Should schools stop teaching ‘Huck Finn?’ Some NJ lawmakers think so

Two Democratic lawmakers from New Jersey are calling on the state’s school districts to stop teaching “Adventures of Huckleberry Finn” in the classroom.

News 12 Staff

Mar 21, 2019, 11:43 PM

Updated 1,886 days ago

Share:

Should schools stop teaching ‘Huck Finn?’ Some NJ lawmakers think so
Two Democratic lawmakers from New Jersey are calling on the state’s school districts to stop teaching “Adventures of Huckleberry Finn” in the classroom.
Assembly members Verlina Reynolds-Jackson and Jamel Holley wrote a resolution encouraging New Jersey school officials to remove the 1884 Mark Twain novel from their curriculum due to the novel’s use of racial slurs and racial themes.
But some educators are not entirely on board with this idea.
“The question is: Is [F. Scott] Fitzgerald, is Harper Lee, is Mark Twain endorsing racism or anti-Semitism or are they providing, as great literature does, an interrogation of those ideas?” asks Audrey Fisch, president of the New Jersey Council of Teachers of English.
Fisch, who is an English professor, says that she can see both sides of the argument.
“Part of the issue is the language in ‘Huckleberry Finn’ that it uses the ‘N-word’ repeatedly,” she says.
Reynolds-Jackson and Holley’s resolution states, “in addition to depicting deeply ingrained racial attitudes of the time-- the book liberally uses a highly offensive racial slur more than 200 times throughout its pages."
They go on to say that the book can cause students to feel upset, marginalized or humiliated and could create an uncomfortable atmosphere in the classroom.
But Fisch says that it should be up to each individual school community to make the decision about what to teach.
“Some might argue that ‘Huckleberry Finn’ is an excellent text for us to engage in debate about race and racism and some of the ugly history of our country. For some teachers, for some classrooms, for some students that’s not going to be a comfortable and easy discussion,” says Fisch.
The professor says that there are other texts that teachers can use to replace the novel, but she says that teachers or schools may not be able to afford to buy class sets of those books.
According to the resolution, school districts in Minnesota, Mississippi, Pennsylvania and Virginia have already removed the book from the curriculum.


More from News 12
2:10
Prosecution resumes presenting its case in Sen. Menendez’s bribery trial, focusing on Egyptian halal beef deal

Prosecution resumes presenting its case in Sen. Menendez’s bribery trial, focusing on Egyptian halal beef deal

1:51
Mostly sunny skies today in New Jersey ahead of major midweek warmup

Mostly sunny skies today in New Jersey ahead of major midweek warmup

0:23
Dead dolphin washes ashore in Long Branch

Dead dolphin washes ashore in Long Branch

1:59
Route 71 bridge in Monmouth County remains closed as Memorial Day weekend approaches

Route 71 bridge in Monmouth County remains closed as Memorial Day weekend approaches

Scottie Scheffler's Louisville court date postponed after arrest during PGA Championship

Scottie Scheffler's Louisville court date postponed after arrest during PGA Championship

1:19
Red Lobster seeks bankruptcy protection days after closing dozens of restaurants

Red Lobster seeks bankruptcy protection days after closing dozens of restaurants

0:32
Prosecutors: Man charged with attempted kidnapping in Garfield; victim saved by good Samaritan

Prosecutors: Man charged with attempted kidnapping in Garfield; victim saved by good Samaritan

3:37
Sources: State police search Massapequa Park home of alleged Gilgo Beach serial killer

Sources: State police search Massapequa Park home of alleged Gilgo Beach serial killer

0:16
Police: Driver killed in Jefferson Township car crash on Route 15

Police: Driver killed in Jefferson Township car crash on Route 15

1:41
New Jersey joins Click it or Ticket seat belt campaign. Here's what you should know.

New Jersey joins Click it or Ticket seat belt campaign. Here's what you should know.

1:56
Celebrating Asian Pacific American Heritage Month with traditional Chinese dragon dance

Celebrating Asian Pacific American Heritage Month with traditional Chinese dragon dance

0:38
Police: Manchester Township driver ejected from motorized bike following crash into SUV

Police: Manchester Township driver ejected from motorized bike following crash into SUV

2:31
Made In New Jersey: Buy or make your own candles at Brighter Days in Marlboro

Made In New Jersey: Buy or make your own candles at Brighter Days in Marlboro

2:11
Turn to Tara: FEMA initiative aims to improve safety of seniors during natural disasters

Turn to Tara: FEMA initiative aims to improve safety of seniors during natural disasters

0:27
Pacers set NBA playoff shooting mark, top Knicks 130-109 in Game 7 to make Eastern Conference finals

Pacers set NBA playoff shooting mark, top Knicks 130-109 in Game 7 to make Eastern Conference finals

Your New Jersey Graduation Photos

Your New Jersey Graduation Photos

2:41
Lantern ceremony in Montclair honors Asian community who faced violence and injustice

Lantern ceremony in Montclair honors Asian community who faced violence and injustice

1:53
Tour de Elizabeth takes cyclists through New Jersey's fourth-largest city

Tour de Elizabeth takes cyclists through New Jersey's fourth-largest city

0:30
Coast Guard boards anchored shipping vessel in Manasquan; no violations

Coast Guard boards anchored shipping vessel in Manasquan; no violations

0:23
Police: Haddonfield man faces charges for arson, stalking and vandalism

Police: Haddonfield man faces charges for arson, stalking and vandalism