Parents of murder victim: ‘You messed with the wrong girl’

A 23-year-old man from Orange has been convicted for the murder of three women and the attempted murder of a fourth woman.

News 12 Staff

Dec 23, 2019, 11:01 PM

Updated 1,602 days ago

Share:

A 23-year-old man from Orange has been convicted for the murder of three women and the attempted murder of a fourth woman.
A jury convicted Khalil Wheeler-Weaver Friday for the 2016 murders.
Essex County Prosecutor Theodore Stephens says that Wheeler-Weaver did not think that the women’s lives mattered – that the women would not be missed. But Stephens says that this is wrong and that the women’s families helped to locate the killer.
Officials say that Wheeler-Weaver arranged sexual encounters the victims: Joanne Brown, Robin West and Sarah Butler. But they say that Wheeler-Weaver strangled them instead. A fourth woman was able to escape.
Butler’s parents attended Monday’s event with the prosecutor to honor their daughter. Mother Laverne Butler said that her daughter’s killer “messed with the wrong girl.”
“She loved to dance. She loved to swim. You took that away from her. She’ll never get a chance again to teach kids how to swim, teach them how to dance,” Laverne Butler said.
Butler’s father expressed the grief that has followed the family the last three years – especially during the holiday season.
“We didn’t even put up a Christmas tree because there was no joy in it. It’s going to take some time,” said Victor Butler.
Officials say that Wheeler-Weaver hid Butler’s body at the Eagle Rock Reservation in West Orange.
Stephens says that investigators could build a solid case against Wheeler-Weaver due to their ability to trace his phone and where he was. The surviving victim’s testimony was also instrumental.
Wheeler-Weaver did not testify. He has yet to be sentenced.


More from News 12
1:52
Car flips off Garden State Parkway in Elmwood Park, narrowly misses hitting a house

Car flips off Garden State Parkway in Elmwood Park, narrowly misses hitting a house

1:30
Multiple Bloomfield police cars totaled following Newark crash

Multiple Bloomfield police cars totaled following Newark crash

1:58
Mostly sunny today with highs near 70 in New Jersey; rain returns Tuesday

Mostly sunny today with highs near 70 in New Jersey; rain returns Tuesday

0:20
Police: 3 firefighters injured in Trenton house fire

Police: 3 firefighters injured in Trenton house fire

Jury selection to begin in the corruption trial of Sen. Bob Menendez

Jury selection to begin in the corruption trial of Sen. Bob Menendez

2:32
‘You hurt a family.’ Kane In Your Corner reveals animal rescue concerns about Pixies and Paws

‘You hurt a family.’ Kane In Your Corner reveals animal rescue concerns about Pixies and Paws

0:28
Little Falls native Chris Gotterup wins Myrtle Beach Classic for 1st PGA Tour title

Little Falls native Chris Gotterup wins Myrtle Beach Classic for 1st PGA Tour title

0:36
Spending time outdoors? Here are 20 tips to prevent tick bites.

Spending time outdoors? Here are 20 tips to prevent tick bites.

0:30
Haliburton, Pacers take advantage of short-handed Knicks to even series with 121-89 rout in Game 4

Haliburton, Pacers take advantage of short-handed Knicks to even series with 121-89 rout in Game 4

1:49
New Jersey families celebrate the women in their lives on Mother's Day

New Jersey families celebrate the women in their lives on Mother's Day

2:38
Rutgers University students brave the rain for Class of 2024 graduation ceremony

Rutgers University students brave the rain for Class of 2024 graduation ceremony

0:20
Prosecutor: Lower Township woman arrested for death of her 6-month-old son

Prosecutor: Lower Township woman arrested for death of her 6-month-old son

0:27
Police: Motorcyclist killed in Egg Harbor Township crash

Police: Motorcyclist killed in Egg Harbor Township crash

0:15
Police: Multi-vehicle crash in Elizabeth leaves 5 people injured

Police: Multi-vehicle crash in Elizabeth leaves 5 people injured

0:30
Haliburton, Pacers take advantage of short-handed Knicks to even series with 121-89 rout in Game 4

Haliburton, Pacers take advantage of short-handed Knicks to even series with 121-89 rout in Game 4

2:46
Pro-Palestinian hunger strike at Princeton University marks 1 week

Pro-Palestinian hunger strike at Princeton University marks 1 week

1:39
Senate bill would limit harmful heavy metals in baby food

Senate bill would limit harmful heavy metals in baby food

0:29
Authorities: 24-year-old man fatally shot in Jersey City

Authorities: 24-year-old man fatally shot in Jersey City

0:22
Montclair police: 2 people hurt in shooting near Mission Street and Bloomfield Avenue

Montclair police: 2 people hurt in shooting near Mission Street and Bloomfield Avenue

2:05
North Arlington garden center 'blooms' with business ahead of Mother's Day

North Arlington garden center 'blooms' with business ahead of Mother's Day