News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Toll of Commuting
Mostly Cloudy
80°
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Toll of Commuting

Body of man found east of Tiana Beach in Hampton Bays

Southampton Town police say they received the call at around 2:45 p.m. for a body located near the beach. The remains were recovered in a bay-side marsh east of the beach.

Jenna Rae Gaertner

and

Brendan O'Leary

and

Roberto Torres

May 31, 2026, 10:10 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

A man's body was recovered Sunday afternoon in a marsh east of Tiana Beach in Hampton Bays.

Southampton Town police say they received the call at around 2:45 p.m. for a body located near the beach. The remains were recovered in a bay-side marsh east of the beach.

Police identified the man as 38-year-old David Stetler, of Greenport.

The death appears to be non-criminal in nature, according to detectives.

John Lombardi, of Flanders, says he was the one who found the body. He was out scouting for horseshoe crab locations in a remote part of the bay that is only accessibly at low tide.

After wading through the marsh for more than 15 minutes, he saw what he thought was a mannequin. But as he got closer, he realized it was a body.

“I thought it was somebody lying on the ground with their face down, so I shouted, ‘Wake up. Wake up.’ But they didn’t move…” Lombardi said. “Then I realized it was a person who wasn’t alive. So I left and went immediately to the coast guard station….He looked like a typical person who wanted to go swimming in his underwear and t-shirt...and the body was blue.”

The medical examiner was set complete an examination as of Sunday night to determine a cause of death, according to police.

More Stories

Top Stories

00:14
Erik Montesinos Mug Blur

Bloomfield man charged in Newark hit-and-run that killed 17-year-old girl

01:41
NJ 3

Wet weather moves in late today and into tonight across the state

02:31
RTNJDeadlyNewarkCrashProbeADaniel10pm_2026-08-15-22-09-32

Attorney General's Office releases more details surrounding Newark crash that killed 17-year-old

car fire

Clifton police officer injured after vehicle crashes into patrol car on Route 21

00:19
Cane-s Box Combo

Raising Cane’s opening new NJ location on Monday

00:17
deadly shooting investigation

3 men charged in Paterson killing, accused of bringing illegal guns into NJ

00:24
SpaceX TN Raw

Did you see it? SpaceX launches two Falcon 9 rockets minutes apart from FL, CA

00:20
AP219774310748890

Monmouth County school district bans metal water bottles from classrooms

01:59
HawthorneFlooding_2026-08-15-17-11-40

Hawthorne fire department seeks high-water vehicle after unprecedented summer flooding

00:17
815southbrunswickcrash_2026-08-15-06-22-57

Crash lands Tesla in kitchen of South Brunswick home

00:23
megalodontoothpic

Family finds massive fossilized megalodon tooth in Sea Isle City

01:54
IndianIndependenceDay

Parsippany celebrates India’s 80th Independence Day and America’s 250th birthday

00:21
lightrail

Altercation leads to slashing on Hudson-Bergen Light Rail in Jersey City

00:13
INDICTED court ANCHOR DESK MON copy

Union County sheriff’s officer indicted for official misconduct, vehicle title fraud

01:03
BerkeleyBoatCrashUpdate_2026-08-14-22-29-51

Police: Bayville man was intoxicated in fatal boating incident

00:32
BayonneLittleLeagueVS_2026-08-14-22-09-10

Bayonne defeats CT to advance to the Little League World Series

02:19
NJLouGehrigAuction814_2026-08-14-22-20-33

Lou Gehrig’s 1933 contract up for bid at Lelands Auction House

02:01
Mosquito

New Jersey reports first case of Zika virus since 2020

01:44
processed-568F2667-AC80-4FB7-95F9-944A6B065BF2

Flock introduces new privacy measures amid camera controversy

00:29
Shroitman

Man charged in Somerville deadly stabbing found competent to stand trial

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices