News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Toll of Commuting
Fair or Mostly Sunny
71°
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Toll of Commuting

Community devastated by fire at Rutherford synagogue

By early Friday evening, nothing remained of the former place of worship on Montross Avenue. The early-morning blaze was a four-alarm fire that residents say turned the dark sky orange.

Tom Krosnowski

Aug 8, 2025, 10:27 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

Neighbors in Rutherford were left heartbroken by Friday’s early-morning fire that destroyed Congregation Beth El synagogue and community center.

“We're shocked,” said Dennis Corwin, of Rutherford.

“It's devastating,” said a neighbor named Luisa. “It's very sad. It's a place of prayer, it's their safe place.”

By early Friday evening, nothing remained of the former place of worship on Montross Avenue. The early morning blaze was a four-alarm fire that residents say turned the dark sky orange.

On Friday afternoon, borough police said that the cause will remain unknown, but that according to an investigation by the Prosecutor’s Office’s Arson Squad, it is not believed to be criminal.

This was fortunate news for neighbors who remembered a 2012 incident where two people were arrested for firebombing the synagogue.

“All the craziness going on in the world right now, of course that would be top of mind with everyone,” Corwin said. “I'm glad to see that's not the situation.”

Traditional Saturday morning worship will be held outside. The property, which dates back over 100 years, has been a valued part of the Rutherford community in many forms.

“It was my father, Benedict Willis's, childhood home,” said Jeane Willis, who grew up in Rutherford. “It was a Victorian home, an old-fashioned northern New Jersey Victorian home.”

“Adjacent to the property, there's an indoor baseball training facility for Wladyka Baseball, and they train thousands of kids,” Corwin said. “From the looks of it, I don't know that the gym is going to be saved.”

There is a fundraiser on Beth El’s website, jewishrutherford.org, that gathered over $85,000 in barely 12 hours.

“Rutherford's the kind of town that will definitely embrace the rabbi and his family and help them along,” Corwin said.

“We are all holding this community in our hearts and in our hands to hope to rebuild,” said Willis.

Top Stories

faa_2025-11-06-22-20-59

Flights are disrupted across the US Northeast due to technical problems at a key air traffic center

02:07
Screenshot 2026-09-21 152637

Coastal flooding the bigger issue over rain threat this week in New Jersey

01:49
Lavallette

Lavallette restaurant remains closed after woman killed when car crashes into outdoor dining area

00:18
motorcycle crash

Linden police officer seriously injured in motorcycle crash during funeral procession

00:29
School Break-In

4 juveniles detained after breaking into 2 schools overnight with fake rifle

attorney general

Former Trenton Water Works employee sentenced to 3 years for falsifying test records

00:25
9212026NJdirtbike_2026-09-21-11-27-40

Teen accused of fleeing police twice on illegal dirt bike in Riverside arrested in Delran

00:23
Horses on the loose

Officers rein in runaway horses in Montville

Car into lake

Driver rescued after car plunges into water in Manchester

01:29
Screenshot 2026-09-21 052509

Diesel prices hit record highs, raising concerns about cost of everyday goods

02:04
9212026Allcostof_2026-09-21-09-13-06

The Cost Of: Fall Sports

03:04
MTNJCycleBar8p0206_2024-02-06-20-25-23

Cyclebar instructor goes viral on social media with message of positivity

02:05
9212026WCtara_2026-09-21-05-42-35

Booking holiday travel? Why you and your family may see different flight prices

02:00
Screenshot 2026-09-21 080124

Made in New Jersey: Jersey Shore entrepreneur transforms Atlantic seawater into a growing business

00:40
Screenshot 2026-09-21 065840

Olympic gold medalist Dominique Dawes opens new gymnastics academy in New Jersey

00:28
Screenshot 2026-09-21 054947

Traffic to crawl through Manhattan as UN General Assembly brings year's worst gridlock

02:01
9212026NJtoc_2026-09-21-05-24-57

'Fair Fares' advocates push NJ Transit for income-based discount program

00:29
NYULangone921_2026-09-21-06-04-12

NYU Langone to end pediatric gender-affirming care following DOJ investigation

01:44
RTNJSeaHearNowInRainCQueally10pm_2026-09-20-22-11-37

Chance of rain doesn't stop thousands of music lovers to rush to Sea.Hear.Now in Asbury Park

00:32
Ernie Accorsi

Ernie Accorsi, Hall of Fame NFL executive and former Giants GM, dies at 84

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices