Defense questions firefighter in 'Black Sunday' trial

Firefighters who survived the deadly ?Black Sunday? blaze that claimed the lives of two of their colleagues in 2005 continued their testimony Wednesday. Retired firefighter Jeffrey Cool was pressed by

News 12 Staff

Jan 15, 2009, 1:44 AM

Updated 5,668 days ago

Share:

Firefighters who survived the deadly ?Black Sunday? blaze that claimed the lives of two of their colleagues in 2005 continued their testimony Wednesday.
Retired firefighter Jeffrey Cool was pressed by defense attorneys for using a personal safety rope to escape the burning building, even though the ropes were banned by the FDNY shortly before the incident. Cool suffered extensive injuries from the fall, despite his use of a safety rope. He broke his neck, back and 12 ribs, which ultimately forced him to retire from the department. The defense argued that had Lt. Curtis Meyran and John Bellew also had safety ropes in their possession that day, they may have survived the fall.
The three defendants in the trial, Cesar Rios, the building?s landlord, Rafael Castillo and Caridad Coste, are accused of erecting an illegal partitioning wall, which, according to Cool and prosecutors, made it more difficult for firefighters to contain the flames.
However, the defense has argued that had all the firefighters been equipped with safety ropes, the tragedy could have been averted.
During a cross examination, a defense attorney pointed to a media report, where Cool said the rope saved his life and could have helped his colleagues.
Cool responded by saying that he cannot be sure his statement was repeated word for word.
Also heard during the trial Wednesday were radio transcripts. One transcript included a firefighter reporting evacuation from the burning apartment by using the fire escape. The defense pointed out that this transcript included the only mention of people trapped inside, and also indicated the firefighters had time to access the escapes.
Cool says this was the first fire during which the Handie Talkie radios were recorded and transcripts may be missing.
The three other firefighters who survived the fire are expected to testify later in the trial.
Defendants in 'Black Sunday' case go on trial Tenant: 'Black Sunday' repeat possible at building


More from News 12
3:01
Monmouth University lockdown prompted by threatening email lifted

Monmouth University lockdown prompted by threatening email lifted

2:05
Rain showers this morning with overcast in New Jersey; tracking more rain for the week

Rain showers this morning with overcast in New Jersey; tracking more rain for the week

2:21
Emergency repairs set to wrap up this morning following fatal Route 3 crash in Clifton

Emergency repairs set to wrap up this morning following fatal Route 3 crash in Clifton

0:31
Son finds his mom stabbed to death in their Edison home; suspect charged with murder

Son finds his mom stabbed to death in their Edison home; suspect charged with murder

0:20
Health officials: West Nile virus, eastern equine encephalitis detected in Cape May County

Health officials: West Nile virus, eastern equine encephalitis detected in Cape May County

0:31
South Jersey pet groomer charged with animal cruelty following death of 3-year-old dog

South Jersey pet groomer charged with animal cruelty following death of 3-year-old dog

0:30
Toms River cuts Silverton EMS services

Toms River cuts Silverton EMS services

0:39
Are the Philadelphia 76ers considering move to New Jersey?

Are the Philadelphia 76ers considering move to New Jersey?

0:27
New York, New Jersey & Delaware sued for failing to protect endangered Atlantic sturgeon

New York, New Jersey & Delaware sued for failing to protect endangered Atlantic sturgeon

1:46
What you should know about a deadly nationwide listeria outbreak linked to deli meat

What you should know about a deadly nationwide listeria outbreak linked to deli meat

0:56
Jersey Proud: Photographer makes it his mission to take photos of every Catholic cathedral in the US

Jersey Proud: Photographer makes it his mission to take photos of every Catholic cathedral in the US

0:48
Senate Ethics Committee starts review of Sen. Bob Menendez's conduct following bribery conviction

Senate Ethics Committee starts review of Sen. Bob Menendez's conduct following bribery conviction

0:22
Wife of New York Yankees executive dies after being found unresponsive at home

Wife of New York Yankees executive dies after being found unresponsive at home

AP survey: Harris has enough delegate support to become the Democratic Party nominee

AP survey: Harris has enough delegate support to become the Democratic Party nominee

Police: Man faces charges for cutting head off seagull at the Jersey Shore

Police: Man faces charges for cutting head off seagull at the Jersey Shore

0:25
Seaside Park man arrested for fatal hit-and-run

Seaside Park man arrested for fatal hit-and-run

0:43
Officials: Firefighter injured battling house fire in Bayonne

Officials: Firefighter injured battling house fire in Bayonne

1:13
‘Palpable excitement.’ Rep. Sherrill expresses support for VP Harris’ presidential campaign

‘Palpable excitement.’ Rep. Sherrill expresses support for VP Harris’ presidential campaign

0:44
Repair Café holds repairing event at Jersey City church this past weekend

Repair Café holds repairing event at Jersey City church this past weekend

2:34
What are the next steps for Democrats as Biden drops out of 2024 presidential race?

What are the next steps for Democrats as Biden drops out of 2024 presidential race?