Former MLB pitcher turned cop Varvaro dies in car crash

Anthony Varvaro, a former Major League Baseball pitcher who retired in 2016 to become a police officer in the New York City area, was killed in a car crash Sunday morning on his way to work at the Sept. 11 memorial ceremony in Manhattan, according to police officials and his former teams.

Associated Press

Sep 11, 2022, 10:43 PM

Updated 639 days ago

Share:

Anthony Varvaro, a former Major League Baseball pitcher who retired in 2016 to become a police officer in the New York City area, was killed in a car crash Sunday morning on his way to work at the Sept. 11 memorial ceremony in Manhattan, according to police officials and his former teams.
Varvaro, 37, was an officer for the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey. He played baseball at St. John's University in New York City before a career in the majors as a relief pitcher with the Seattle Mariners, Atlanta Braves and Boston Red Sox from 2010 to 2015.
“We are deeply saddened on the passing of former Braves pitcher Anthony Varvaro,” the Braves said in a statement. “Our thoughts and prayers are with his family and colleagues.”
The crash happened Sunday morning in New Jersey. Messages seeking details about the crash were left with New Jersey state police.
St. John's head baseball coach Mike Hampton said he was “at a loss for words” over Varvaro's death.
“Not only was he everything you could want out of a ball player, he was everything you could want in a person," said Hampton, who was an assistant coach at St. John's during all three of Varvaro's seasons there. "My heart goes out to his family, friends, teammates and fellow officers.”
Port Authority officials said in a statement that Varvaro “represented the very best of this agency, and will be remembered for his courage and commitment to service.”
“On this solemn occasion as the Port Authority mourns the loss of 84 employees in the attacks on the World Trade Center - including 37 members of the Port Authority Police Department - our grief only deepens today with the passing of Officer Varvaro," said the statement by Port Authority Chairman Kevin O'Toole and Executive Director Rick Cotton.
Raised in Staten Island in New York City, Varvaro was drafted by Seattle in the 12th round in 2005. He played for the Mariners in 2010 and Atlanta from 2011 to 2014.
Varvaro was traded to the Red Sox in late 2014 and pitched 11 innings for Boston early in the 2015 season. In May 2015, the Chicago Cubs claimed him off waivers from Boston, but returned him to the Red Sox after testing showed he had a elbow injury in his right pitching arm, which resulted in season-ending surgery.
For his major league career, he pitched 183 innings in 166 games, compiling a 3.23 earned run average, 150 strikeouts and one save.
In 2016, he appeared in 18 games for Boston's top minor league affiliate before retiring in June and beginning his police training.
Varvaro, who studied criminal justice at St. John's and graduated in 2005, told the student newspaper, The Torch, in December 2016 that he inquired about police jobs at the Port Authority while pitching in the majors.
“I figured that I had a pretty successful career in baseball, I had played a number of seasons, and I was fine moving on to the next step of my life,” he told the newspaper.
Port Authority officials said Varvaro became a police officer in December 2016 and was assigned to patrol for nearly five years before transferring to the Port Authority Police Academy to become an instructor.


More from News 12
2:25
Prosecutor: Suspect taken into custody in deadly shooting in West Carteret

Prosecutor: Suspect taken into custody in deadly shooting in West Carteret

2:41
Clear skies overnight with a sunny Thursday ahead; tracking storm potentials for Friday

Clear skies overnight with a sunny Thursday ahead; tracking storm potentials for Friday

2:17
KIYC documentary prompts state senator to call for all rape kits in New Jersey to be tested

KIYC documentary prompts state senator to call for all rape kits in New Jersey to be tested

2:08
Jersey Shore leaders meet with state officials to discuss pop-up party prevention

Jersey Shore leaders meet with state officials to discuss pop-up party prevention

1:57
No, it’s not the Caribbean. New Jersey’s oceanfront really is that clear right now

No, it’s not the Caribbean. New Jersey’s oceanfront really is that clear right now

0:47
Mayor: Administrative mishaps prevent Secaucus from offering full-day pre-K program

Mayor: Administrative mishaps prevent Secaucus from offering full-day pre-K program

0:39
East Brunswick High School printing new page for yearbook amid photo controversy

East Brunswick High School printing new page for yearbook amid photo controversy

1:56
NJ Transit, Amtrak lay out service disruption initiative following system failures in May

NJ Transit, Amtrak lay out service disruption initiative following system failures in May

0:24
New Jersey to receive over $30 million from Johnson & Johnson talc settlement

New Jersey to receive over $30 million from Johnson & Johnson talc settlement

1:40
NJ native Kristoffer Diaz dishes on Tony nomination for ‘Hell’s Kitchen’

NJ native Kristoffer Diaz dishes on Tony nomination for ‘Hell’s Kitchen’

0:28
‘Operation Cruel Summer’ nets 4 arrests in Middlesex County

‘Operation Cruel Summer’ nets 4 arrests in Middlesex County

1:55
Waldwick's boil water advisory remains in effect Wednesday due to nearly 2-day water main break

Waldwick's boil water advisory remains in effect Wednesday due to nearly 2-day water main break

0:32
Attorney general: On-duty Franklin Borough police sergeant involved in crash that killed 19-year-old

Attorney general: On-duty Franklin Borough police sergeant involved in crash that killed 19-year-old

0:29
Sussex County school bus driver gets 14 years in prison for driving students around while drunk

Sussex County school bus driver gets 14 years in prison for driving students around while drunk

0:28
Aldi warns customers of data breach involving skimming devices; 2 NJ stores affected

Aldi warns customers of data breach involving skimming devices; 2 NJ stores affected

0:17
Middlesex police: Construction worker killed after being hit by metal beam

Middlesex police: Construction worker killed after being hit by metal beam

0:19
Ridgefield man accused of strangling a child before attempting sexual assault

Ridgefield man accused of strangling a child before attempting sexual assault

2:28
India defeats USA in last Nassau Cricket World Cup match

India defeats USA in last Nassau Cricket World Cup match

1:35
What's Cooking: Uncle Giuseppe's Marketplace's lemon iced almond biscotti

What's Cooking: Uncle Giuseppe's Marketplace's lemon iced almond biscotti

2:11
Somerset County volunteer fire department at odds over new terms made by Board of Fire Commissioners

Somerset County volunteer fire department at odds over new terms made by Board of Fire Commissioners