Judge refuses to throw out case against Sen. Menendez

Posted: Updated:
(AP Photo/Seth Wenig, File) FILE - In this Sept. 6, 2017, file photo, Sen. Bob Menendez arrives to court for his federal corruption trial in Newark, N.J. (AP Photo/Seth Wenig, File) FILE - In this Sept. 6, 2017, file photo, Sen. Bob Menendez arrives to court for his federal corruption trial in Newark, N.J.

By DAVID PORTER
Associated Press

NEWARK, N.J. (AP) - In a big defeat for Democratic Sen. Bob Menendez, the judge at his corruption trial Monday refused to throw out any of the charges against him in light of a U.S. Supreme Court ruling narrowing the definition of bribery.

The decision by U.S. District Judge William Walls was a major victory for federal prosecutors, who had warned that dismissing the charges would torpedo nearly all other bribery cases and open the door wide to graft.

Walls rejected defense lawyers' arguments that the allegations against Menendez didn't meet the new definition of bribery contained in the 2016 Supreme Court ruling that reversed the conviction of former Virginia Gov. Bob McDonnell. In recent months, the McDonnell ruling led judges to throw out the bribery convictions of at least three other public officials, including a former Louisiana congressman.

Just days ago, Walls appeared to be leaning toward a ruling that could have gutted the case against Menendez and co-defendant Dr. Salomon Melgen. Virtually the entire 18-count indictment against them focuses on bribery.

The senator had no comment after the ruling.

Menendez, 63, is charged with accepting free flights on a private jet, luxury hotel stays and other gifts from the wealthy Florida eye doctor over a seven-year period. In exchange, prosecutors say, he pressured government officials on Melgen's behalf over an $8.9 million Medicare billing dispute and a contract to provide port screening equipment in the Dominican Republic.

The most serious charge Menendez and Melgen face, honest services fraud, is punishable by up to 20 years in prison.

Prosecutors rested their case last week. After Walls' ruling, the defense began presenting its side, with family members of both defendants taking the stand.

Menendez's son, Robert Jr., and Melgen's wife, Flor, testified about the close relationship between the two men. Defense attorneys are seeking to emphasize that Melgen's gifts were an outgrowth of that friendship and not part of a bribery scheme.

Last week, Walls appeared to cast doubt on the prosecution's "stream of benefits" theory of bribery, which holds that each bribe in a series of them over time doesn't necessarily have to be made with the intent of prompting a specific official action.

Defense attorneys had argued that the McDonnell ruling said instead that a bribe must be given in exchange for a public official taking action, or agreeing to take action, on a specific matter.

The defense accused the prosecution of using a "mix-and-match" strategy to pair up Melgen's gifts between 2006 and 2013 with actions Menendez took during the same period, without establishing direct connections.

On Monday, Walls instead cited a federal appeals court ruling, issued after McDonnell, that upheld the stream of benefits theory in cases where gifts flow to a public official "in exchange for a pattern of official action ... on an as-needed basis."

In court papers, prosecutors had warned that invalidating the theory would "jettison the vast majority of bribery prosecutions and broadly legalize pay-to-play politics."

___

This story has been corrected to show that the congressman whose case was thrown out was from Louisiana, not Pennsylvania.

Copyright 2017 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

  • PoliticsMore>>

  • Christie says he wishes he eliminated sick-leave payouts

    Christie says he wishes he eliminated sick-leave payouts

    Wednesday, November 22 2017 5:56 AM EST2017-11-22 10:56:13 GMT
    New Jersey Gov. Chris ChristieNew Jersey Gov. Chris Christie

    New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie says he wishes he was able to do away with state payouts to public pensioners for unused sick leave.

    New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie says he wishes he was able to do away with state payouts to public pensioners for unused sick leave.

  • Judge permanently blocks Trump sanctuary cities order

    Judge permanently blocks Trump sanctuary cities order

    Monday, November 20 2017 9:17 PM EST2017-11-21 02:17:34 GMT
    (FILE) President Donald Trump speaks to the National Association of Manufactures at the Mandarin Oriental hotel, Friday, Sept. 29, 2017, in Washington.(FILE) President Donald Trump speaks to the National Association of Manufactures at the Mandarin Oriental hotel, Friday, Sept. 29, 2017, in Washington.

    A federal judge has permanently blocked President Donald Trump's executive order to cut funding from cities that limit cooperation with U.S. immigration authorities.

    A federal judge has permanently blocked President Donald Trump's executive order to cut funding from cities that limit cooperation with U.S. immigration authorities.

  • Trump promises Americans 'huge tax cut' for Christmas

    Trump promises Americans 'huge tax cut' for Christmas

    Monday, November 20 2017 10:52 AM EST2017-11-20 15:52:04 GMT
    Monday, November 20 2017 8:41 PM EST2017-11-21 01:41:35 GMT

    President Donald Trump on Monday promised a tax overhaul by Christmas.

    President Donald Trump on Monday promised a tax overhaul by Christmas.

sorry to interrupt
your first 20 are free
Access to News 12 is free for Optimum, Comcast®, Time Warner® and Service ElectricSM customers.
Please enjoy 20 complimentary views of articles, photos, and videos during the next 30 days.
you have reached your 5 view limit
Access to News 12 is free for Optimum, Comcast®, Time Warner® and Service ElectricSM customers.
Please login, create an account or subscribe to continue enjoying News12.
Our sign-up page is undergoing maintenance and is not currently available. However, you will be given direct access to news12.com while we complete our upgrade.
When we are back up and running you will be prompted at that time to complete your sign in. Until then, enjoy the local news, weather, traffic and more that's "as local as local news gets."