Sarah Stern jury hears first police interview with alleged killer
Posted: Updated:Jurors in the Sarah Stern murder trial heard the first interview that defendant Liam McAtasney gave to police.
The interview was conducted in December 2016, not long after Stern was reported missing. Police spoke with McAtasney because he was the last person to see Stern before she went missing.
McAtasney is heard telling detectives, “Over the past few weeks she was packing up things in containers and moving them to other people’s houses.”
When asked if he thought that the behavior was strange, McAtasney admitted that he did at first, “but she always wanted to go to Canada.”
McAtasney is heard multiple times in the interview alluding to the fact that Stern may have wanted to run away from home or even commit suicide.
RELATED: Father testifies about moments leading up to daughter’s disappearance
RELATED: Sarah Stern murder trial Day 3: Jurors view police body cam footage of defendant
But prosecutors say that McAtasney strangled Stern in her home in order to get money that she has recently inherited. They say that he and accomplice Preston Taylor drove Stern’s car to the Route 35 Bridge in Belmar and threw her body into the Shark River.
During the interview, McAtasney asks about the possibility of Stern’s body being in the water.
“One thing I kind of wanted to talk to you guys about was, if she did jump off the bridge, what are the odds that she’s not somewhere all the way out in the ocean by now?” he is heard asking.
RELATED: Man on trial for killing of classmate driven to tears during testimony
RELATED: ‘He stuffed a scarf down her throat’ – Trial begins for man accused of killing childhood friend
When detective ask McAtasney if Stern told him that she was going to jump, he said “No.”
Jurors also heard from three Monmouth County Prosecutor Office investigators who spoke about some of the key evidence in the case – including a safe that was found buried that apparently contained Stern’s money.
Investigator Bryan Muller testified that Taylor brought him to the location where the safe was buried.
“You can see loose dirt and soil and that’s where Mr. Taylor had said, ‘Here’s the tree that had fallen, and the soil. This was the result of us burying it.’ So he knew he had the right spot at this point,” Muller testified.
Taylor has pleaded guilty to his role in the crime and testified for the prosecution.
The trial is expected to continue Thursday.
Stern’s body has never been found.
CrimeMore>>
Police: Union man mugged pregnant NJ Transit bus driver
Police: Union man mugged pregnant NJ Transit bus driver
Police say a Union man mugged a pregnant NJ Transit bus driver in Elizabeth.Police say a Union man mugged a pregnant NJ Transit bus driver in Elizabeth.Whoops! Thief confuses police car for getaway Lyft, police say
Whoops! Thief confuses police car for getaway Lyft, police say
Rochelle Park police were able to arrest an alleged thief after he mistook a police cruiser for the ride-share car he ordered as a getaway vehicle.Rochelle Park police were able to arrest an alleged thief after he mistook a police cruiser for the ride-share car he ordered as a getaway vehicle.Police warn drivers not to leave cars idling amid rash of thefts
Police warn drivers not to leave cars idling amid rash of thefts
The Newark Police Department is reminding city residents not to leave their cars idling to warm them up in the winter after a series of car thefts.The Newark Police Department is reminding city residents not to leave their cars idling to warm them up in the winter after a series of car thefts.Woman in videotaped Wildwood beach arrest accepts plea deal
Woman in videotaped Wildwood beach arrest accepts plea deal
A Philadelphia woman whose violent arrest at the Jersey Shore over Memorial Day weekend last year was captured on video has pleaded guilty to disorderly conductA Philadelphia woman whose violent arrest at the Jersey Shore over Memorial Day weekend last year was captured on video has pleaded guilty to disorderly conductPolice: Woman bit officer, resisted arrest
Police: Woman bit officer, resisted arrest
A Sussex County woman is accused of biting a police officer.A Sussex County woman is accused of biting a police officer.Prosecutors: Man had thousands of child pornography videos, images
Prosecutors: Man had thousands of child pornography videos, images
A man from Westfield who allegedly had thousands of child porn videos and images is now facing numerous charges.A man from Westfield who allegedly had thousands of child porn videos and images is now facing numerous charges.Homeland Security: 90 shipments of MDMA seized so far this year
Homeland Security: 90 shipments of MDMA seized so far this year
Officials with the Department of Homeland Security joined U.S. Custom and Border Protection officials to discuss recent seizures of the drug MDMA.Officials with the Department of Homeland Security joined U.S. Custom and Border Protection officials to discuss recent seizures of the drug MDMA.Grand jury indicts man accused of leaving caged pit bull to drown in rising tide
Grand jury indicts man accused of leaving caged pit bull to drown in rising tide
A Monmouth County grand jury has indicted a man accused of leaving a young pit bull mix to drown in a cage at water's edge during a rising tide last summer.A Monmouth County grand jury has indicted a man accused of leaving a young pit bull mix to drown in a cage at water's edge during a rising tide last summer.Former Christie staffer to appeal ‘Bridgegate’ conviction to Supreme Court
Former Christie staffer to appeal ‘Bridgegate’ conviction to Supreme Court
A former staffer to former Republican Gov. Chris Christie plans to appeal her conviction in the “Bridgegate” George Washington Bridge lane-closing case.A former staffer to former Republican Gov. Chris Christie plans to appeal her conviction in the “Bridgegate” George Washington Bridge lane-closing case.NJ camera program helps expose elder abuse at facility
NJ camera program helps expose elder abuse at facility
A home health aide is facing charges after allegedly assaulting an elderly woman at an assisted living facility in Bergen County.A home health aide is facing charges after allegedly assaulting an elderly woman at an assisted living facility in Bergen County.
Top StoriesTop StoriesMore>>
$26K raised for families left homeless by Fort Lee fire
$26K raised for families left homeless by Fort Lee fire
Demolition began on parts of a Fort Lee apartment that was decimated by a massive fire last week.Demolition began on parts of a Fort Lee apartment that was decimated by a massive fire last week.Forecast: More snow, sleet to return Wednesday
Forecast: More snow, sleet to return Wednesday
Here's the latest News 12 weather update.
Here's the latest News 12 weather update.
Mobile 12: Slick roads Monday morning following wintry mix
Mobile 12: Slick roads Monday morning following wintry mix
News 12's Tony Caputo is in Mobile 12 to get a look at the roads for the Presidents' Day morning commute following Sunday's snow and rain.News 12's Tony Caputo is in Mobile 12 to get a look at the roads for the Presidents' Day morning commute following Sunday's snow and rain.Mind Game Monday: Presidents' Day Trivia
Mind Game Monday: Presidents' Day Trivia
Today is Presidents' Day! But how much do you know about our presidents? Test your knowledge with our quiz.Today is Presidents' Day! But how much do you know about our presidents? Test your knowledge with our quiz.Poll: National Drink Wine Day
Poll: National Drink Wine Day
Happy National Drink Wine Day! Do you enjoy wine?Happy National Drink Wine Day! Do you enjoy wine?Authorities: 2 hurt following brawl at McMahon Park
Authorities: 2 hurt following brawl at McMahon Park
A man has been charged with aggravated assault following a park fight that left two people hurt.A man has been charged with aggravated assault following a park fight that left two people hurt.Historic cricket clubhouse to be restored after 50 years
Historic cricket clubhouse to be restored after 50 years
Paterson is restoring a historic cricket clubhouse after 50 years.Paterson is restoring a historic cricket clubhouse after 50 years.Legalization of marijuana may be on the horizon
Legalization of marijuana may be on the horizon
A deal to legalize recreational marijuana in New Jersey may be one step closer to becoming a reality.A deal to legalize recreational marijuana in New Jersey may be one step closer to becoming a reality.Jersey Buzz: Feb. 18, 2019
Jersey Buzz: Feb. 18, 2019
Jersey Buzz: Feb. 18, 2019Jersey Buzz: Feb. 18, 2019Really good neighbor: Woman donates kidney to save man's life
Really good neighbor: Woman donates kidney to save man's life
A good neighbor may pick up your mail or even let you have a cup of sugar, but a Morris County woman went one step further - she gave up a kidney to save a man's life.A good neighbor may pick up your mail or even let you have a cup of sugar, but a Morris County woman went one step further - she gave up a kidney to save a man's life.