News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Weather
Crime
Politics
Toll of Commuting
Sunny
64°
Local
Weather
Crime
Politics
Toll of Commuting

Wyandanch church seeks support after fire damages longtime soup kitchen

Church leaders said the fire started near an outside door in the basement before it spread through the kitchen and upstairs to the church offices.

Jenna Rae Gaertner

•

Oct 18, 2026, 10:20 PM

•

Updated

Share:

A fire at Trinity Lutheran Church in Wyandanch on Sunday afternoon caused damage to the building and its longtime soup kitchen ministry, though no one was injured, according to church leaders and fire officials.

After Sunday morning services had ended, church leaders received a call that the church was on fire.

“I first heard about it, I was kind of almost teary because I'm like, 'oh my God, this church that I hold so dear since 1977 could just be'...When you hear fire. Your mind goes to the worse scenario,” said Penelope Owens, the church council president.

Photos from inside the building show damage caused by the fire. Church leaders said the fire started near an outside door in the basement before it spread through the kitchen and upstairs to the church offices.

“The damage is minimal, but there’s smoke damage, there’s water damage, they had to rip out doors and windows. So we got to get all that replaced,” said Vito Colletti, president of the Mercy Soup Kitchen.

Trinity Lutheran Church has been part of the Wyandanch community for nearly 90 years. One of its key ministries is the Mercy Soup Kitchen, which has fed people for 45 years.

Soup kitchen organizers said the kitchen equipment and most of the food survived the fire. However, the program serves about 150 meals each day and organizers are hoping to resume operations as quickly as possible.

“This is devastating. Very difficult for me. It's a it's a hard road ahead. And, like they say, keeping the doors open is important. Too many people depend on us,” Colletti said.

Colletti added he hopes most of the cleanup can be completed on Monday so that the soup kitchen can reopen and begin serving meals again Tuesday or Wednesday.

“We really need the donations from the community to help us rebuild what has been damaged,” Owens said.

Police said the fire appears to have been accidental and fire officials said no one was hurt.

Top Stories

six flags elephants

USDA finds no violations in inspection of Six Flags Great Adventure elephant facility

02:27
RizzoSM2

Calm and fair weather persists all week with cool afternoons and crispy mornings.

01:34
Screenshot 2026-10-19 082812

Major Secaucus ramp closure will force weeks of detours and delays

00:14
monroegoats

'You've GOAT to be kidding me.' Monroe EMS helps escaped herd find its way home

00:24
AP26282834609572

George Clooney transforms Westfield drug store into movie set

Credit: AP

McDonald's proposes Fair Lawn restaurant rebuild with dual-lane drive-through

AP18305743845572

Bon Jovi announces July 2027 concert at MetLife Stadium

00:29
Screenshot 2026-10-19 075524

Kitten rescued from Marlboro car wash finds forever home

01:51
10192026NJtoc_2026-10-19-05-35-37

Parkway exits in Toms River set for safety-related, $500M overhaul

00:23
car theft

Off-duty police captain injured confronting thieves stealing father's car

00:42
AP18305743845572

Record 7 NJ ZIP codes rank among nation's most expensive, report finds

00:22
Rutgers Alpha Sigma Phi Hazing Claims_2025-10-17-22-04-51

Tampered gas sources spark attempted arson and break-in probe in New Brunswick

00:29
HalloweenTravel1027NJLE_2023-10-27-12-29-46

Long Branch to enforce Halloween curfew for children under 17

00:27
RABIES ALERT

Rabid raccoon confirmed amid aggressive behavior reports in Bethlehem Township

00:23
police investigation police lights mon copy

Neighborhood disturbance triggers proposed short-term rental restrictions in Hoboken

02:07
RTNJWoodbridgeOEMDrillJFord10pm_2026-10-18-22-18-01

Woodbridge first responders stage school bus crash drill

00:24
fatal crash - mon copy (1)

Piscataway woman fatally struck after getting out of disabled vehicle on I-287

00:22
CarIntoHouseDover

Car crashes into house in Dover

01:36
ChallengerFlagFootball

More than a game: Point Pleasant flag football program builds confidence, friendships

01:50
BloomfieldTownHall5P_2026-10-18-17-09-47

Bloomfield residents voice concern over future of Watsessing neighborhood at town hall at 23 Skiddoo Cafe

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices