President Trump revokes Obama guidance on race in school admissionsPosted: Updated:
By ERIC TUCKER
WASHINGTON (AP) - The Trump administration on Tuesday rescinded Obama-era guidance that encouraged schools to take a student's race into account to promote diversity in admissions.
The shift suggests schools will have the federal government's blessing to leave race out of admissions and enrollment decisions, and it underscores the contentious politics that continue to surround affirmative action policies, which have repeatedly been challenged before the Supreme Court.
The admissions memos were among 24 policy documents revoked by the Justice Department for being "unnecessary, outdated, inconsistent with existing law, or otherwise improper." Attorney General Jeff Sessions called the changes an effort to restore the "rule of law" and blamed past administrations for imposing new rules without seeking public comment.
"That's wrong, and it's not good government," Sessions said in a statement.
The action comes amid a high-profile court fight over Harvard University admissions as well as Supreme Court turnover expected to produce a more critical eye toward schools' race-conscious admissions policies.
The court's most recent significant ruling on the subject bolstered colleges' use of race among many factors in the admission process. But the opinion's author, Anthony Kennedy, announced his retirement last week, giving President Donald Trump a chance to replace him with a justice who may be more reliably skeptical of admissions programs that take race and ethnicity into account.
The new policy dramatically departs from the stance of the Obama administration, which in a 2011 policy document said courts had recognized schools' "compelling interest" in ensuring racially diverse populations. The guidance said that while race shouldn't be the primary factor in an admission decision, schools could lawfully consider it in the interest of achieving diversity.
"Institutions are not required to implement race-neutral approaches if, in their judgment, the approaches would be unworkable," the guidance said. "In some cases, race-neutral approaches will be unworkable because they will be ineffective to achieve the diversity the institution seeks."
That guidance has now been rescinded, as have more than a half-dozen other similar documents, including some that sought to explain court rulings affirming the use of race as one of several factors in the admissions process.
In one such document, the Obama administration stated, "As the Supreme Court has recognized, diversity has benefits for all students, and today's students must be prepared to succeed in a diverse society and an increasingly global workforce."
The Trump administration's announcement is more in line with Bush-era policy that discouraged affirmative action and instead encouraged the use of race-neutral alternatives, like percentage plans and economic diversity programs.
Though such guidance doesn't have the force of law, schools could presumably use it to defend themselves against lawsuits over admission policies.
The Trump administration's Justice Department had already signaled concern about the use of race in admissions decisions.
The department, for instance, has sided with Asian-American plaintiffs who contend in a lawsuit against Harvard that the school unlawfully limits how many Asian students are admitted.
Students for Fair Admissions, the group suing Harvard, is led by Ed Blum, a legal strategist who also helped white student Abigail Fisher sue the University of Texas for alleged discrimination in a case that reached the Supreme Court.
Blum said Tuesday the organization "welcomes any governmental actions that will eliminate racial classifications and preferences in college admissions." Harvard, meanwhile, said it would continue considering race as an admissions factor to create a "diverse campus community where students from all walks of life have the opportunity to learn with and from each other."
Civil liberties groups criticized the Trump administration's announcement, saying it went against decades of court precedent permitting colleges to take race into account.
"We condemn the Department of Education's politically motivated attack on affirmative action and deliberate attempt to discourage colleges and universities from pursuing racial diversity at our nation's colleges and universities," Kristen Clarke, president and executive director of the Lawyers' Committee for Civil Rights Under Law, said in a statement.
Lily Eskelsen García, president of the National Education Association, said "affirmative action has proven to be one of the most effective ways to create diverse and inclusive classrooms." She said the announcement underscored the stakes surrounding the upcoming Supreme Court appointment.
The high court has been generally accepting of considering race in admissions decisions to achieve diversity. In a 2016 opinion written by Kennedy, the court granted affirmative action policies a victory by permitting race to be among the factors considered in the college admission process.
