Prosecutors: Dix Hills man starved dog to point of emaciation

<p>Prosecutors say a nurse from Dix Hills made up a lost-and-found story about his neglected dog Oakley, who starved to the point of emaciation.</p>

News 12 Staff

Jan 11, 2018, 12:22 AM

Updated 2,290 days ago

Share:

Prosecutors say a nurse from Dix Hills made up a lost-and-found story about his neglected dog Oakley, who starved to the point of emaciation.
Paul Matthews faces a slew of charges including torturing and injuring animals, failure to provide sustenance to an animal and abandonment of animals.
Prosecutors say an examination revealed that Oakley was severely malnourished and weighed only 57 pounds – about 25 pounds underweight. They say an X-ray revealed sheetrock and steel debris in his stomach.
"He had no nutrition in his stomach, only rocks, steel, leaves and grass," says Jed Painter, an assistant district attorney in Nassau County. "Starving dogs will eat anything to survive, in this case, it was causing a lot of damage, possibly a blockage."
Oakley was near death when Matthews surrendered him to the Town of Hempstead Animal Shelter on Dec. 21, according to prosecutors. They say Matthews made up a story about finding the dog on Jericho Turnpike as a stray. 
A veterinarian determined the dog had been starved for about three months.
Prosecutors say an investigation found Matthews had been Oakley's owner and caregiver for at least two years. 
"You can't watch your animal waste away," Painter says. "You can't knowingly neglect your animal."
The dog underwent surgery and is doing better. Once he makes a full recovery, prosecutors say he'll be put up for adoption.
Matthews is due back in court Feb. 22.
No one answered the door at his Dix Hills home.


More from News 12
1:37
Officials: Some Marlboro schools, Trenton Board of Ed receive bomb threat 2nd day in a row

Officials: Some Marlboro schools, Trenton Board of Ed receive bomb threat 2nd day in a row

2:10
Rain showers return tonight in New Jersey; temps warm up for the weekend

Rain showers return tonight in New Jersey; temps warm up for the weekend

NJDOT looks to complete emergency repairs on Route 71 Bridge in Belmar by Memorial Day

NJDOT looks to complete emergency repairs on Route 71 Bridge in Belmar by Memorial Day

Prosecutors: Atlantic City’s Central Pier bursts into flames; 1 man dead

Prosecutors: Atlantic City’s Central Pier bursts into flames; 1 man dead

0:35
How to get rid of unused or expired medications

How to get rid of unused or expired medications

2:51
EPA: Elevated levels of lead found at multiple East Trenton homes, parks

EPA: Elevated levels of lead found at multiple East Trenton homes, parks

0:25
Boil water advisory issued for parts of Monmouth County

Boil water advisory issued for parts of Monmouth County

0:36
NJ General Assembly passes bill to combat school bus driver shortage

NJ General Assembly passes bill to combat school bus driver shortage

0:24
Former NJ elementary school employee sentenced for possession of child porn involving at least 79 victims

Former NJ elementary school employee sentenced for possession of child porn involving at least 79 victims

2:32
Main Street New Jersey: Some great food spots to try in South River

Main Street New Jersey: Some great food spots to try in South River

0:25
NJ Department of Education awarding over $9 million in grants to help students with disabilities

NJ Department of Education awarding over $9 million in grants to help students with disabilities

2:19
Paws & Pals: Ellie Mae now up for adoption with Best Friend Dog and Animal Adoption

Paws & Pals: Ellie Mae now up for adoption with Best Friend Dog and Animal Adoption

Is your mom awesome? New Jersey tell us why your Mom Rocks!

Is your mom awesome? New Jersey tell us why your Mom Rocks!

0:25
New Jersey native Jack Leiter makes pitching debut for Rangers as they beat Tigers 9-7

New Jersey native Jack Leiter makes pitching debut for Rangers as they beat Tigers 9-7

0:54
Guide: How to host Passover on a budget

Guide: How to host Passover on a budget

Show off your team spirit! Share your photos with News 12

Show off your team spirit! Share your photos with News 12

0:29
GoFundMe pages created for Paterson families displaced by house fires

GoFundMe pages created for Paterson families displaced by house fires

2:43
‘Now he literally has a part of me.’ Brother donates part of his liver to twin

‘Now he literally has a part of me.’ Brother donates part of his liver to twin

0:27
Police: Husband and wife stole jewelry from Bridgewater retirement facility

Police: Husband and wife stole jewelry from Bridgewater retirement facility

2:23
Rutgers police: Person charged for shooting people with Orbeez gun

Rutgers police: Person charged for shooting people with Orbeez gun