Dad of teen killed by classmates: ‘I have my good days and bad days’

<p>The father of a 19-year-old Monmouth County woman allegedly killed by her high school friends says that he is trying to move forward a year after her death.</p>

News 12 Staff

Dec 4, 2017, 10:51 PM

Updated 2,324 days ago

Share:

The father of a 19-year-old Monmouth County woman allegedly killed by her high school friends says that he is trying to move forward a year after her death.
“That’s all I can do. One day at a time. I have my good days and I have my bad days,” Michael Stern says.
It was December 2016 when Stern’s daughter Sarah was reported missing. A large search effort was put into place after her car was found near the Route 35 Bridge in Belmar. About a month after her disappearance, police arrested two of her former friends and high school classmates.
"[Sarah] was just a great person. Real dynamic and artistic and funny. Just an all-around good kid,” Michael Stern says. “She just wanted to have a good time and enjoy life. That's all she wanted to do."
Monmouth County prosecutors say that Liam McAtasney and Preston Taylor hatched a monthslong plan to kill Sarah Stern in order to obtain a sum of money that was left to her.
Officials say that McAtasney strangled Sarah Stern, hid her body in the bushes and then called Taylor to help him dispose of the body. The two staged her disappearance to look like a suicide and then allegedly threw her body into the Shark River. Her body has not been recovered to date.
“The tides are swift and the sea is a cruel mistress,” says Michael Stern.
A memorial to honor Sarah Stern was erected near the river.
"I can't tell you how sad it is that they’re such deprived individuals to even contemplate anything like this,” Michael Stern says. “I just can't imagine what was going through their heads."
Taylor pleaded guilty to the crime and is expected to testify for the prosecutor.
McAtasney’s next court appearance is scheduled for Dec. 13. His attorney is expected to argue that a taped conversation recorded by a fellow classmate that allegedly contains a confession by McAtasney to the crime should not be allowed as evidence during the trial.
Michael Stern says that he is in the process of setting up scholarships in her name at Neptune High School and Brookdale Community College, where she attended classes.


More from News 12
1:45
Elizabeth roadway reopens following New Jersey Turnpike crash that sent debris falling onto ground

Elizabeth roadway reopens following New Jersey Turnpike crash that sent debris falling onto ground

1:28
Sunny today in New Jersey with highs in the 70s; rain returns Wednesday

Sunny today in New Jersey with highs in the 70s; rain returns Wednesday

2:53
Officials work on beach replenishment at Sea Girt where toddler got trapped in sand

Officials work on beach replenishment at Sea Girt where toddler got trapped in sand

0:16
NJ Transit rail service resumes on Northeast Corridor between Trenton and Rahway following overhead wire issues

NJ Transit rail service resumes on Northeast Corridor between Trenton and Rahway following overhead wire issues

2:08
Prosecutor: Montclair police officer injured in shootout; suspect also hospitalized

Prosecutor: Montclair police officer injured in shootout; suspect also hospitalized

0:22
Police: 3 drivers hospitalized with head injuries following Manchester crash

Police: 3 drivers hospitalized with head injuries following Manchester crash

1:47
Officials investigate 2 homes possibly damaged by 4.8 magnitude earthquake

Officials investigate 2 homes possibly damaged by 4.8 magnitude earthquake

2:29
Prosecutor: Atlantic City mayor, wife accused of physically abusing teen daughter

Prosecutor: Atlantic City mayor, wife accused of physically abusing teen daughter

1:39
Best of New Jersey visits popular seafood spot Angry Archies in Jersey City

Best of New Jersey visits popular seafood spot Angry Archies in Jersey City

0:27
Jets 'return to roots' with new uniforms that pay tribute to team's 'New York Sack Exchange' look

Jets 'return to roots' with new uniforms that pay tribute to team's 'New York Sack Exchange' look

Guide: Alcohol addiction recovery support and resources

Guide: Alcohol addiction recovery support and resources

0:39
Jersey Proud: Preschool students hold fundraiser for Make-A-Wish

Jersey Proud: Preschool students hold fundraiser for Make-A-Wish

0:18
Officials: Lightning sparks fire that displaces 8 Kearny families

Officials: Lightning sparks fire that displaces 8 Kearny families

1:56
‘He was a beautiful person.’ Man found dead following house fire in Paterson

‘He was a beautiful person.’ Man found dead following house fire in Paterson

2:17
Community comes together to clean veterans’ gravestones in Nutley

Community comes together to clean veterans’ gravestones in Nutley

0:20
Police: Toms River man won’t face charges for striking toddler with car

Police: Toms River man won’t face charges for striking toddler with car

0:27
NJ Transit: Body found on train tracks in Fair Lawn

NJ Transit: Body found on train tracks in Fair Lawn

1:55
Middlesex County rabbi: No loss of life during Iran airstrikes on Israel was ‘miraculous’

Middlesex County rabbi: No loss of life during Iran airstrikes on Israel was ‘miraculous’

0:20
Downed wires cause car fires in Elmwood Park; no injuries

Downed wires cause car fires in Elmwood Park; no injuries

0:18
2 best friends from New Jersey split $1 million Powerball prize

2 best friends from New Jersey split $1 million Powerball prize