News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Toll of Commuting
Showers
59°
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Toll of Commuting

Message in a bottle tossed off Jersey Shore 54 years ago found in Bahamas

A message in a bottle thrown overboard back in 1971 off the Jersey Shore was found earlier this year on a remote island in the Bahamas. 

Jim Murdoch

•

Oct 9, 2025, 6:07 PM

•

Updated

Share:

More Stories

What's in a message?  

How about 50 years of history.

And for a Monmouth County family, it meant beloved memories of their late captain of the "Miss Belmar." 

A message in a bottle thrown overboard back in 1971 off the Jersey Shore was found earlier this year on a remote island in the Bahamas.   

By pure chance and luck, singer and songwriter Clint Buffington, on vacation from Utah, spotted what appeared to be a very special sealed bottle in the Southern Bahamas back in March, 50 to 100 feet away from the water.  

“I looked down and there’s this kind of gap in the bushes and walked through and there was this bottle, clear as day, Dr. Pepper label facing the sky. I could immediately tell it was old and saw that brown paper inside and just knew,” said Buffington.  

Then, the puzzle began. Who wrote it? Where did it come from? Clint took to Instagram, telling his story.  

“The message itself says sent off fishing boat Miss Belmar 90 miles east of Belmar Inlet, and that name there is John Forsyth,” Buffington narrated during an Instagram video post.   

Word soon reached Alan Shinn, the captain and owner of Miss Belmar, who contacted John’s sister Kathy, who then checked her late brother’s written logs. John passed away three years ago after retiring from a life of working on and around boats.  

“In 1971, it says in 1971, they went out to the canyon and they were 90 miles offshore, so that’s when I said one plus one equals two,” said Kathy Forsyth.   

The bottle likely got picked up by the North Atlantic Gyre, a looping current that took it on a journey from Hudson Canyon, to Europe, off Africa and to the Bahamas.  

Before becoming captain, John Forsyth was a mate on the Miss Belmar, and at 18 years old, the note was launched.  

“He was here first thing in the morning because he enjoyed being here so much,” said Alan Shinn.  

“Knowing my brother, he finished his lunch, he said, 'Aha,' wrote a note, stuffed it in there and just went 'Boop,' and I’m like there was no thought behind it,” said Forsyth.  

For Buffington, it was his 140th found message in a bottle, the oldest one to date.  

“Whatever path my life took me down, I happened to be in the right place on the right day. If we hadn’t decided to turn back looking on that beach,” he said.  

“Of all the people who could find it, his level of excitement is coming right through from my brother for sure. I’m so glad Clint found it,” added Kathy.  

Buffington said he wants to return the message he found in the bottle back to the Forsyth family, but he doesn’t want to put it in the mail.

Alan offered Clint and his whole family a free all-expense paid trip to Belmar so he could do that in person. 

Top Stories

Screenshot 2026-09-28 073838

LIVE UPDATES: Severe beach erosion and storm debris revealed along the Jersey Shore as storm pulls away

02:52
RizzoSM7

STORM WATCH: Nor'easter departs today, conditions improve by tonight

02:09
processed-0F33D722-6090-4883-BB31-4D487BAE012D

Transformer explosion sparks basement fire as family and pets escape Ho-Ho-Kus home

00:29
Screenshot 2026-09-28 064623

Jersey Shore star Pauly D gets engaged after surprise proposal at Caesars Palace

00:17
dog attack paws MONITOR copy

Sayreville officer shoots dog during attack on 3 family members

02:07
Screenshot 2026-09-28 073745

Made in New Jersey: From tragedy to thriving brewery, Jersey City business creates gluten-free beers for all

02:14
Screenshot 2026-09-28 054216

Toll of Commuting: Did NJ Transit experience another 'Summer of Hell?'

02:03
Screenshot 2026-09-28 054122

Scammers exploit missing pets with fake photos and demands for money, BBB says

01:48
LIPUMPKINAPPLE92826_2026-09-28-06-29-46

The Cost Of: Apple and pumpkin picking

01:02
Lt. Gov. Dale Caldwell

Former Lt. Gov. Dale Caldwell says he resigned to avoid distracting from Sherrill administration

00:13
fatal crash - mon copy (1)

21-year-old killed after car hits parked tractor-trailer on I-78 in Hunterdon County

03:15
Tier1 map

Voluntary evacuation issued for some Manasquan residents

Police-involved shooting

Man killed in Middle Township officer-involved shooting after woman found with stab wounds

00:19
Cobb Photo

Four accused of aiding fugitive murder suspect as search for Toms River man continues

00:32
GasPricesHitRecordHigh_2026-09-25-22-21-02

Gas prices on track to set new September record

AP26268019599199

Lt. Gov. Caldwell resigns after sexual harassment and ethics complaints

00:33
JerseyProudSponsored0925_2026-09-25-22-24-48

Jersey Proud: Fist bump Friday brings smiles to Phillipsburg schools

Drug Arrest - MONITOR copy (1)

3 women arrested in Jersey City drug bust, including 70-year-old facing gun charges

00:15
child hit by car SCHOOL CROSSING SIGN MON copy

Child injured after being struck by responding ambulance in Hoboken

fatal train strike

Trespasser fatally struck by NJ Transit train in Plainfield

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices