Attorney seeks mistrial after murder trial juror’s social media post

The defense attorney for a Monmouth County man accused of killing a childhood friend is seeking a mistrial after a juror posted about the case on social media.

News 12 Staff

Feb 13, 2019, 5:06 PM

Updated 1,909 days ago

Share:

The defense attorney for a Monmouth County man accused of killing a childhood friend is seeking a mistrial after a juror posted about the case on social media.
The juror has since been dismissed from the case. Monmouth County Superior Court Judge Richard English questioned each of the remaining jurors about the Facebook post to see what they knew.
Some said that they knew Juror 13 posted something about the trial on Facebook, but others said that they knew nothing about it.
Defense attorney Carols Diaz-Cobo asked for a continuance to the trial Wednesday because he said he needs time to put together an argument for a mistrial.
“We believe there are issues that would cause a potential mistrial in this case and deals with my client’s Sixth Amendment right to a fair trial,” Diaz-Cobo said.
But the prosecution argued that a mistrial is not needed. Assistant Monmouth County Prosecutor Meghan Doyle said that the Facebook post made by Juror 13 simply stated that she was on the jury for the case.
"Nothing about the facts of this case were discussed in that Facebook post. No one read the article. Not one juror knew anything about the contents of it, where it was posted, or anything like that,” Doyle said.
Liam McAtasney is accused of strangling his childhood friend Sarah Stern in December 2016 and throwing her body off the Route 35 Bridge into the Shark River below. Prosecutors say that he did this in order to steal thousands of dollars that Stern had recently inherited.
Jurors last week watched a secretly recorded video where McAtasney appeared to tell a friend about the slaying in great detail.
The prosecution called Diaz-Cobo’s attempt to get a mistrial a delay tactic in order to attempt to further the recording from the minds of the jury.
Judge English called a recess to allow both parties to research and consider a motion for mistrial. But he also warned the jury about the rules.
“I’m going to indicate again and warn you not to go on Facebook at all, to put up anything relevant to this case, to do any independent research on this case or review media articles,” he said.
Jurors were told to be back in court Thursday at 10:30 a.m. The prosecution has two more witnesses to call to the stand – both investigators with the Monmouth County Prosecutor’ Office. Then they are expected to rest their case.
The defense will present their case next, which should include three to five witnesses.


More from News 12
2:09
Middletown moves forward with cheaper parking to offset NJ Transit fare increase

Middletown moves forward with cheaper parking to offset NJ Transit fare increase

1:36
Early storms Tuesday followed by partial sun; temps warm to upper-70s

Early storms Tuesday followed by partial sun; temps warm to upper-70s

0:48
Authorities: Construction worker suffers fatal fall into trench at Kenilworth site

Authorities: Construction worker suffers fatal fall into trench at Kenilworth site

0:21
Rutgers president to testify before Congress on antisemitism on college campuses

Rutgers president to testify before Congress on antisemitism on college campuses

2:06
First weekend of Newark’s youth curfew debuts to great success

First weekend of Newark’s youth curfew debuts to great success

1:41
Death of New Jersey state trooper during training incident prompts investigation

Death of New Jersey state trooper during training incident prompts investigation

0:50
Jersey Proud: Somerset charter school competes in World Robotics Championship in Texas

Jersey Proud: Somerset charter school competes in World Robotics Championship in Texas

0:16
Police: Hoboken man facing weapons charges in road rage incident

Police: Hoboken man facing weapons charges in road rage incident

2:42
Jersey Shore surfer whose 20-foot wipeout went viral helps rescue struggling swimmer

Jersey Shore surfer whose 20-foot wipeout went viral helps rescue struggling swimmer

2:11
Seniors learn about potential scams as Rep. Gottheimer introduces legislation to protect them

Seniors learn about potential scams as Rep. Gottheimer introduces legislation to protect them

0:42
New Jersey florists prep orders for Mother’s Day celebrations

New Jersey florists prep orders for Mother’s Day celebrations

0:22
Upgrades underway at Newark Liberty International Airport’s Terminal A

Upgrades underway at Newark Liberty International Airport’s Terminal A

1:32
How to prepare for spotted lanternfly season

How to prepare for spotted lanternfly season

0:25
Officials: 2 firefighters hospitalized; dog dies in Wayne house fire

Officials: 2 firefighters hospitalized; dog dies in Wayne house fire

0:19
Fire officials: Driver extricated from car following Lyndhurst crash

Fire officials: Driver extricated from car following Lyndhurst crash

0:29
Department of Justice: 2 men sentenced for defrauding JetBlue Airways of $10 million

Department of Justice: 2 men sentenced for defrauding JetBlue Airways of $10 million

0:59
Jersey Buzz: Newark's Frankie Valli receives star on Hollywood Walk of Fame

Jersey Buzz: Newark's Frankie Valli receives star on Hollywood Walk of Fame

0:26
Three groups are suing New Jersey to block an offshore wind farm

Three groups are suing New Jersey to block an offshore wind farm

1:59
Asian Pacific American Heritage: News 12 speaks to 1st woman & Asian-American to lead New Jersey National Guard

Asian Pacific American Heritage: News 12 speaks to 1st woman & Asian-American to lead New Jersey National Guard

1:55
'Real Housewives' star Margaret Joseph's Soiree mocktail is Made In New Jersey

'Real Housewives' star Margaret Joseph's Soiree mocktail is Made In New Jersey