evening by the Sodom Reservoir off Milltown Road in Brewster.

Their heads were cut off and their blood was drained from their bodies.

Officials with the SPCA said Monday the bird mutilation might have been part of a ritual.

SPCA investigators said it seems the doves and roosters were killed and beheaded somewhere else before being placed by the water.

People who live and hike in the scenic area are appalled and curious.

"It weirded me out because around here, you don't have livestock," said Jessica Binns, of North Salem. "I didn't know if something had just died and someone just dumped it, but to hear there was mutilation involved is definitely disturbing."

Putnam County SPCA Law Enforcement Chief Ken Ross told News 12 his team dealt with four similar incidents last year and another last month: animals decapitated, blood drained and placed by a body of water.

In one case last year, he said a goat's head was found in a bag along with some coconuts and literature about animal sacrifice.

Past incidents are informing how Ross approaches this most recent one.

"We just don't have enough to point the finger and say that's exactly what this is," Ross said, "but appearances are that it was a ritualistic killing."

Ross said that since the animals are likely only left by the reservoir, not killed there, there is no crime scene.

He said that makes cases like this one difficult. He adds that he hopes someone who knows about the mutilations or someone with expertise in sacrifice rituals can help his team solve these cases.

Anyone with information that might be helpful to the investigations of any of the mutilation incidents is asked to call the Putnam County SPCA at 845-520-6915.

More Stories

Top Stories

02:09
NJ Sat 07182026 Radar 630pm

STORM WATCH: Flash flood warning issued in NJ as severe storm brings heavy rain and wind

00:00
TriStateRadar07182026At308pm

LIVE RADAR: Track today's rain storms

00:16
718newarkfire_2026-07-18-06-07-41

More than 20 residents displaced as fire rips through Newark home

00:34
718atlanticityprosecutorsoffice_subclip_2026-07-18-09-28-05

Atlantic City man gets seven years in prison for setting apartment building fire

02:06
World Cup Book_2026-07-18-17-23-11

Hoboken man's World Cup 'passport book' tells story of global connection

00:45
recall alert

Taylor Farms recalls iceberg lettuce in New Jersey and Connecticut linked to Cyclospora bacteria

drug bust

Secaucus police bust alleged cocaine operation, seize loaded stolen handgun

00:45
HawaiiCoffeeShopOpeningVS_2026-07-18-14-52-18

Bad Ass Coffee of Hawaii opens first Jersey shore location in Wall Township

00:19
718eveshamsexassault_subclip_2026-07-18-06-08-52_06-03-29,16

Evesham man charged with sexual assault of young girl

02:03
REhealthriskwildfire5pm_2026-07-17-17-43-51

Health experts warn that wildfire smoke can lead to increased heart issues

developing copy

The all-new News 12 app is live. Here’s how to update

00:19
AP26198726106860

Federal appeals court rules that New Jersey's assault weapons ban is unconstitutional

00:21
REParamus Robbery_2026-07-17-17-47-33

Police: 2 accused of assaulting Dollar Tree manager who caught them shoplifting

02:23
REworldcupfansfinalexcitment_2026-07-17-22-22-03

World Cup fever builds in New Jersey as fans gather outside team hotels ahead of final

01:45
REchrisnewarkpoolclosure_2026-07-17-17-33-10

Public pools are being shutdown around New Jersey due to poor air quality

00:31
717wingstoparrest_2026-07-17-07-54-01

Suspected Wingstop food bandit tries to bite police after chase in Rochelle Park

Hoboken Drug Bust Mugshot

Two arrested on drug charges following neighborhood complaints in Hoboken

01:45
REpokemoncardrelease10pm_2026-07-17-22-23-55

Pokémon fans across New Jersey get hyped up for new card release

00:46
REjp7172026_2026-07-17-22-25-10

Jersey Proud: Stanley Cup makes victory tour stops across New Jersey

HandcuffsLights

Cranford traffic stop leads to stolen gun, drug arrests

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices