Parents of murder victim: ‘You messed with the wrong girl’

A 23-year-old man from Orange has been convicted for the murder of three women and the attempted murder of a fourth woman.

News 12 Staff

Dec 23, 2019, 11:01 PM

Updated 1,573 days ago

Share:

A 23-year-old man from Orange has been convicted for the murder of three women and the attempted murder of a fourth woman.
A jury convicted Khalil Wheeler-Weaver Friday for the 2016 murders.
Essex County Prosecutor Theodore Stephens says that Wheeler-Weaver did not think that the women’s lives mattered – that the women would not be missed. But Stephens says that this is wrong and that the women’s families helped to locate the killer.
Officials say that Wheeler-Weaver arranged sexual encounters the victims: Joanne Brown, Robin West and Sarah Butler. But they say that Wheeler-Weaver strangled them instead. A fourth woman was able to escape.
Butler’s parents attended Monday’s event with the prosecutor to honor their daughter. Mother Laverne Butler said that her daughter’s killer “messed with the wrong girl.”
“She loved to dance. She loved to swim. You took that away from her. She’ll never get a chance again to teach kids how to swim, teach them how to dance,” Laverne Butler said.
Butler’s father expressed the grief that has followed the family the last three years – especially during the holiday season.
“We didn’t even put up a Christmas tree because there was no joy in it. It’s going to take some time,” said Victor Butler.
Officials say that Wheeler-Weaver hid Butler’s body at the Eagle Rock Reservation in West Orange.
Stephens says that investigators could build a solid case against Wheeler-Weaver due to their ability to trace his phone and where he was. The surviving victim’s testimony was also instrumental.
Wheeler-Weaver did not testify. He has yet to be sentenced.


More from News 12
2:36
'She was the glue.' Loved ones call for justice for Passaic woman killed in hit-and-run

'She was the glue.' Loved ones call for justice for Passaic woman killed in hit-and-run

1:06
Scattered severe storms possible Sunday night in New Jersey

Scattered severe storms possible Sunday night in New Jersey

0:32
Prosecutors: Howell woman indicted in Monmouth County crash that killed 3-year-old

Prosecutors: Howell woman indicted in Monmouth County crash that killed 3-year-old

Booms and sirens in Israel after Iran launches over 200 missiles and drones in unprecedented attack

Booms and sirens in Israel after Iran launches over 200 missiles and drones in unprecedented attack

0:54
Clean Ocean Action hosts 39th Spring Beach Sweep in Sandy Hook

Clean Ocean Action hosts 39th Spring Beach Sweep in Sandy Hook

0:30
Out in the street: Bruce Springsteen makes it to Mohegan Sun show after flat tire in Jersey

Out in the street: Bruce Springsteen makes it to Mohegan Sun show after flat tire in Jersey

0:16
Police: Elizabeth man charged with sexually assaulting 2 children

Police: Elizabeth man charged with sexually assaulting 2 children

2:39
Police: 3 people in van on way to adult day care center killed in crash in South Brunswick

Police: 3 people in van on way to adult day care center killed in crash in South Brunswick

Police: Truck driver, toll booth attendant seriously injured in crash at Barnegat Toll Plaza

Police: Truck driver, toll booth attendant seriously injured in crash at Barnegat Toll Plaza

1:35
CDC: Measles could lose 'elimination status' amid uptick across the U.S.

CDC: Measles could lose 'elimination status' amid uptick across the U.S.

0:51
IRS warns public about potential tax scams as Tax Day deadline approaches

IRS warns public about potential tax scams as Tax Day deadline approaches

2:27
Congress investigates rise in antisemitism at Rutgers, including incident involving student 2 weeks ago

Congress investigates rise in antisemitism at Rutgers, including incident involving student 2 weeks ago

0:22
Elizabeth man sentenced to 25 years in prison for road rage rampage

Elizabeth man sentenced to 25 years in prison for road rage rampage

0:56
Jersey Proud: Miracle League of Mercer County to hold first game of season

Jersey Proud: Miracle League of Mercer County to hold first game of season

0:18
Prosecutor: 4th person charged in New Brunswick shooting that injured 2 Rutgers students

Prosecutor: 4th person charged in New Brunswick shooting that injured 2 Rutgers students

0:20
Newark officials postpone plans for overnight curfew for minors

Newark officials postpone plans for overnight curfew for minors

1:52
New York Red Bulls to hold annual Autism Acceptance match for families with autism

New York Red Bulls to hold annual Autism Acceptance match for families with autism

1:59
Fire destroys iconic restaurant DP’s Pub and Seafood Grill in Garfield

Fire destroys iconic restaurant DP’s Pub and Seafood Grill in Garfield

0:29
Officials: More than 70 lab mice at Seton Hall euthanized due to neglect

Officials: More than 70 lab mice at Seton Hall euthanized due to neglect