HEAT ALERT

Temps will be even hotter Friday in New Jersey as highs approach 100 degrees

Sarah Stern jury hears first police interview with alleged killer

Jurors in the Sarah Stern murder trial heard the first interview that defendant Liam McAtasney gave to police.

News 12 Staff

Feb 6, 2019, 11:42 PM

Updated 1,961 days ago

Share:

Jurors in the Sarah Stern murder trial heard the first interview that defendant Liam McAtasney gave to police.
The interview was conducted in December 2016, not long after Stern was reported missing. Police spoke with McAtasney because he was the last person to see Stern before she went missing.
McAtasney is heard telling detectives, “Over the past few weeks she was packing up things in containers and moving them to other people’s houses.”
When asked if he thought that the behavior was strange, McAtasney admitted that he did at first, “but she always wanted to go to Canada.”
McAtasney is heard multiple times in the interview alluding to the fact that Stern may have wanted to run away from home or even commit suicide.
But prosecutors say that McAtasney strangled Stern in her home in order to get money that she has recently inherited. They say that he and accomplice Preston Taylor drove Stern’s car to the Route 35 Bridge in Belmar and threw her body into the Shark River.
During the interview, McAtasney asks about the possibility of Stern’s body being in the water.
“One thing I kind of wanted to talk to you guys about was, if she did jump off the bridge, what are the odds that she’s not somewhere all the way out in the ocean by now?” he is heard asking.
When detective ask McAtasney if Stern told him that she was going to jump, he said “No.”
Jurors also heard from three Monmouth County Prosecutor Office investigators who spoke about some of the key evidence in the case – including a safe that was found buried that apparently contained Stern’s money.
Investigator Bryan Muller testified that Taylor brought him to the location where the safe was buried.
“You can see loose dirt and soil and that’s where Mr. Taylor had said, ‘Here’s the tree that had fallen, and the soil. This was the result of us burying it.’ So he knew he had the right spot at this point,” Muller testified.
Taylor has pleaded guilty to his role in the crime and testified for the prosecution.
The trial is expected to continue Thursday.
Stern’s body has never been found.


More from News 12
2:37
Amtrak, NJ Transit service resumes with ‘significant delays’ after power outage, overhead wire issues

Amtrak, NJ Transit service resumes with ‘significant delays’ after power outage, overhead wire issues

1:24
Brushfire along New Jersey Turnpike in Secaucus snarls traffic, causes NJ Transit delays

Brushfire along New Jersey Turnpike in Secaucus snarls traffic, causes NJ Transit delays

2:39
HEAT ALERT: Temps dip into the 70s overnight; highs approach 100 for Friday

HEAT ALERT: Temps dip into the 70s overnight; highs approach 100 for Friday

0:53
Boil water advisory issued for parts of Edison following water main break

Boil water advisory issued for parts of Edison following water main break

0:45
Rep. Gottheimer announces federal security action ahead of 2026 FIFA World Cup

Rep. Gottheimer announces federal security action ahead of 2026 FIFA World Cup

2:59
Summer fun! News 12’s Dave Curren visits State Fair Meadowlands

Summer fun! News 12’s Dave Curren visits State Fair Meadowlands

0:33
Jersey Proud: Livingston crossing guard retires after 30 years

Jersey Proud: Livingston crossing guard retires after 30 years

2:42
Heading to the Jersey Shore to escape the heat? Beware of the cold ocean water

Heading to the Jersey Shore to escape the heat? Beware of the cold ocean water

2:06
‘Operation After Dark’ nets 78 arrests, thousands in fines in illegal club crackdown in Paterson

‘Operation After Dark’ nets 78 arrests, thousands in fines in illegal club crackdown in Paterson

0:58
Grand jury declines to file charges in deadly 2023 police shooting in Fort Lee

Grand jury declines to file charges in deadly 2023 police shooting in Fort Lee

1:43
Best Beaches: Checking out the ocean beaches at Brick Township

Best Beaches: Checking out the ocean beaches at Brick Township

2:00
Climbing to new heights at Iron Peak Sports & Events in Hillsborough

Climbing to new heights at Iron Peak Sports & Events in Hillsborough

1:28
George Norcross' longtime lawyer called to step down from Rutgers Board of Governors

George Norcross' longtime lawyer called to step down from Rutgers Board of Governors

0:20
Historic Battleship New Jersey returns to Camden waterfront following weeks of repairs

Historic Battleship New Jersey returns to Camden waterfront following weeks of repairs

2:18
2 beaches close due to over-capacity amid record-breaking season of beach badge sales

2 beaches close due to over-capacity amid record-breaking season of beach badge sales

2:12
Scorching temperatures won’t stop NJ residents from enjoying themselves outside

Scorching temperatures won’t stop NJ residents from enjoying themselves outside

0:26
 Boil water advisory issued for parts of Clifton and Paterson due to water main break

Boil water advisory issued for parts of Clifton and Paterson due to water main break

1:09
The East End: Goat yoga at Corwith Farm in Water Mill

The East End: Goat yoga at Corwith Farm in Water Mill

0:47
Jersey Proud: 4 Byram Intermediate School students place wreath on Tomb of Unknown Soldier

Jersey Proud: 4 Byram Intermediate School students place wreath on Tomb of Unknown Soldier

0:56
Independent investigation finds no malice intended regarding East Brunswick HS yearbook photo controversy

Independent investigation finds no malice intended regarding East Brunswick HS yearbook photo controversy