Groups oppose bill to require car dealerships to notify buyers about recalls
Posted: Updated:A network of consumer advocacy organizations is lining up to oppose a controversial consumer bill that was first exposed in a Kane In Your Corner investigation in June.
The bill, proposed by Sen. James Beach (D – Cherry Hill) and Assemblyman Lou Greenwald (D – Mount Holly), would require car dealers to notify prospective buyers of open recalls. Sponsors argue that since there is currently no regulation, the bill is a step in the right direction.
RELATED: Consumer Alert: Government’s handling of car recalls
But consumer advocates say the bill would hurt consumers, since it would limit their ability to sue car dealers under the New Jersey Consumer Fraud Act over any issue, even ones that are unrelated to recalls. It would also shield a car dealer from recall-related liability as long as disclosure was made. The consumer groups contend lawmakers should simply prohibit the sale of used cars with open recalls, as is already the case for new cars and rental cars.
“Disclosure is not enough, we have to have repair,” says Bob Russo, president of the Consumers League of New Jersey. “We cannot have dealers selling cars that are just disclosed as dangerous or having defects or having recalls or being lemons. We have to have a repair.”
Jason Levine of the Center for Auto Safety adds, “You shouldn't be able to sell a car with a recall on it, whether it's a used car, a new car or a rental car. Period. End of story.”
Other groups opposing the bill include the Consumer Federation of America, the National Association of Consumer Advocates, Consumer Action, Consumers for Auto Reliability and Safety, The Safety Institute, New Jersey Citizen Action and the New Jersey Chapter of the NAACP.
The bill has passed the state Senate and was assigned to an Assembly committee. New Jersey lawmakers are expected to take up debate on the legislation when they return to session this fall.
Kane in Your CornerMore>>
Inside the Investigation: “Concussion Cover-up”
Inside the Investigation: “Concussion Cover-up”
Is there a danger of concussion on high-speed thrill rides? The Kane In Your Corner team takes you inside this in-depth investigation.Is there a danger of concussion on high-speed thrill rides? The Kane In Your Corner team takes you inside this in-depth investigation.Consumer Alert: Is it worth switching to LED holiday lights?
Consumer Alert: Is it worth switching to LED holiday lights?
As homeowners begin decorating their homes for the holiday season, some are wondering if LED lights are worth the higher price.As homeowners begin decorating their homes for the holiday season, some are wondering if LED lights are worth the higher price.Consumer Alert: Black Friday deals, tips to avoid knockoffs and more
Consumer Alert: Black Friday deals, tips to avoid knockoffs and more
The holiday shopping is officially here. So when is it worth braving the crowds? News 12's Walt Kane asks the experts.The holiday shopping is officially here. So when is it worth braving the crowds? News 12's Walt Kane asks the experts.Consumer Alert: Buying a new TV this holiday season? Here's what to look for
Consumer Alert: Buying a new TV this holiday season? Here's what to look for
If you're in the market for a new TV this holiday season, you could find that the choices are staggering and the features are not always easy to understand. News 12's Walt Kane breaks it all down.If you're in the market for a new TV this holiday season, you could find that the choices are staggering and the features are not always easy to understand. News 12's Walt Kane breaks it all down.Kane In Your Corner podcast: Black Friday and Cyber Monday Consumer Alert
Kane In Your Corner podcast: Black Friday and Cyber Monday Consumer Alert
This special holiday consumer alert shares shopping tips for Black Friday and Cyber Monday and looks at how TV technology is ever-changing and how to decide what tech is right for you.This special holiday consumer alert shares shopping tips for Black Friday and Cyber Monday and looks at how TV technology is ever-changing and how to decide what tech is right for you.
