Superior court judge rules against Jersey Shore residents in sand dune case

A superior court judge ruled against Jersey Shore residents in the sand dune eminent domain case.

A superior court judge ruled against Jersey Shore residents in the sand dune eminent domain case. (4/1/16)

TOMS RIVER - A New Jersey Superior Court judge ruled this week that the state can use eminent domain to take a part of private beachfront property to make way for new, federally funded sand dunes.

The ruling comes as more than two dozen property owners tried to block the state from taking the land. They called the state’s takeover illegal.

The beach protection project would span from Point Pleasant Beach down to Toms River, where a rough winter took a toll on the coastline.

Rachel Abenilla of Ortley Beach says that her neighborhood was badly damaged during Superstorm Sandy and several other storms, so she is happy with the ruling.

"I don’t understand how some people can be so selfish,” she says.  “Not only did they lose their own property but also their neighbors…I can’t believe people are holding out. Just ridiculous."

Toms River Mayor Tom Kelaher says that he is also happy with the ruling. He says that this January’s blizzard cost Toms River about $1 million in damage.

"I'm optimistic for the eight holdouts we have here in Toms River. Hopefully that will be the incentive for them to get on board,” Kelaher says.

A spokesperson for the New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection says that the judge's decision will encourage other Northern Ocean County holdouts to provide their easements voluntarily so the project can finally go out for bidding.

The judge also agreed to hold a future hearing for several residents of Bay Head and Mantoloking who claim a rock wall provides adequate protection and would not need to give up part of their land.

advertisement | advertise on News 12

Trending Video

News 12 New Jersey - Weather On The 1 New Jersey Weather Forecast
News 12 asked residents what they thought about 2 Westchester Talks Trump: First 100 days
News 12 asked viewers what they thought about 3 Hudson Valley Talks Trump: First 100 days
Saturday marks Donald Trump's 100th day in office. 4 Long Island Talks Trump: Rating Trump's first 100 days
6 of the 7 Hempstead IDA board members 5 6 Hempstead IDA board members resign after tax breaks

advertisement | advertise on News 12

More News

A judge has sided with the state in Judge backs DEP in dune condemnation cases

A judge has sided with New Jersey in its efforts to seize parts of oceanfront

State officials and Jenkinson's owners are still trying Jenkinson's, state still trying to settle dunes lawsuit

The state and the owners of a popular Jersey Shore beach say they're making progress

Sand dune at the Jersey Shore More beach owners sue over dunes at Jersey shore

In the dead of winter, the dune wars are heating up at the Jersey shore.

Sand dune at the Jersey Shore State blasts delay in LBI beach work

New Jersey's environmental protection commissioner is blasting plans to halt beach replenishment work on Long

Sorry to interrupt...

Your first 5 are free

Access to News12 is free for Optimum, Comcast®, Time Warner® and Service Electric℠ video customers.

Please enjoy 5 complimentary views to articles, photos, and videos during the next 30 days.