Panel: Gov. Murphy’s staff botched sex assault claim response

A state legislative panel investigating Gov. Phil Murphy's handling of a sexual assault claim made by one state worker against another found the administration mishandled its response.

News 12 Staff

Jun 5, 2019, 9:30 PM

Updated 1,793 days ago

Share:

A state legislative panel investigating Gov. Phil Murphy's handling of a sexual assault claim made by one state worker against another found the administration mishandled its response.
The Legislative Select Oversight Committee voted Wednesday to release its 123-page report.
The investigation stems from Katie Brennan's complaint that emerged in an October newspaper account. Brennan, chief of staff of the state's housing authority, alleged Albert Alvarez sexually assaulted her while they were both working to get Murphy, a Democrat, elected in 2017.
Alvarez, who left as chief of staff at the Schools Development Authority last year, denies the allegations. Law enforcement declined to bring charges.
The committee says it found Murphy's administration appeared more concerned with "avoiding negative publicity" than following procedures and should have investigated Brennan's allegations more thoroughly.
“It was a scar on state government. And it was another sad reminder of conditions, behavior and attitudes that need to change,” says state Sen. Loretta Weinberg, co-chair of the committee.
The committee’s report called the actions of Murphy’s staff “shocking,” “sloppy” and “highly unusual.”
“The transition committee and the administration woefully mishandled the sexual assault allegation. No one conducted a rigorous in-depth examination prior to the hiring of Al. That was a disservice to Ms. Brennan and Mr. Alvarez. The system didn't fail Ms. Brennan. People failed her,” says Assemblywoman Eliana Pintor Marin.
The committee held nine hearings, during which no one could say for certain who hired Alvarez for his six-figure job at the Authority. The report found that Murphy's former chief of staff Peter Cammarano and transition team head Jose Lozano made the decision.
The report also found no evidence that anyone told the governor about the allegations against Alvarez.
“It remains unclear if that environment of suppression is intended to shield Gov. Murphy by providing plausible deniability or if it is simply the result of an implicit understanding that the governor does not want to know the details of unsavory matters that occur under his watch,” says state Sen. Kristin Corrado.
The report recommends that the state strengthen background checks, record keeping rules and discrimination laws to better handle sex assault claims and investigations.
Brennan released a statement following the report that says in part, "The findings of this report confirm what I have known all along--that sexual violence survivors in this state still cannot expect to receive justice. I waved a red flag at every turn of this process, and at every turn, I went unheard.”
"To our lawmakers, you now have a mandate--take meaningful action to create real accountability for perpetrators of sexual violence and for those who would protect them."
“To the Administration, you have a mandate as well, to hold accountable those who failed to take action or actively protected Al Alvarez.”
The Associated Press wire services contributed to this report.


More from News 12
0:41
Aftermath of deadly house explosion in South River shows home blown into pieces

Aftermath of deadly house explosion in South River shows home blown into pieces

2:17
Cooler temps today in the 60s for New Jersey ahead of some wet weather this weekend

Cooler temps today in the 60s for New Jersey ahead of some wet weather this weekend

1:42
3 pedestrians, including 2 children, struck by NYC-based news van in Elizabeth

3 pedestrians, including 2 children, struck by NYC-based news van in Elizabeth

1:31
Fire chief: 20 people displaced in Elizabeth fire that damaged multiple businesses, apartments

Fire chief: 20 people displaced in Elizabeth fire that damaged multiple businesses, apartments

0:28
GoFundMe started for 6-month-old boy and his grandfather killed by fallen tree in Verona

GoFundMe started for 6-month-old boy and his grandfather killed by fallen tree in Verona

0:40
Main Street New Jersey: Restaurants, businesses to visit in Edgewater

Main Street New Jersey: Restaurants, businesses to visit in Edgewater

WATCH LIVE: Bridge over section of I-95 is being demolished due to damage from truck fire

WATCH LIVE: Bridge over section of I-95 is being demolished due to damage from truck fire

1:12
Several house fires break out Thursday in New Jersey; 1 man dead

Several house fires break out Thursday in New Jersey; 1 man dead

0:18
South Brunswick police searching for missing man last seen on Route 1

South Brunswick police searching for missing man last seen on Route 1

0:23
South Orange woman indicted for stealing over $1 million federal benefits intended for dead aunt

South Orange woman indicted for stealing over $1 million federal benefits intended for dead aunt

2:10
Paws & Pals: Lilypad now up for adoption with AHS Newark

Paws & Pals: Lilypad now up for adoption with AHS Newark

0:38
Knicks advance to the Eastern Conference semis, topping 76ers 118-115 in Game 6

Knicks advance to the Eastern Conference semis, topping 76ers 118-115 in Game 6

0:33
Experts fear 'catastrophic' college declines thanks to botched FAFSA rollout

Experts fear 'catastrophic' college declines thanks to botched FAFSA rollout

10 organizations to donate to in support of the Asian American and Pacific Islander communities

10 organizations to donate to in support of the Asian American and Pacific Islander communities

1:26
Look up! Annual Eta Aquarid meteor shower peaks early Sunday morning

Look up! Annual Eta Aquarid meteor shower peaks early Sunday morning

1:20
Pro-Palestinian protest that postponed final exams at Rutgers ends peacefully

Pro-Palestinian protest that postponed final exams at Rutgers ends peacefully

0:36
Jersey Proud: Police officers gather for town cleanup in memory of fallen officer

Jersey Proud: Police officers gather for town cleanup in memory of fallen officer

2:17
Bound Brook starts Lithium Ion Identification Program to help firefighters identify risks

Bound Brook starts Lithium Ion Identification Program to help firefighters identify risks

0:57
Funeral services held in Newark for Rep. Donald Payne, Jr.

Funeral services held in Newark for Rep. Donald Payne, Jr.

0:22
Prosecutor: 61-year-old man dies in Jersey City high-rise fire

Prosecutor: 61-year-old man dies in Jersey City high-rise fire