Good Samaritan helps return lost Hanukkah card with $180 inside

A good Samaritan found a Hanukkah card with nearly $200 inside and made it his mission to find the owner.

News 12 Staff

Dec 27, 2019, 3:19 AM

Updated 1,580 days ago

Share:

It was a Hanukkah miracle right here in the Garden State.
A good Samaritan found a Hanukkah card with nearly $200 inside and made it his mission to find the owner.
Josh Israel says that he found the Hanukkah card outside a sushi restaurant in Montgomery Township on Christmas Day. The card said “Dear Ben, With my love. Grandma” and had $180 in cash inside.
Israel said that he wanted to find Ben or at least Grandma so that he could return the money. He posted about the find on Twitter and tagged some larger accounts, including News 12 New Jersey.
"I tagged you know, folks that I knew who might have way more followers than me that I knew would retweet it,” he says.
In less than 24 hours he was contacted by Amy Rosenthal who manages Congregation Kehilat Shalom's membership database.
"The power of social media is strong here because one person told the next, told the next, told the next, and it came through to me eventually,” Rosenthal says. "I have the history of all of our members, so I looked up all of our Bens."
Rosenthal says that she called and messaged all of the Bens and eventually found the right Ben’s mother.
"She started screaming basically - as much as you can on social media, all caps, very excited,” says Rosenthal.
It turns out that Ben had been eating at the restaurant on Christmas Day and accidentally left the card behind in the parking lot. Israel and his friend dropped the card and the money off at the synagogue on Thursday.
“I feel good about it. It feels good to do a nice thing, especially around the holidays,” Israel says.
Rosenthal says that she plans to return the card and the money to Ben’s family this weekend. She says that says Ben and his family asked her for Israel's contact information so that they can personally thank him.


More from News 12
0:51
Wildfire in Wharton State Forest consumes more than 400 acres of land

Wildfire in Wharton State Forest consumes more than 400 acres of land

1:36
Isolated storms tonight; freeze warning in effect for parts of NJ overnight

Isolated storms tonight; freeze warning in effect for parts of NJ overnight

2:54
Longtime Democratic US Rep. Donald Payne Jr. dies at 65 following heart attack

Longtime Democratic US Rep. Donald Payne Jr. dies at 65 following heart attack

1:53
Shop Mother’s Day Gifts – Exclusive Offers Up to 75% OFF!

Shop Mother’s Day Gifts – Exclusive Offers Up to 75% OFF!

0:56
Passaic to get $1.6M in federal funds to reduce flash flooding where 2 people died

Passaic to get $1.6M in federal funds to reduce flash flooding where 2 people died

2:56
Doctors combine a pig kidney transplant and a heart device in a bid to extend New Jersey woman's life

Doctors combine a pig kidney transplant and a heart device in a bid to extend New Jersey woman's life

2:23
'The tower is an eyesore.' Demolition of former Nabisco factory tower set to begin after 1-year delay

'The tower is an eyesore.' Demolition of former Nabisco factory tower set to begin after 1-year delay

1:03
Rep. Gottheimer announces another attempt to put an end to NYC’s congestion pricing plan

Rep. Gottheimer announces another attempt to put an end to NYC’s congestion pricing plan

0:29
Former Wawa gas attendant accused of stealing thousands of dollars from customers

Former Wawa gas attendant accused of stealing thousands of dollars from customers

1:33
AAA: New Jersey gas prices increase nearly 20 cents from last week

AAA: New Jersey gas prices increase nearly 20 cents from last week

2:12
Princeton University accused of violating civil rights of Jewish students

Princeton University accused of violating civil rights of Jewish students

0:37
Prosecutors: Former Jersey City police officer charged with sex assault, criminal restraint

Prosecutors: Former Jersey City police officer charged with sex assault, criminal restraint

0:27
Washington Township police issues warning over 'Water Wars' game

Washington Township police issues warning over 'Water Wars' game

0:34
Camden County man charged in crash that killed young mother

Camden County man charged in crash that killed young mother

2:18
Remnants of bird flu virus found in pasteurized milk, FDA says

Remnants of bird flu virus found in pasteurized milk, FDA says

0:32
US banning TikTok? Your key questions answered

US banning TikTok? Your key questions answered

0:35
Bon Jovi docuseries premieres Friday on Hulu

Bon Jovi docuseries premieres Friday on Hulu

0:31
New federal rule would bar 'noncompete' agreements for most employees

New federal rule would bar 'noncompete' agreements for most employees

1:02
Composting can save money, help gardens and save the planet. Here are 10 tips to get you started

Composting can save money, help gardens and save the planet. Here are 10 tips to get you started

1:38
What's Cooking: Uncle Giuseppe's Marketplace's Key Lime Pie

What's Cooking: Uncle Giuseppe's Marketplace's Key Lime Pie