Developers are taking advantage of COVID-19 construction ban loopholes, a KIYC investigation finds

A Kane In Your Corner investigation finds New Jersey's ban on nonessential construction may be having a minimal impact because developers and construction companies are taking advantage of the ban's myriad of exemptions.

News 12 Staff

Apr 21, 2020, 1:07 AM

Updated 1,546 days ago

Share:

A Kane In Your Corner investigation finds New Jersey's ban on nonessential construction may be having a minimal impact because developers and construction companies are taking advantage of the ban's myriad of exemptions.
Journal Squared, the luxury high-rise complex being built in Jersey City, seems like no one's idea of essential construction. In fact, two weeks ago, some construction workers there told Kane In Your Corner they were afraid of contracting COVID-19 because of the crowded conditions, and they didn't think the project was worth the risk.
"We’re building a 70-story luxury high-rise," one construction worker said at the time. "I don’t see how that’s essential or why we’re exposed to this every day. Call me crazy."
Days later, Gov. Phil Murphy announced a ban on all nonessential construction. But on Monday, work at Journal Squared continues. The project is still classified as "essential." A union official tells Kane In your Corner that's because some units there are designated as affordable housing.
Another luxury project along the Jersey City waterfront is also deemed "essential.” Jersey City Councilman James Solomon says that's because part of the basement in one building will be used for a private school, triggering the exemption for education.
"I don't think anyone thinks a tiny little private school, 10,000 square feet, means that you get to build 30 stories," Solomon says. "I mean, that's absurd."
Kane In Your Corner found similar examples across New Jersey. At Newark Liberty International Airport, where workers previously complained about their safety, work continues on a new terminal; it is deemed essential because it involves transportation. An Amazon warehouse under construction in Franklin Township, Somerset County, is considered essential because it involves a mail-order retail business. A commercial site under construction in Clifton is essential because it will include a lab where people can go for blood work.
When a job is essential, workers who don't want to risk their health working on site can be left with few options.
"If we're asked to come to work, we have to come to work," says one union worker, currently assigned to a job site in Trenton. "If we choose not to, we're put down as a 'quit', which means we're ineligible for unemployment benefits."
The job site this worker is assigned to is, of all places, the New Jersey Department of Labor building.
Kane In Your Corner asked Murphy if he would consider removing some of the exemptions from the construction ban. "I don't think we're considering any more tweaks to this for the time being," the governor replied.
Michael Zhadanovsky, a Murphy spokesman, says "many major construction projects have suspended work as required by Executive Order #122, which only provides limited exemptions."
Pressed for examples, however, a Murphy administration spokesman cited three projects, two of which had actually closed prior to the governor's executive order being issued. The Harrison Urby project in Harrison was actually fully completed in 2018. The American Dream mega-mall in East Rutherford halted construction voluntarily in mid-March, nearly a month before the governor's order, although the order eliminated any chance the developer could opt to restart construction on its own.
Some unionized workers aren't convinced they can turn to leadership for support either. After Kane In Your Corner's initial investigation, IBEW Local 102 emailed its more than 2,000 members to urge them to refrain from contacting the governor's office and news media to complain about unsafe conditions and request jobs be shut down. Instead, the union said, "if you ask for a layoff, you will be helping another brother or sister who desperately needs employment."
"I was appalled," one electrician who received the letter says. "It makes them seem like they don't care about us as workers." Several union members describe the email as "threatening" and say it makes them less likely to request a layoff, fearing it would make them look bad in the union's eyes.
"That's what a lot of us feel," one member said, "that if you do take it, it's going to be held against you.".
IBEW Local 102 Business Manager Pat Delle Cava says he never intended to pressure workers to stay on a job site. If anything, he says, his email was intended to convey the opposite message. He calls the communication "sloppy."
Kane in Your Corner noticed one significant change on job sites they observed over the past two weeks. Construction workers observed recently were much more consistently wearing masks and gloves.


More from News 12
Prosecutor: Manchester murder investigation leads to discovery of 2nd victim; 4 facing charges

Prosecutor: Manchester murder investigation leads to discovery of 2nd victim; 4 facing charges

2:28
HEAT ALERT: Excessive heat warning extended through Wednesday as temps rise

HEAT ALERT: Excessive heat warning extended through Wednesday as temps rise

7:10
Trump picks Sen. JD Vance of Ohio, a once-fierce critic turned loyal ally, as his GOP running mate

Trump picks Sen. JD Vance of Ohio, a once-fierce critic turned loyal ally, as his GOP running mate

Authorities identify victims killed in weekend house fire in West Orange

Authorities identify victims killed in weekend house fire in West Orange

1:33
‘People need heat relief.’ Paterson opens cooling centers as temps rise around NJ

‘People need heat relief.’ Paterson opens cooling centers as temps rise around NJ

0:24
Spokesperson: Rep. Bill Pascrell checks into hospital for fever

Spokesperson: Rep. Bill Pascrell checks into hospital for fever

2:55
Jury finishes 2nd day of deliberations without a verdict at Sen. Bob Menendez's bribery trial

Jury finishes 2nd day of deliberations without a verdict at Sen. Bob Menendez's bribery trial

0:19
Jersey City police officers promoted during Monday ceremony

Jersey City police officers promoted during Monday ceremony

1:34
Vacant building fire in Plainfield causes roof collapse; investigation underway

Vacant building fire in Plainfield causes roof collapse; investigation underway

1:18
Going for gold: A look at some New Jersey athletes heading to the Paris Olympic Games

Going for gold: A look at some New Jersey athletes heading to the Paris Olympic Games

0:28
Mays Landing man pleads guilty to murdering his mother

Mays Landing man pleads guilty to murdering his mother

2:04
Route 15 temporary bridge in Jefferson opens earlier than expected

Route 15 temporary bridge in Jefferson opens earlier than expected

0:28
Woman jumps out of window in Franklin Township to avoid being struck by bullets

Woman jumps out of window in Franklin Township to avoid being struck by bullets

2:14
Don't be caught in the dark: Are you ready to power through hurricane season?

Don't be caught in the dark: Are you ready to power through hurricane season?

0:48
NJ Attorney General’s Office releases video of fatal South Brunswick motel standoff with NYC suspect

NJ Attorney General’s Office releases video of fatal South Brunswick motel standoff with NYC suspect

3:30
Trump heads to convention as authorities investigate motive, security in assassination attempt

Trump heads to convention as authorities investigate motive, security in assassination attempt

0:23
Newark official: 5 men stabbed in Ironbound neighborhood

Newark official: 5 men stabbed in Ironbound neighborhood

2:23
NJ American Water issues mandatory water restrictions for parts of Ocean, Monmouth counties

NJ American Water issues mandatory water restrictions for parts of Ocean, Monmouth counties

3:04
Made in New Jersey: For nearly 150 years, Serratelli Hat Company in Newark has served the hat industry

Made in New Jersey: For nearly 150 years, Serratelli Hat Company in Newark has served the hat industry

0:24
Fire officials: 2 people trapped inside car after hitting parked trucks at Cherry Hill rest stop

Fire officials: 2 people trapped inside car after hitting parked trucks at Cherry Hill rest stop