The ruling bitterly disappointed conservatives who thought Kennedy would be part of a Supreme Court majority to outlaw affirmative action in education. Justice Antonin Scalia died after the court heard arguments in the case but before the decision was handed down.
The new affirmative action guidance may add to an already contentious fight over the next justice.
With Trump expected to announce his nominee next week, the issue should be a central part of any confirmation process, said Howard University law school dean Danielle Holley-Walker.
She called the new guidance "highly unfortunate and counterproductive" and said the decision is another indication that the Justice Department under Sessions is likely to be aggressive toward schools that do continue to factor in race in admissions decisions.
"People have been talking about precedent in regard to Roe. v. Wade" - the landmark 1973 ruling affirming a woman's right to abortion - "but it's important to remember that affirmative action has been a precedent for the past 40 years," she said. "This is a clear attack on precedent. Any Supreme Court nominee needs to be asked if they support precedent related to affirmative action."
Associated Press writers Mark Sherman and Jesse Holland in Washington, Collin Binkley in Boston and National Writer Errin Haines Whack in Philadelphia contributed to this report.
Copyright 2018 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
- Camden County police say they are looking to cut down on crime in the city with help from artificial intelligence.Camden County police say they are looking to cut down on crime in the city with help from artificial intelligence.
- The Hobbymaster store in Red Bank has announced it will be closing.The Hobbymaster store in Red Bank has announced it will be closing.
- The American Transportation Institute ranked a road in Fort Lee the most congested intersections in the nation.The American Transportation Institute ranked a road in Fort Lee the most congested intersections in the nation.
- President Trump grants clemency to 11 people using presidential pardonPresident Trump grants clemency to 11 people using presidential pardon
- The NJ Department of Transportation says it is spending less on snow removal than in previous years.The NJ Department of Transportation says it is spending less on snow removal than in previous years.
Power & PoliticsMore>>
- Gov. Phil Murphy announced new legislation Tuesday in an effort to overhaul New Jersey’s workplace sexual harassment laws.Gov. Phil Murphy announced new legislation Tuesday in an effort to overhaul New Jersey’s workplace sexual harassment laws.
- Former Attorney General Chris Porrino, who served during Republican Gov. Chris Christie's administration, talks about the status of bail reform in New Jersey.Former Attorney General Chris Porrino, who served during Republican Gov. Chris Christie's administration, talks about the status of bail reform in New Jersey.
- Gov. Phil Murphy says New Jersey will re-evaluate workplace standards and guidelines for state employees.Gov. Phil Murphy says New Jersey will re-evaluate workplace standards and guidelines for state employees.
- The leader of a labor union says that New Jersey Senate President Steve Sweeney once threatened her with physical violence during an intense meeting.The leader of a labor union says that New Jersey Senate President Steve Sweeney once threatened her with physical violence during an intense meeting.
- Nearly a dozen witnesses told a New Jersey panel looking at sexual misconduct and misogyny in state politics that better training is needed to halt misbehavior.Nearly a dozen witnesses told a New Jersey panel looking at sexual misconduct and misogyny in state politics that better training is needed to halt misbehavior.
- Two of the country’s largest teacher’s unions are urging school districts to scale back on active shooter drills because they say the drills are traumatizing to students.Two of the country’s largest teacher’s unions are urging school districts to scale back on active shooter drills because they say the drills are traumatizing to students.
- Childhood experts are suggesting to parents that they ditch traditional baby talk when teaching their young children communication skills.Childhood experts are suggesting to parents that they ditch traditional baby talk when teaching their young children communication skills.
- Gov. Phil Murphy announced two new programs to help address mental health issues among the state’s students.Gov. Phil Murphy announced two new programs to help address mental health issues among the state’s students.
- Anyone who wants a chance to test out the latest in technology can have the chance if they have a Hoboken library card.Anyone who wants a chance to test out the latest in technology can have the chance if they have a Hoboken library card.