Kane In Your Corner: Would PTC system have prevented Hoboken train crash?

Thursday’s report by the National Transportation Safety Board, showing a NJ Transit train accelerated just before crashing in Hoboken last week, provides the first real

Kane In Your Corner investigates if a positive train control system would have prevented a deadly Hoboken train crash.

Kane In Your Corner investigates if a positive train control system would have prevented a deadly Hoboken train crash. (10/7/16)

HOBOKEN - Thursday’s report by the National Transportation Safety Board, showing a NJ Transit train accelerated just before crashing in Hoboken last week, provides the first real clues that the anti-speeding system known as Positive Train Control might have been able to prevent it.

In the final seconds before last week’s crash, the NTSB says the train suddenly accelerated from 8 to 21 miles per hour, more than double the maximum authorized speed. The engineer then did not attempt to hit the brakes until just one second before the train crashed into the terminal wall.

The NTSB says it still does not know if PTC would have prevented the crash, but sources tell Kane In Your Corner the answer largely depends on your point of view.

Filings from NJ Transit with the Federal Railroad Administration show the railroad got an exemption, allowing it not to install PTC on the 10th of a mile of track located inside the Hoboken Terminal itself.  So taken literally, PTC could not have prevented the crash.

But it’s not that simple. Railroads that seek a “terminal exemption,” as NJ Transit did, are required by law to use other technology to make sure maximum allowable speeds, 10 mph in the case of Hoboken, are not exceeded. Therefore, the sources tell Kane In Your Corner, PTC likely would have prevented the crash. 

NJ Transit does not yet use PTC on any of its trains. The system is currently in place in fewer than half of all commuter railroads nationwide and the federal implementation deadline was recently extended to 2018 because railroads were having trouble securing the necessary funding for implementation. 

In an interview that will air on this weekend’s edition of New Jersey Power and Politics, Sen. Cory Booker (D-New Jersey) expressed unhappiness at the slow pace of PTC implementation. “I'm very frustrated with the state of rail safety in America, that we have modes or technology we could be doing to secure our rail lines, but we haven't been doing them,” Booker said.

More on this topic

NTSB Hoboken Crash News Release

More information

Fundraiser for Hoboken train crash victim's daughter

Fundraiser for Fabiloa Bittar de Kroon's daughter Updates at NJ Transit website

advertisement | advertise on News 12

Trending Video

VIDEO: News conference on arrest in murder of 1 VIDEO: News conference on arrest in murder of Sarah Butler
News 12 New Jersey - Weather On The 2 New Jersey Weather Forecast
More than 1,000 runners dressed as Santa Claus 3 Santas run through Asbury Park for charity
Police: Teen student arrested for terror threats against 4 Police: Teen makes threats against Linden H.S. students
Andrew Ehinger shows off some gadgets that are 5 The Download - Hot for the Holidays: Part 2

advertisement | advertise on News 12

More News

Partial rail service is expected to resume Monday Partial service to resume at Hoboken station after crash

Some rail service at a New Jersey Transit station damaged after a deadly train crash

New Jersey Transit says last week's deadly train NJ Transit to Beyonce concertgoers: Expect delays, crowds

New Jersey Transit says last week's deadly train crash in Hoboken is affecting service to

Crews have removed a New Jersey Transit train Crews remove crashed NJ Transit train from Hoboken Terminal

Crews have removed a New Jersey Transit train that crashed into Hoboken Terminal last week,

NJ Transit will soon require an engineer and NJ Transit issues rule change for crew when entering Hoboken

A New Jersey Transit spokesperson says the transit agency has issued a new rule stating

Sorry to interrupt...

Your first 5 are free

Access to News12 is free for Optimum, Comcast®, Time Warner® and Service Electric℠ video customers.

Please enjoy 5 complimentary views to articles, photos, and videos during the next 30 days.

LOGIN SUBSCRIBE