Defense witness says he saw Sarah Stern alive after she was reported missing
Posted: Updated:A witness testified Wednesday that he saw Sarah Stern alive after she was supposedly murdered.
Craig Hetzel, Sr., a contractor from Neptune, testified for the defense that he saw Stern alive one day after she was allegedly strangled by childhood friend Liam McAtasney.
Stern was reported missing Dec. 2, 2016, sparking a large search effort. Hetzel testified that he saw Stern on Dec. 3.
“When I pulled up to the door, there was a picture of a girl. I said to my son, I said, ‘That’s who we saw. That’s who I saw that day,’” Hetzel testified, adding that there was “no doubt” in his mind that the girl he saw was Stern.
Earlier in the day, the prosecution called their final two witnesses to testify – both detectives from the Monmouth County Prosecutor’s Office.
RELATED: Judge dismisses 2nd juror; denies mistrial request in Sarah Stern murder trial
RELATED: ‘It took me a half-hour to kill her' - Secret recording played at Sarah Stern trial
One detective testified about a timer on a phone McAtasney is accused of using to time how long it took to allegedly strangle Stern. That time was mentioned by McAtasney during a hidden video that the jury saw earlier in the trial where McAtasney appeared to describe how Stern died.
McAtasney is accused of killing Stern so that he could steal thousands of dollars she recently received. Prosecutors say that McAtasney and accomplice Preston Taylor then threw Stern’s body off the Route 35 Bridge into the Shark River below. Stern’s body has never been found.
Taylor pleaded guilty to his role in the crime and testified for the prosecution.
The trial is expected to resume Thursday. Defense witnesses expected to speak include McAtasney’s mother and a private investigator hired by the defense team.
CrimeMore>>
Mayor Fulop calls Jersey City shootings a hate crime; police still seek motive
Mayor Fulop calls Jersey City shootings a hate crime; police still seek motive
Mayor Steve Fulop says this was a targeted attack against the Jewish community and it should be labeled as such. Police say they are not ready to label the shootings just yet.Mayor Steve Fulop says this was a targeted attack against the Jewish community and it should be labeled as such. Police say they are not ready to label the shootings just yet.Man arrested at scene of fire that destroyed Franklin Lakes church
Man arrested at scene of fire that destroyed Franklin Lakes church
Parishioners were devastated to hear the news that Most Blessed Sacrament in Franklin Lakes is no more after a fire ripped through the building Wednesday morning.Parishioners were devastated to hear the news that Most Blessed Sacrament in Franklin Lakes is no more after a fire ripped through the building Wednesday morning.Attorney General Grewal: Motive still unclear in Jersey City shooting
Attorney General Grewal: Motive still unclear in Jersey City shooting
Attorney General Gurbir Grewal says there is still no motive in the Jersey City shooting that killed three civilians and one police detective.Attorney General Gurbir Grewal says there is still no motive in the Jersey City shooting that killed three civilians and one police detective.Police chief: Officers investigating 3 crime scenes involved in Jersey City shooting
Police chief: Officers investigating 3 crime scenes involved in Jersey City shooting
Jersey City Police Chief Mike Kelly said the cemetery, the stolen U-Haul truck and JC Kosher Supermarket are considered to be crime scenes.Jersey City Police Chief Mike Kelly said the cemetery, the stolen U-Haul truck and JC Kosher Supermarket are considered to be crime scenes.Gov. Murphy remembers fallen Jersey City detective
Gov. Murphy remembers fallen Jersey City detective
News 12's Chris Keating caught up with parents who waited to see their children as Jersey City schools were on lockdown during the shooting.News 12's Chris Keating caught up with parents who waited to see their children as Jersey City schools were on lockdown during the shooting.
Top StoriesNewsMore>>
NJ attorney general: Jersey City attack being investigated as 'domestic terrorism'
NJ attorney general: Jersey City attack being investigated as 'domestic terrorism'
New Jersey Attorney General Gurbir Grewal said Thursday that social media postings appear to show the Jersey City shooters held anti-Jewish and anti-law enforcement beliefs.
New Jersey Attorney General Gurbir Grewal said Thursday that social media postings appear to show the Jersey City shooters held anti-Jewish and anti-law enforcement beliefs.
New Jersey Attorney General Gurbir Grewal said Thursday that social media postings appear to show the Jersey City shooters held anti-Jewish and anti-law enforcement beliefs.New Jersey Attorney General Gurbir Grewal said Thursday that social media postings appear to show the Jersey City shooters held anti-Jewish and anti-law enforcement beliefs.Surveillance video shows shooters park U-Haul, point guns, and storm Jersey City supermarket
Surveillance video shows shooters park U-Haul, point guns, and storm Jersey City supermarket
Surveillance video out of Jersey City Tuesday shows two shooters, later identified as Francine Graham and David Anderson, coming out of a stolen U-Haul they parked across from JC Kosher Supermarket.Surveillance video out of Jersey City Tuesday shows two shooters, later identified as Francine Graham and David Anderson, coming out of a stolen U-Haul they parked across from JC Kosher Supermarket.JC Kosher Market employee killed in Tuesday's gunfire remember by wife at vigil
JC Kosher Market employee killed in Tuesday's gunfire remember by wife at vigil
An Ecuadorian immigrant and store employee at JC Kosher Market was remembered at a vigil for the victim of this week's shooting Thursday night.An Ecuadorian immigrant and store employee at JC Kosher Market was remembered at a vigil for the victim of this week's shooting Thursday night.Religious leaders, elected officials urge message of unity in wake of Jersey City shooting
Religious leaders, elected officials urge message of unity in wake of Jersey City shooting
Elected officials and religious leaders came together for a news conference addressing this week's violence and subsequent tension in the Jersey City community.Elected officials and religious leaders came together for a news conference addressing this week's violence and subsequent tension in the Jersey City community.‘Brick Citi Buddha’ brings enlightenment, holistic approach to healthy living
‘Brick Citi Buddha’ brings enlightenment, holistic approach to healthy living
An Essex County man who battled drug and alcohol is now helping people through a holistic approach.An Essex County man who battled drug and alcohol is now helping people through a holistic approach.