Man held in Michigan suspected in ex-NJ priest slaying in Nevada

Authorities say a 25-year-old man being held in a Michigan jail is the suspect in a March killing in Nevada of a defrocked New Jersey priest accused of sexual abuse.

News 12 Staff

Jun 5, 2019, 9:39 AM

Updated 1,811 days ago

Share:

Authorities say a 25-year-old man being held in a Michigan jail is the suspect in a March killing in Nevada of a defrocked New Jersey priest accused of sexual abuse.
Court documents say Derrick Mitchell Decoste met and exchanged messages with 70-year-old John Capparelli for several weeks after answering an internet ad for young male wrestlers.
Police say Decoste owned the gun used to shoot Capparelli dead in his Henderson home. A police report suggests robbery was the motive for the killing. It says Dacoste's girlfriend turned over to police a bag containing items belonging to Capparelli, including a distinctive Newark Teachers Union wristwatch.
Capparelli was named in February among 180 priests listed by five New Jersey dioceses as alleged sex abusers.
New Jersey resident Rich Fitter says that he was sexually assaulted by Caparelli when he was 16 years old after taking part in a wrestling program coached by the priest.
“He had a certain playbook that he followed for 40 years and in the end, everything that led up to his death was attributable to the life that he led,” Fitter says.
Caparelli was removed from ministry in 1992, but went on to teach in Newark's public schools until retiring. He moved to Nevada in 2016.
Fitter says that he feels Caparelli met a just ending. But he says that there won’t be any justice for his alleged victims.
“He’s never going to be brought to court and be found guilty of all that he did. On the other hand, he's no longer a danger,” says Fitter.
Decoste was already in jail in Michigan for unrelated crimes when he was charged with murder and robbery in the Caparelli case.
The Associated Press wire services contributed to this report.


More from News 12
2:30
Roselle schools temporarily put on lockdown following reports of gunfire in the area

Roselle schools temporarily put on lockdown following reports of gunfire in the area

2:26
Summerlike weather returns to New Jersey ahead of Memorial Day

Summerlike weather returns to New Jersey ahead of Memorial Day

0:15
Officials: Single-engine plane crash-lands in Holland Township field

Officials: Single-engine plane crash-lands in Holland Township field

1:18
TGI Fridays in Brick Township among 36 across the US permanently closing

TGI Fridays in Brick Township among 36 across the US permanently closing

0:25
PBA: Millburn police officer killed in car crash

PBA: Millburn police officer killed in car crash

Police: Man accused of attacking mechanic with bleach, smashing windshield

Police: Man accused of attacking mechanic with bleach, smashing windshield

0:30
Jersey Proud: Hillside HS football team sorts food donations for those in need

Jersey Proud: Hillside HS football team sorts food donations for those in need

2:13
‘It’s our responsibility to tell their story.’ Vietnam Veterans Memorial Wall unveiled in Wayne Township

‘It’s our responsibility to tell their story.’ Vietnam Veterans Memorial Wall unveiled in Wayne Township

1:51
Officials: Train pulls down wires in Elizabeth, causing some power outages

Officials: Train pulls down wires in Elizabeth, causing some power outages

2:31
Prosecution focuses on Egyptian halal beef deal in Menendez’s bribery trial

Prosecution focuses on Egyptian halal beef deal in Menendez’s bribery trial

2:27
Advocates express concern as badly decomposed dolphin washes up in Long Branch

Advocates express concern as badly decomposed dolphin washes up in Long Branch

1:59
Route 71 bridge in Monmouth County remains closed as Memorial Day weekend approaches

Route 71 bridge in Monmouth County remains closed as Memorial Day weekend approaches

0:21
Scottie Scheffler's Louisville court date postponed after arrest during PGA Championship

Scottie Scheffler's Louisville court date postponed after arrest during PGA Championship

1:19
Red Lobster seeks bankruptcy protection days after closing dozens of restaurants

Red Lobster seeks bankruptcy protection days after closing dozens of restaurants

0:32
Prosecutors: Man charged with attempted kidnapping in Garfield; victim saved by good Samaritan

Prosecutors: Man charged with attempted kidnapping in Garfield; victim saved by good Samaritan

2:52
Sources: State police search Massapequa Park home of alleged Gilgo Beach serial killer

Sources: State police search Massapequa Park home of alleged Gilgo Beach serial killer

0:16
Police: Driver killed in Jefferson Township car crash on Route 15

Police: Driver killed in Jefferson Township car crash on Route 15

1:41
New Jersey joins Click it or Ticket seat belt campaign. Here's what you should know.

New Jersey joins Click it or Ticket seat belt campaign. Here's what you should know.

1:56
Celebrating Asian Pacific American Heritage Month with traditional Chinese dragon dance

Celebrating Asian Pacific American Heritage Month with traditional Chinese dragon dance

Your New Jersey Graduation Photos

Your New Jersey Graduation Photos