TransportationMore>>
New Jersey congressmen fight to save GWB carpool toll discount
New Jersey congressmen fight to save GWB carpool toll discount
Two New Jersey congressmen are fighting to save a toll discount for carpoolers at the George Washington Bridge.Two New Jersey congressmen are fighting to save a toll discount for carpoolers at the George Washington Bridge.Officials unanimously vote to cancel e-scooter contract following teen’s death
Officials unanimously vote to cancel e-scooter contract following teen’s death
The Elizabeth City Council has voted to end its contract with electronic scooter company Lime, following the death of a 16-year-old boy.The Elizabeth City Council has voted to end its contract with electronic scooter company Lime, following the death of a 16-year-old boy.Schumer: Airlines must allow kids to sit with their parents
Schumer: Airlines must allow kids to sit with their parents
New York Sen. Charles Schumer says airlines lack policies assuring children can sit with their parents, despite the 2016 legislation requiring the federal Department of Transportation to enact a universal family-friendly seating policy.New York Sen. Charles Schumer says airlines lack policies assuring children can sit with their parents, despite the 2016 legislation requiring the federal Department of Transportation to enact a universal family-friendly seating policy.Lawmakers hear list of complaints as they probe New Jersey Transit woes
Lawmakers hear list of complaints as they probe New Jersey Transit woes
Fed up commuters and transit activists gave New Jersey lawmakers an earful as they expressed their concerns and frustrations with New Jersey Transit train and bus service.Fed up commuters and transit activists gave New Jersey lawmakers an earful as they expressed their concerns and frustrations with New Jersey Transit train and bus service.NJ vs. NY: Tolls under congestion pricing
NJ vs. NY: Tolls under congestion pricing
New Jersey commuters could face two tolls instead of one due to congestion pricing.New Jersey commuters could face two tolls instead of one due to congestion pricing.
Top StoriesNewsMore>>
‘The active shooters targeted the location they attacked’: Multiple dead, including officer, in Jersey City shooting
‘The active shooters targeted the location they attacked’: Multiple dead, including officer, in Jersey City shooting
‘The active shooters targeted the location they attacked’: Multiple dead, including officer, in Jersey City shooting
‘The active shooters targeted the location they attacked’: Multiple dead, including officer, in Jersey City shooting
Investigators in Jersey City say three innocent civilians and a police detective were killed in Tuesday’s shootout – as well as the shooters that were later killed. Mayor Steven Fulop now says some of the victims may have been targeted.Investigators in Jersey City say three innocent civilians and a police detective were killed in Tuesday’s shootout – as well as the shooters that were later killed. Mayor Steven Fulop now says some of the victims may have been targeted.35 Jersey City police officers killed in line of duty since 1881
35 Jersey City police officers killed in line of duty since 1881
The death of Det. Joseph Seals in Tuesday’s shooting now brings the total to 35 Jersey City police officers killed in the line of duty since the department started keeping records in 1881.The death of Det. Joseph Seals in Tuesday’s shooting now brings the total to 35 Jersey City police officers killed in the line of duty since the department started keeping records in 1881.‘It's a tough day for Jersey City’: Gov. Murphy, Mayor Fulop remember fallen Jersey City detective
‘It's a tough day for Jersey City’: Gov. Murphy, Mayor Fulop remember fallen Jersey City detective
There are heavy hearts this morning for law enforcement in the area, and all around the country, after Det. Joseph Seals, a 15-year veteran of the Jersey City Police Department, was killed in Tuesday’s shooting.There are heavy hearts this morning for law enforcement in the area, and all around the country, after Det. Joseph Seals, a 15-year veteran of the Jersey City Police Department, was killed in Tuesday’s shooting.Police chief: Officers investigating 3 crime scenes involved in Jersey City shooting
Police chief: Officers investigating 3 crime scenes involved in Jersey City shooting
Jersey City Police Chief Mike Kelly said the cemetery, the stolen U-Haul truck and JC Kosher Supermarket are considered to be crime scenes.Jersey City Police Chief Mike Kelly said the cemetery, the stolen U-Haul truck and JC Kosher Supermarket are considered to be crime scenes.News 12 Lights Up the Holidays: Vote on the Top 12!
News 12 Lights Up the Holidays: Vote on the Top 12!
News 12 New Jersey wants to light up the holidays and we need your help!
News 12 New Jersey wants to light up the holidays and we need your help!