Doctor takes stand in baby sitter's murder trial

Expert testimony from a doctor was brought before a jury Wednesday in the trial of a baby sitter accused of shaking the child she was caring for to death. Michelle Heale, of Toms River, is facing charges

News 12 Staff

Apr 9, 2015, 1:38 AM

Updated 3,296 days ago

Share:

Doctor takes stand in baby sitter's murder trial
Expert testimony from a doctor was brought before a jury Wednesday in the trial of a baby sitter accused of shaking the child she was caring for to death.
Michelle Heale, of Toms River, is facing charges of murder and endangering the welfare of a child in the death of 14-month-old Mason Hess in 2012.
Dr. John Plunkett, a pathologist from Minnesota, disagreed completely that Hess died from being shaken. He said there was no sign of blunt cerebral trauma and shaken baby syndrome, which is the crux of the state's case against Heale.
The Monmouth County prosecutor argued that Heale shook Hess violently, causing brain and spinal cord damage.
The defense also took a shot at the state's use of a doll, which Heale was instructed to use to demonstrate how she handled Hess. They claimed that it had no resemblance to the baby and was an inaccurate depiction of what it represented.
State prosecutors fired back at Dr. Plunkett, noting that in 150 cases, he always testified for the defense. They also pointed out that he has not performed an autopsy in four years.
Heale testified in court on Tuesday. She gave her side of the story, saying that Hess was sitting on her bedroom floor when he began choking on applesauce. According to Heale, she picked Hess up and hit him on the back until the applesauce came out, which is when his head snapped back and she called 911.
The trial is expected to continue Thursday.


More from News 12
2:48
Toll worker with ‘premonition’ called out of work before truck crashed into booth

Toll worker with ‘premonition’ called out of work before truck crashed into booth

1:53
Nice weather ends: Rain, cooler temperatures for Wednesday through Friday

Nice weather ends: Rain, cooler temperatures for Wednesday through Friday

2:34
Buc-ee’s billboard erected along NJ Turnpike. But don’t expect to see the chain here anytime soon

Buc-ee’s billboard erected along NJ Turnpike. But don’t expect to see the chain here anytime soon

0:21
Prosecutor: Montclair officer injured in shootout released from hospital, suspect charged

Prosecutor: Montclair officer injured in shootout released from hospital, suspect charged

Detective says daughter's boyfriend, disliked by Atlantic City mayor, recorded abuse in video call

Detective says daughter's boyfriend, disliked by Atlantic City mayor, recorded abuse in video call

0:27
Toms River police chief suspended for 2 days amid feud with town’s mayor

Toms River police chief suspended for 2 days amid feud with town’s mayor

0:53
Jersey Proud: Artwork featured in Newark Liberty’s Terminal A done by NJ artists

Jersey Proud: Artwork featured in Newark Liberty’s Terminal A done by NJ artists

0:44
Dozens of residents escape 4-alarm fire in Paterson that damaged 3 homes

Dozens of residents escape 4-alarm fire in Paterson that damaged 3 homes

0:21
FAA: Cessna 150 plane crashes at Sussex Airport in Wantage

FAA: Cessna 150 plane crashes at Sussex Airport in Wantage

Another record for New Jersey internet gambling revenue as in-person winnings struggle

Another record for New Jersey internet gambling revenue as in-person winnings struggle

2:02
Middletown mayor proposes reducing parking fees to offset NJ Transit fare hike

Middletown mayor proposes reducing parking fees to offset NJ Transit fare hike

1:48
Look up! Lyrid meteor shower returns to the tri-state area

Look up! Lyrid meteor shower returns to the tri-state area

2:22
Hudson County officials say noise from NYC helicopter tours is disrupting residents

Hudson County officials say noise from NYC helicopter tours is disrupting residents

0:30
4 men accused in shooting near Rutgers face judge; 2 ordered to remain jailed

4 men accused in shooting near Rutgers face judge; 2 ordered to remain jailed

2:01
Sea Girt officials expect beach entrance where toddler got trapped in sand to reopen in May

Sea Girt officials expect beach entrance where toddler got trapped in sand to reopen in May

0:32
Investigation finds deficiencies in Essex County’s $40 million COVID-19 vaccination program

Investigation finds deficiencies in Essex County’s $40 million COVID-19 vaccination program

0:57
Wawa celebrates 60th anniversary with free coffee

Wawa celebrates 60th anniversary with free coffee

0:17
AMC Theatres at Menlo Park Mall in Edison completes multimillion-dollar renovations

AMC Theatres at Menlo Park Mall in Edison completes multimillion-dollar renovations

0:08
CDC warns of counterfeit Botox in 9 states, including New Jersey and New York

CDC warns of counterfeit Botox in 9 states, including New Jersey and New York

0:22
Police: 3 drivers hospitalized with head injuries following Manchester crash

Police: 3 drivers hospitalized with head injuries following Manchester crash