Criminologists create podcast based on the New Jersey ‘suitcase murder’

Two criminologists from Fairleigh Dickinson University have created a podcast based on the well-known New Jersey criminal case known as “the suitcase murders.”

News 12 Staff

Jun 15, 2019, 2:13 AM

Updated 1,802 days ago

Share:

Two criminologists from Fairleigh Dickinson University have created a podcast based on the well-known New Jersey criminal case known as “the suitcase murders.”
The podcast is called “Direct Appeal” and it looks at the case of Melanie McGuire.
McGuire, of Woodbridge, was convicted in the 2004 murder of her husband. Authorities say that McGuire killed and dismembered her husband, packaged his body into suitcases and then threw them off the Chesapeake Bay Bridge in Virginia. She was convicted in 2007 and sentenced to life in prison.
McGuire has maintained her innocence and reached out to criminologist Meghan Sacks to take a look at her case.
“The first thing I said when I sat down in visitation with Melanie was I was not there as her lawyer, not there as her advocate. If we did anything with regards to her story or investigated it at all it would be from a completely unbiased point of view and she might not like how it turns out in the end because I might conclude that she is guilty as charged,” says Sacks. “She was immediately OK with that.”
Over two years, Sacks and her fellow FDU criminologist Amy Shlosberg re-examined the case. The prosecution's mountain of circumstantial evidence, the lack of forensic evidence and the stories presented by both prosecutors at the time and McGuire herself in 40 hours of new interviews.
“I say over and over, 'I don't know if she did it or not,' but if she did it, she absolutely did not do it the way the prosecution said she did,” says Shlosberg. “The timeline doesn't add up, the lack of forensic evidence. It did not happen in that way.”
From the lack of blood in a small Woodbridge apartment where prosecutors said McGuire cut up her husband's body, to McGuire's inexplicable actions in the days after her husband went missing - the podcast is a 14-episode roller-coaster search for what seems to still be missing in this case - a version of the facts, based on evidence presented by both sides, that makes sense.
The criminologists say they plan to take questions from listeners and ask them directly of McGuire themselves for the final episode of the series.
“Direct Appeal” can be found wherever podcasts are heard.


More from News 12
0:33
Monmouth County high school students may have had personal info stolen in data breach

Monmouth County high school students may have had personal info stolen in data breach

1:57
Taste of summer returns to New Jersey with highs in the mid-80s

Taste of summer returns to New Jersey with highs in the mid-80s

0:45
Manchester police: 2 men accused of burglarizing several businesses around New Jersey

Manchester police: 2 men accused of burglarizing several businesses around New Jersey

2:35
Ocean Grove temporarily allows Sunday morning beach access

Ocean Grove temporarily allows Sunday morning beach access

0:16
Krispy Kreme opening new location at the Jersey Shore

Krispy Kreme opening new location at the Jersey Shore

0:25
Prosecutors: 73-year-old man accused of murdering his wife in their Moorestown apartment

Prosecutors: 73-year-old man accused of murdering his wife in their Moorestown apartment

1:57
Peapack-Gladstone taking new steps to control geese problem

Peapack-Gladstone taking new steps to control geese problem

0:23
NJ Transit police save man from drowning in Hudson River with rescue ring buoys

NJ Transit police save man from drowning in Hudson River with rescue ring buoys

0:20
Prosecutor: Teen killed, another injured in shooting outside Trenton apartment

Prosecutor: Teen killed, another injured in shooting outside Trenton apartment

1:54
Best of New Jersey: A taste of Italy in Monmouth County at Limoncello at Piazza Di Roma

Best of New Jersey: A taste of Italy in Monmouth County at Limoncello at Piazza Di Roma

0:14
Prosecutor: Walk-in Camden hospital patient dies days after being shot

Prosecutor: Walk-in Camden hospital patient dies days after being shot

0:25
PBA: Millburn police officer killed in car crash

PBA: Millburn police officer killed in car crash

1:18
TGI Fridays in Brick Township among 36 across the US permanently closing

TGI Fridays in Brick Township among 36 across the US permanently closing

0:30
Jersey Proud: Hillside HS football team sorts food donations for those in need

Jersey Proud: Hillside HS football team sorts food donations for those in need

2:13
‘It’s our responsibility to tell their story.’ Vietnam Veterans Memorial Wall unveiled in Wayne Township

‘It’s our responsibility to tell their story.’ Vietnam Veterans Memorial Wall unveiled in Wayne Township

2:30
Roselle schools temporarily put on lockdown following reports of gunfire in the area

Roselle schools temporarily put on lockdown following reports of gunfire in the area

0:15
Officials: Single-engine plane crash-lands in Holland Township field

Officials: Single-engine plane crash-lands in Holland Township field

1:51
Officials: Train pulls down wires in Elizabeth, causing some power outages

Officials: Train pulls down wires in Elizabeth, causing some power outages

2:31
Prosecution focuses on Egyptian halal beef deal in Menendez’s bribery trial

Prosecution focuses on Egyptian halal beef deal in Menendez’s bribery trial

2:27
Advocates express concern as badly decomposed dolphin washes up in Long Branch

Advocates express concern as badly decomposed dolphin washes up in Long Branch