Timothy Puskas pleads not guilty in New Brunswick beating death of William McCaw

New Brunswick resident Timothy Puskas was convicted in the 2014 beating death of college student William McCaw.

New Brunswick resident Timothy Puskas was convicted in the 2014 beating death of college student William McCaw. (3/26/14)

NEW BRUNSWICK - The man accused in the beating death of a Kean University student visiting New Brunswick was in court for the first time Wednesday.

Timothy Puskas, 38, of New Brunswick, pleaded not guilty in the vicious attack that killed William McCaw, whose body was discovered in the snow behind a house on Hartwell Street last month.  

McCaw, a former Rutgers student, was in the area to see friends. "He was going from place to place, having a good time, enjoying his weekend, when he came upon the defendant," says Assistant Prosecutor Sheree Pitch. "When he came upon him, his weekend ended."

Puskas was out on bail for a fatal 2012 hit-and-run when he allegedly killed McCaw. Puskas was arrested again last week for allegedly attacking his roommate, which eventually led investigators to charge him in McCaw's death.
The arrest comes as a relief to a community where most of the residents are Rutgers students.

"I'm just glad the guy got caught honestly," says Rutgers junior Jeff Contino. "I mean, it's nice realizing that it's a little bit safer."

Rutgers junior Charles Owl agrees. "It's just something that the community has been pretty distraught about," he says.

McCaw grew up in Hillsborough but moved with his family to Tennessee several years ago. He returned to New Jersey to attend college.

Puskas is being held in the Middlesex County Jail on $5 million bail. He could ask for reduced bail at a future court date.

advertisement | advertise on News 12

Trending Video

1 VIDEO: Crews work to remove 600-year-old white oak tree
Eric Landskroner has the latest on the recovery 2 Sandy Recovery Day 250: Atlantic Highlands
South Amboy police said two men were killed 3 New details released in fatal South Amboy wrong-way crash
Mikayla Raji, 8, paid for a Jamesburg police 4 Girl whose father was killed in line of duty buys officer dinner
The Majestic Lanes bowling alley was damaged when 5 Driver crashes into Woodbridge bowling alley

advertisement | advertise on News 12

More News

Middlesex County Acting Prosecutor Andrew Carey and New Arrest made in murder of Kean Univ. student

Police have announced an arrest in the beating death of a former Rutgers student found

McCaw was found beaten to death in the Cash reward offered in McCaw case

Investigators are offering a cash reward for information in the death of former Rutgers student

Billy McCaw was found dead behind the house Kean Univ. student found dead near Rutgers

A Kean University student from Tennessee was found beaten to death behind a house near

Sorry to interrupt...

Your first 5 are free

Access to News12 is free for Optimum, Comcast®, Time Warner® and Service Electric℠ video customers.

Please enjoy 5 complimentary views to articles, photos, and videos during the next 30 days.