WATCH LIVE

Sen. JD Vance, Donald Trump’s running mate, speaks at RNC. Live now on News 12 and News 12 New York

Closing arguments delivered at actor's Bronx trial

Closing arguments were made Tuesday in the trial of Lillo Brancato Jr., the former actor accused of second-degree murder in the shooting death of an off-duty NYPD officer. In their summations, the prosecution

News 12 Staff

Dec 17, 2008, 4:36 PM

Updated 5,691 days ago

Share:

Closing arguments were made Tuesday in the trial of Lillo Brancato Jr., the former actor accused of second-degree murder in the shooting death of an off-duty NYPD officer.
In their summations, the prosecution and defense left the jury with one question to answer: Is Brancato a cop-killing robber or was the ex-actor, who once appeared regularly on "The Sopranos," simply in the wrong place at the wrong time?
Brancato faces the murder charge in the 2005 killing of off-duty police Officer Daniel Enchautegui in Pelham Bay. Brancato's co-defendant, Steven Armento, was convicted of first-degree murder on Oct. 30 and later sentenced to life in prison without parole.
Brancato has said he was suffering from heroin withdrawal when he and Armento went to an apartment where the actor had obtained drugs before. Authorities say Armento and Brancato broke into the basement apartment to steal prescription drugs after a night of drinking at a strip club.
Enchautegui had returned home after finishing a late shift when he heard glass breaking at the residence next door. When he went to investigate, Armento fired at him, striking him in the chest.
Brancato's defense team tried to argue during the trial that its client was not armed and was unaware Armento was carrying a weapon. Prosecutors charged Brancato with second-degree murder because they say the officer was killed during a felony burglary.
"If Lillo didn't try to enter [the apartment], this is not a burglary," said Joseph Tacopina, Brancato's lawyer. "If it's not a burglary, Lillo is not guilty."
Brancato takes stand at murder trial Allegeddrug dealer testifies at Brancato trialWitness:Brancato was addicted to drugs in 2005Clericalmix-up puts Brancato trial on holdDoctortestifies in Lillo Brancato Jr. trial


More from News 12
2:39
STORM WATCH: Severe thunderstorms possible across New Jersey into the overnight hours

STORM WATCH: Severe thunderstorms possible across New Jersey into the overnight hours

1:30
NJ Transit warns riders intense heat may cause delays, cancellations

NJ Transit warns riders intense heat may cause delays, cancellations

0:30
WATCH: Daylight fireball that caused loud boom streaks across sky in New Jersey

WATCH: Daylight fireball that caused loud boom streaks across sky in New Jersey

0:27
Police: West Milford man accused of smashing windshield of Wayne police cruiser

Police: West Milford man accused of smashing windshield of Wayne police cruiser

0:20
President Joe Biden tests positive for COVID-19 while campaigning in Las Vegas

President Joe Biden tests positive for COVID-19 while campaigning in Las Vegas

0:24
Jersey Proud: Belleville police officers host pop-up lemonade stand

Jersey Proud: Belleville police officers host pop-up lemonade stand

0:51
Hackensack Fire Department to get $250K in federal grants for flood response

Hackensack Fire Department to get $250K in federal grants for flood response

0:58
Meryl Streep, Phil Simms and Jersey Mike’s founder among those to be inducted into NJ Hall of Fame

Meryl Streep, Phil Simms and Jersey Mike’s founder among those to be inducted into NJ Hall of Fame

1:53
Newest community refrigerator now installed at Hyatt Court in Newark

Newest community refrigerator now installed at Hyatt Court in Newark

1:39
Hundreds participate in 37th annual Belmar beach sandcastle contest

Hundreds participate in 37th annual Belmar beach sandcastle contest

0:25
Wildfire at major military gunnery range in Burlington and Ocean counties burns over 1,100 acres

Wildfire at major military gunnery range in Burlington and Ocean counties burns over 1,100 acres

1:34
Bricks fall two-stories from municipal building onto Paterson sidewalk; no injuries

Bricks fall two-stories from municipal building onto Paterson sidewalk; no injuries

0:33
Police: Probe of dog’s death leads to discovery of drug stash at South Jersey business

Police: Probe of dog’s death leads to discovery of drug stash at South Jersey business

0:27
Former Wall Township teacher accused of having a sexual relationship with student

Former Wall Township teacher accused of having a sexual relationship with student

0:37
Officials: Bergenfield woman admits to defrauding customers of over $360K in social media investment scheme

Officials: Bergenfield woman admits to defrauding customers of over $360K in social media investment scheme

1:26
HEAT ALERT: Cars heat fast in direct sunlight!

HEAT ALERT: Cars heat fast in direct sunlight!

1:28
What's Cooking: Uncle Giuseppe's Marketplace's Italian potato salad

What's Cooking: Uncle Giuseppe's Marketplace's Italian potato salad

2:09
Prosecutor: Infant dies after being left in hot car in Lakewood; father faces charges

Prosecutor: Infant dies after being left in hot car in Lakewood; father faces charges

1:11
Officials: 3 firefighters injured, dozens displaced by fire in Newark

Officials: 3 firefighters injured, dozens displaced by fire in Newark