News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Weather
Crime
Politics
Toll of Commuting
Homeless Youth In Crisis
Hot Toys
Clear
42°
Local
Weather
Crime
Politics
Toll of Commuting
Homeless Youth In Crisis
Hot Toys

Town of Babylon proposes 5.8% tax hike; Supervisor takes pay cut amid resident backlash

At a recent public hearing, several residents voiced frustration over the proposed increase, arguing that local taxes have become increasingly difficult to afford.

Kevin Vesey

•

Nov 13, 2026, 5:32 PM

•

Updated

Share:

More Stories

The Town of Babylon is proposing a 5.8% property tax increase for next year, a move that would exceed New York's state tax cap and has drawn criticism from residents already grappling with rising costs.

At a recent public hearing, several residents voiced frustration over the proposed increase, arguing that local taxes have become increasingly difficult to afford.

"The tax bills are just crazy," said Deer Park resident Joseph Prevete.

Prevete said the proposed increase could force some longtime residents out of the community.

"I was born and raised here all my life and now I have to leave my town because you're taxing me out of it," he said. "I think that's wrong."

Town officials say the proposed budget would increase the average town tax bill by approximately $113 next year. For residents who live in incorporated villages, the increase would average about $74.

Babylon Town Supervisor Rich Schaffer said the tax increase is largely driven by rising pension obligations and employee healthcare costs, challenges he said municipalities across the region are facing.

"We are experiencing the same difficulties that all other towns are," Schaffer said.

He defended the spending plan, saying officials sought to balance fiscal realities with maintaining services for residents.

"We understand the economy and the way things are, but we felt it was important to present an honest budget that was going to protect services," Schaffer said.

The proposed tax increase was initially expected to be even higher. Town officials removed planned raises for elected officials, including the supervisor, from the budget. Schaffer said he will instead take a $3,700 pay cut next year.

"I'm serious about the challenges we face, so I cut my salary for next year," Schaffer said.

Still, many residents remain unconvinced.

Opponents of the plan pointed out that Babylon officials also voted to exceed the state tax cap in both 2024 and 2025, raising concerns that the practice is becoming routine rather than exceptional.

"Why are we doing it?" asked Deer Park resident Kristin Schuster during the hearing. "You're only supposed to pierce the cap occasionally. Not every two years."

Town officials have said they expect to remain within the state tax cap in 2028 and 2029.

The Babylon Town Board is expected to vote on the proposed budget Wednesday.

Top Stories

00:23
Image (22)

Fire erupts near MetLife Stadium following NY Jets game

02:20
FB Temp Feel Morning

Mostly sunny and cool Monday before 60-degree temperatures make a comeback in New Jersey

APGroundStop11142026At10pmSG001

LIVE UPDATES: Trump administration asks for billions to overhaul FAA. Democrats question how money was spent

01:50
RTNJRoxburyICEDetentCenterProtestCQueally10pm_2026-11-15-22-07-44

Hundreds protest proposed ICE detention center at Rockaway Mall

00:22
5986

Suspect posing as delivery person sought in Middletown attempted robbery

01:41
28CatsRescuedPaterson_2026-11-15-17-10-27

Ramapo Bergen animal refuge seeking help for dozens of cats rescued from Paterson home

00:16
902962061 1846034313077629 8074231276345730131 n

9 arrested in major Passaic County drug bust

Hinchliffe Historic

From Negro League baseball to a second life: The remarkable history of Paterson’s Hinchliffe Stadium

01:44
RTNJSexAssaultProtectBillCQueally10pm_2026-11-14-22-18-48

NJ bill aims to help sexual assault victims who take drugs, drink alcohol

Passaic City Hall TN

Developer says no market-rate apartments planned for 106-unit Passaic project

Joseph Severini Mug Blur

Teacher from Woodbridge charged in child sexual abuse material investigation

00:17
House Fire Generic

Homeowner rescued from roof during house fire in Hunterdon County

AP24017775186772 Snowflake

Bergen County Winter Wonderland to return to Van Saun Park on Nov. 27

26242

Perth Amboy honors 3 fallen police officers with boat dedications and street naming

00:54
image (11)

FDU women's basketball takes 10-hour bus ride after nationwide ground stop

00:15
dwi arrest

Driver arrested on DWI charge after crashing into NJ Transit bus in Rahway

A12A6872-1794705278880-594db9b9-8236-4a22-a770-b44c0ff45417

Red Bulls player scores in U.S. national team's 6-0 win over Haiti

00:14
sex abuse sentence

Hackettstown man sentenced to 40 years in child sexual assault case

01:46
PatersonEbikeRestrictions_2026-11-14-17-27-12

Paterson proposes restrictions on E-bikes and scooters

00:25
Jersey City

Jersey City to begin camera-assisted parking enforcement pilot next week in downtown, Journal Square

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices