Accused Bronx teen murderer faces judge again

A Bronx teen girl who has been charged with murdering two men in separate incidents last week was in court Wednesday. Sharell Butler, 15, was charged with killing Christopher Umpierrie, 24, on Dec. 19,

News 12 Staff

Dec 31, 2008, 11:36 PM

Updated 5,680 days ago

Share:

A Bronx teen girl who has been charged with murdering two men in separate incidents last week was in court Wednesday.
Sharell Butler, 15, was charged with killing Christopher Umpierrie, 24, on Dec. 19, after robbing his Throgs Neck home. She is also charged with killing John Hopkins-Drago, 20, whose body was found dismembered in a garbage bag behind a Pelham Parkway apartment building on Dec. 21.
In court Wednesday, Butler's lawyer waived her right to testify before a grand jury. He also denied some of the allegations against her.
"Things are not always what they seem," says Xavier Donaldson, Butler's lawyer. "That's important to realize. The case is in its infancy stages. We expect more facts to come out that will be beneficial."
Investigators say Butler may not have been the only person responsible for the death of Hopkins-Drago. Police are questioning Robert Pastore, 19, for his possible involvement in the crime.
Pastore's rap sheet includes charges of rape, sodomy, sexual misconduct, endangering the welfare of a child and sexual abuse.
Pastore was also in court and ordered to stay away from Butler. He is due back in court on February 24.
Butler, who is due back in court on February 9, is being held without bail. Pastore is being held on $15,000 bail.


More from News 12
1:59
Flight disruptions persist at Newark Liberty Int’l Airport due to global technology outage

Flight disruptions persist at Newark Liberty Int’l Airport due to global technology outage

2:35
Clouds and sun for Sunday in New Jersey

Clouds and sun for Sunday in New Jersey

1:49
Toms River firefighters headed to national competition

Toms River firefighters headed to national competition

0:17
Police: Man fatally shot inside car in Clifton

Police: Man fatally shot inside car in Clifton

0:29
Fire leaves several residents in Lakewood displaced

Fire leaves several residents in Lakewood displaced

0:26
Police: Egg Harbor Township man accused of fatally striking bicyclist while driving drunk

Police: Egg Harbor Township man accused of fatally striking bicyclist while driving drunk

1:41
 Officials: COVID-19 has hit high levels in several states, including Connecticut

Officials: COVID-19 has hit high levels in several states, including Connecticut

1:41
 Officials: COVID-19 has hit high levels in several states, including Connecticut

Officials: COVID-19 has hit high levels in several states, including Connecticut

0:27
Prosecutor: Jackson Township man accused of fatally stabbing roommate

Prosecutor: Jackson Township man accused of fatally stabbing roommate

1:27
Prosecutor: Infant girl dies after being left inside parked car in East Hanover

Prosecutor: Infant girl dies after being left inside parked car in East Hanover

0:23
CDC: NJ resident dies from listeria food poisoning linked to deli meat

CDC: NJ resident dies from listeria food poisoning linked to deli meat

2:25
A massive tech outage is causing worldwide disruptions. Here's what we know

A massive tech outage is causing worldwide disruptions. Here's what we know

NJ Transit to resume regular weekend schedule following disruptions due to extreme heat

NJ Transit to resume regular weekend schedule following disruptions due to extreme heat

2:01
Doctors urge parents to get their children in for doctor visit ahead of new school year

Doctors urge parents to get their children in for doctor visit ahead of new school year

0:48
Jersey Proud: Stockton students spend summer measuring New Jersey shoreline

Jersey Proud: Stockton students spend summer measuring New Jersey shoreline

0:53
Beachwood West Beach closed for rest of summer due to high bacteria levels

Beachwood West Beach closed for rest of summer due to high bacteria levels

2:02
What happens if Biden drops out of the race? Here are some scenarios

What happens if Biden drops out of the race? Here are some scenarios

0:26
Costco sells ‘emergency food supply’ bucket with a 25-year shelf life

Costco sells ‘emergency food supply’ bucket with a 25-year shelf life

5:00
Tech expert weighs in on Microsoft outage impacts across the globe

Tech expert weighs in on Microsoft outage impacts across the globe

0:31
Man dies after he rescues two young boys who were struggling to stay afloat in New Jersey river

Man dies after he rescues two young boys who were struggling to stay afloat in New Jersey river