News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Toll of Commuting
FIFA World Cup

Body of man found east of Tiana Beach in Hampton Bays

Southampton Town police say they received the call at around 2:45 p.m. for a body located near the beach. The remains were recovered in a bay-side marsh east of the beach.

Jenna Rae Gaertner

and

Brendan O'Leary

and

Roberto Torres

May 31, 2026, 10:10 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

A man's body was recovered Sunday afternoon in a marsh east of Tiana Beach in Hampton Bays.

Southampton Town police say they received the call at around 2:45 p.m. for a body located near the beach. The remains were recovered in a bay-side marsh east of the beach.

Police identified the man as 38-year-old David Stetler, of Greenport.

The death appears to be non-criminal in nature, according to detectives.

John Lombardi, of Flanders, says he was the one who found the body. He was out scouting for horseshoe crab locations in a remote part of the bay that is only accessibly at low tide.

After wading through the marsh for more than 15 minutes, he saw what he thought was a mannequin. But as he got closer, he realized it was a body.

“I thought it was somebody lying on the ground with their face down, so I shouted, ‘Wake up. Wake up.’ But they didn’t move…” Lombardi said. “Then I realized it was a person who wasn’t alive. So I left and went immediately to the coast guard station….He looked like a typical person who wanted to go swimming in his underwear and t-shirt...and the body was blue.”

The medical examiner was set complete an examination as of Sunday night to determine a cause of death, according to police.

More Stories

Top Stories

01:56
Screenshot 2026-07-07 064725

Surveillance video captures moment BJ's roof collapses with customers nearby

02:45
MARSHALL2

A few showers today as the area begins to dry out from the flooding rains

00:27
Jerry O'Connell visits Jersey City

From Hollywood to Hudson County: Jerry O’Connell revisits family ties to Jersey City

02:59
Screenshot 2026-07-07 065014

Storm damage leaves tree down, wires tangled and road blocked in Wyckoff

00:20
772026NJswimmerbody_2026-07-07-06-58-17

Body of missing swimmer recovered from Atlantic County quarry

00:25
Brigatine Fire 001

Heavy fire destroys Brigantine home, leaving one injured and five displaced

00:26
JASON BLANCO

Body of missing 19-year-old Flemington man recovered from Delaware River

02:07
Screenshot 2026-07-07 055340

Hospital among sites hit as floodwaters overwhelm parts of Monmouth County

01:57
REtomkPower Outages_2026-07-06-22-19-34

Parts of Monmouth County without power for four days

02:04
1YearSincePlainfieldFloodsVS5P_2026-07-06-17-14-09

Plainfield marks one year since deadly flooding as city advances stormwater projects

00:21
WC 430PM MON_WC Heat Alert_ajc_2026-06-29-16-47-36

NJ reports 29 suspected heat-related deaths following extreme heat event

Screenshot 2026-07-06 171734

Your New Jersey 2026 Storm Photos

00:43
RTNJJerseyProud07062026VO10pm_2026-07-06-22-32-01

Jersey Proud: Lawrence Township educator recognized with most prestigious award in teaching

01:33
DEAL FLOODING RAW TN

Heavy rain causes flooding across NJ, forcing road closures & stranding vehicles

00:17
RACCOON RESCUE RAW TN

Jamesburg police rescue baby raccoon trapped in peanut butter jar

00:22
Winfield Tree 1

Winfield Park left without power after fallen tree triggers wire fire

01:04
Screenshot 2026-07-06 071835

NJ Transit disruptions continue as storm cleanup forces rail suspensions

01:22
735969952 1464497355480491 8596822639894272345 n

Middletown crews repair water main break near Route 35, mayor says

00:56
healthstory0706_2026-07-06-17-05-54

Summer can impact your sleep. Here are ways to sustain your sleep schedule

00:27
BKDOGFOOD7626_2026-07-06-12-55-09

Pedigree dog food cans recalled due to metal, plastic in food

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices