News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Weather
Crime
Politics
Toll of Commuting
Homeless Youth In Crisis
Hot Toys
40°
Local
Weather
Crime
Politics
Toll of Commuting
Homeless Youth In Crisis
Hot Toys

'Carving not on actual product': Reese's adds disclaimer after lawsuit over pumpkin candy design

Printed directly beneath an illustration of a pumpkin-shaped face.

Pedro Carmona

•

Oct 8, 2026, 9:57 AM

•

Updated

Share:

More Stories

If you pick up a pack of Reese’s Peanut Butter Pumpkins this Halloween, you might notice a small but notable change on the wrapper.

The Hershey Company has added a new disclaimer to its iconic seasonal candy packaging, printed directly beneath an illustration of a pumpkin-shaped treat featuring a carved jack-o’-lantern face.

The new label reads: “CARVING NOT ON ACTUAL PRODUCT.”

The update replaces the phrase “Decorating Suggestion,” which previously occupied the spot on older wrappers.

The change follows the dismissal of a federal lawsuit filed against Hershey that alleged deceptive marketing. Plaintiffs in the suit argued that the company tricked consumers by displaying detailed, carved faces on the outer packaging while the actual peanut butter cups inside were blank and featureless.

A federal judge dismissed the case, ruling that the lack of carved features amounted to subjective consumer disappointment rather than an actionable legal injury or product defect.

Despite winning the court challenge, Hershey opted to update the packaging fine print to leave no ambiguity for shoppers heading into the holiday season.

Top Stories

AP26317776750151

LIVE UPDATES: FAA lifts nationwide ground stop on flights that halted travel across the US

02:14
F P1 PM

STORM WATCH: Cold rain showers continue on and off through the evening

01:43
REChesterfieldTwpTornadopart2_2026-11-13-17-58-19

Chesterfield tornado rated EF-1 with 100 mph winds 

TURKEYPIC

Stop & Shop launches Thanksgiving meal deal with turkey, sides and pie for under $40

01:35
crash investigation - MONITOR copy

New Jersey AG releases findings on Linden car crash that critically injured a family of 3

00:42
MTNJMonsterTattoo1113_2026-11-13-18-05-49

Elizabeth tattoo shop packed for Friday the 13th ‘flash’ sale

01:13
Screenshot 2026-11-13 080944

News 12 viewers capture first snow of the season in northern New Jersey

04:35
Screenshot 2026-11-13 121112

STORM WRANGLER 12: Snowflakes fly in Sussex County as New Jersey sees its first snowfall of the season

00:17
HandcuffsLights

Middletown police sergeant suspended without pay after DUI arrest

00:19
scam alert

Union County sheriff warns residents about phone scam impersonating officers

01:08
EmailOutageReactions1113NJTA_2026-11-13-06-03-06

Some NJ residents say they were happy about the Microsoft Outlook outage

901046660 18370766599244073 4690852545361068123 n

Heavy fire draws multiple departments to Bridgewater residential structure

00:21
murder chaqrges

Son accused of killing 63-year-old father in Hunterdon County

00:25
NJPotentionalMeaslesExposure_2026-11-13-17-15-48

Measles exposure alert issued for multiple NJ sites. Here’s what you need to know

01:44
701d04d9-33b2-44c3-8011-84f4570e789b

Paws & Pals: Meet Milo, a friendly poodle who loves people and playtime

image (11)

Macy's reveals new balloons, floats and performers for landmark 100th Thanksgiving Day Parade

01:36
Screenshot 2026-11-13 063519

Step inside Minecraft: New immersive experience opens at American Dream

01:18
1113HOTTOYS_2026-11-13-06-09-54

Hot Toys: Holiday shopping hacks

02:22
Screenshot 2026-11-12 182932

News 12 field crew takes shelter in basement while tornado chasing

01:47
original-5E707D16-ADE4-4805-AA9A-6CDD40F8F3DE

Truck driver killed after tractor-trailer overturns, catches fire on New Jersey Turnpike

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices