Meet Lenny Cathcart – New Jersey’s biggest San Francisco 49ers fan

There is one New Jersey man who is such a big fan of the San Francisco 49ers that he put a home improvement project on hold in order to ensure that the team went to the Super Bowl.

News 12 Staff

Jan 30, 2020, 1:15 AM

Updated 1,538 days ago

Share:

Sports fans are notoriously superstitious and often have their own rituals to bring their teams luck.
There is one New Jersey man who is such a big fan of the San Francisco 49ers that he put a home improvement project on hold in order to ensure that the team went to the Super Bowl.
Lenny Cathcart of Plainfield has a home filled with 49ers memorabilia. There are helmets games balls, signed jerseys and personal photos of legendary wide receiver Jerry Rice.
“That’s Jerry calling my wife from his retirement party,” Cathcart says while showing off a photograph.
He keeps all of the items in his “49ers Cave,” a finished basement displaying all of his treasures. It is also where he watches the team play.
“When I’m watching my games, I don’t allow anyone down my basement,” he says.
But the 49er Cave is in shambles now that the team is heading to the Super Bowl on Sunday. See, Cathcart was having the place painted and renovated earlier this fall. But when the 49ers beat the Seattle Seahawks on Dec. 29, he told the contractor to go away.
“And I haven't let them back down there since. Because we haven't lost since,” he says.
Like any sports fan, Cathcart says that he can’t do anything to blow his team’s chances of winning. He says that he wanted to have renovations done in time for the Super Bowl – but now he will delay the project.
“I can’t. I can’t touch it,” he says.
Cathcart says that he is just doing his part for a team that he loves. A team that seems to love him back. Cathcart is practically an honorary member of the 49ers organization. All of the memorabilia pieces were purchases with just Cathcart’s infectious personality.
“I have a way of getting things. I talk to people. Everybody knows my passion,” he says.
49ers owner John York befriended Cathcart and gives him good seats to the game or two he sees every year in San Francisco. Cathcart will be at all the team events and parties and of course the game itself on Sunday.
“My goal is, when that confetti is coming down, I just want to lay there. Just one time. That's my goal,” he says.
If the 49ers do win on Sunday, it may just be because of Cathcart’s efforts.
Cathcart says he became a 49ers fan in the 1980s because of his appreciation of Jerry Rice, and also to stick it to his friends who are fans of the rival Dallas Cowboys.


More from News 12
FAA: Small plane crashes at Sussex Airport

FAA: Small plane crashes at Sussex Airport

2:24
Clear and sunny today in New Jersey with highs in the 70s; rain returns Wednesday

Clear and sunny today in New Jersey with highs in the 70s; rain returns Wednesday

2:01
Sea Girt officials expect beach entrance where toddler got trapped in sand to reopen in May

Sea Girt officials expect beach entrance where toddler got trapped in sand to reopen in May

0:32
Investigation finds deficiencies in Essex County’s $40 million COVID-19 vaccination program

Investigation finds deficiencies in Essex County’s $40 million COVID-19 vaccination program

0:57
Wawa celebrates 60th anniversary with free coffee

Wawa celebrates 60th anniversary with free coffee

0:17
AMC Theatres at Menlo Park Mall in Edison completes multimillion-dollar renovations

AMC Theatres at Menlo Park Mall in Edison completes multimillion-dollar renovations

0:08
CDC warns of counterfeit Botox in 9 states, including New Jersey and New York

CDC warns of counterfeit Botox in 9 states, including New Jersey and New York

0:22
Police: 3 drivers hospitalized with head injuries following Manchester crash

Police: 3 drivers hospitalized with head injuries following Manchester crash

1:37
Elizabeth roadway reopens following New Jersey Turnpike crash that sent debris falling onto ground

Elizabeth roadway reopens following New Jersey Turnpike crash that sent debris falling onto ground

0:18
Authorities: Crips gang member charged with racketeering, murder that left ‘trail of blood’

Authorities: Crips gang member charged with racketeering, murder that left ‘trail of blood’

1:39
Best of New Jersey visits popular seafood spot Angry Archies in Jersey City

Best of New Jersey visits popular seafood spot Angry Archies in Jersey City

0:16
NJ Transit rail service resumes on Northeast Corridor between Trenton and Rahway following overhead wire issues

NJ Transit rail service resumes on Northeast Corridor between Trenton and Rahway following overhead wire issues

0:27
Jets 'return to roots' with new uniforms that pay tribute to team's 'New York Sack Exchange' look

Jets 'return to roots' with new uniforms that pay tribute to team's 'New York Sack Exchange' look

Guide: Alcohol addiction recovery support and resources

Guide: Alcohol addiction recovery support and resources

Eagles lock in WR DeVonta Smith with 3-year contract extension

Eagles lock in WR DeVonta Smith with 3-year contract extension

0:18
2 best friends from New Jersey split $1 million Powerball prize

2 best friends from New Jersey split $1 million Powerball prize

2:08
Prosecutor: Montclair police officer injured in shootout; suspect also hospitalized

Prosecutor: Montclair police officer injured in shootout; suspect also hospitalized

1:47
Officials investigate 2 homes possibly damaged by 4.8 magnitude earthquake

Officials investigate 2 homes possibly damaged by 4.8 magnitude earthquake

0:39
Jersey Proud: Preschool students hold fundraiser for Make-A-Wish

Jersey Proud: Preschool students hold fundraiser for Make-A-Wish

2:29
Prosecutor: Atlantic City mayor, wife accused of physically abusing teen daughter

Prosecutor: Atlantic City mayor, wife accused of physically abusing teen daughter