Toll of Commuting
News12 New York
Where to Watch
Download the App
Local
Crime
Weather
beWell
The East End
Crime Files
FIFA World Cup

Islanders season ends with late collapse

In late March, the Islanders were in a playoff position and feeling good.

Kevin Maher

Apr 15, 2026, 6:45 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

Casey Cizikas is in his 15th season with the Islanders. He's seen the team miss the playoffs before.

But Wednesday, as he and his teammates spoke to reporters for the final time this season, he said this year's late collapse is one of the toughest to accept.

"The way we competed and the way we put ourselves into position and then let it slip through our fingers, it sucks," Cizikas said.

In late March, the Islanders were in a playoff position and feeling good.

But on March 19, they lost 3-2 against Ottawa when they gave up a goal with 11 seconds to go.

Islanders GM Mathieu Darche believes that kind of loss, coupled with some injuries, was the signal that all was not well.

The Islanders lost 10 of the 14 games that followed and ended up finishing in sixth place.

It's the second straight year the team missed the playoffs.

"You can feel it today and the last two days really, there is no sense of satisfaction. We are pissed off in this room," said forward Mat Barzal.

The Islanders even tried a late coaching change.

They fired Patrick Roy with four regular season games left to go and replaced him with Peter DeBoer.

The new coach tried to help and implement more defensive structure, but in all fairness to the players, it was like the NHL's version of cramming for a test.

"I think we did as good as we could have done with the time we had," Barzal said.

But this was not the ending the Islanders planned after a season that brought renewed optimism. Some was created by the arrival of the new general manager.

But much of it was brought by 18-year-old defenseman Matthew Schaefer. He was the first overall pick in the draft and ended up with 59 points. He also tied the record for most goals by a rookie defenseman in NHL history. Schaefer admits that he exceeded even his own expectations.

"It's still crazy to think that I'm playing in the NHL," he said. "It's crazy to think that I was in a sports camp a few years ago, probably. I think everyone is going to do what they have to do in the offseason so that next season we're coming ready and we're coming guns blazing."

But will Anders Lee be part of the team next season?

The Islanders' captain is an unrestricted free agent.

Darche said he'd love to see Lee return and play his 1,000th game in an Isles uniform. The GM did not comment on any negotiations with Lee, but some of his teammates praised the 13-year veteran for his leadership.

"He's been a protector of a lot of guys in this locker room," defenseman Ryan Pulock said about Lee. "He's really done it all. I'm proud to have been his teammate and hopefully for longer. He's laid it all out there every single night."

But now the game nights are over for the Islanders. A once promising season has come to an end, and fans are stuck waiting again for more playoff glory.

More Stories

Top Stories

05:12
Screenshot 2026-05-05 054826

New video appears to show first flames inside Belleville warehouse before massive fire erupted

02:21
RizzoSM

Midweek 'interruption' of weather douses New Jersey with beneficial rain after 11 a.m. on Wednesday

00:21
Credit: Six Flags Great Adventure

Great Adventure will 'deck the halls' this year as Holiday in the Park returns

00:26
Beaver attack

Angry beaver attacks 8-year-old boy at Mahwah park

00:13
flag football

Girls flag football to become varsity sport in New Jersey high school

26ca0292-a7d1-4abe-9fbf-ecaf43e93824

Man threatens landscaper with handgun, triggering SWAT response

00:16
PHILA MAN ARRESTED EBIKE

Summit police arrest Philadelphia man in overnight burglary and e-bike theft

00:27
Screenshot 2026-05-05 055431

New Jersey celebrities make bold fashion statements at this year’s Met Gala

01:57
RETompatersonrally_2026-05-04-22-15-12

Paterson teachers rally against projected layoffs

02:19
Screenshot 2026-05-04 060622

Dashcam video captures United jet striking pole and truck near Newark airport

02:11
Screenshot 2026-05-04 170529

Residents renew push for Rahway river flood mitigation plan amid long-standing concerns

shootingnearwashingtonmonumentAP

Secret Service says suspect opened fire on them and was shot in exchange near Washington Monument

BRIDGETON POLICE DEPARTMENT RAW

Gun, drugs recovered after traffic stop turns into foot pursuit in NJ town

00:40
REjp542026_2026-05-04-22-21-12

Jersey Proud: Firetruck drop-off for book loving student sparks 'Jersey Proud' moment in Mount Laurel

03:27
3

Welding sparks eyed as possible cause of massive Belleville warehouse fire

NEWARK DEPT. OF PUBLIC SAFETY 1

Newark police seek woman accused of stealing package from home

01:58
AngelsPlayground_2026-05-04-17-18-01_17-15-53,18

Playground built to commemorate life of 3-year-old boy in Point Pleasant Borough

00:29
basketball

NJSIAA narrowly approves 35-second shot clock for high school basketball

Westfield racoon

Westfield sergeant safely returns young raccoon to Tamaques Park

1

Belleville Mayor: "This is what hell looks like the morning after…"

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices