Educators say shooter drills are traumatizing students; urge admins to scale back

Two of the country’s largest teacher’s unions are urging school districts to scale back on active shooter drills because they say the drills are traumatizing to students.

News 12 Staff

Feb 19, 2020, 2:41 AM

Updated 1,535 days ago

Share:

Educators say shooter drills are traumatizing students; urge admins to scale back
Two of the country’s largest teacher’s unions are urging school districts to scale back on active shooter drills because they say the drills are traumatizing to students.
Officials say that while the chances of a school shooting are low, they are never zero. There were more than 400 mass shootings in the United States last year, so the fear of a shooting is real to many school officials.
But some teachers are left wondering if shooter drills need to be as intense as they sometimes are. Some schools will conduct drills that realistically simulate a school shooting.
"They've used blanks to simulate the gunshots, they've had a masked person in the hallway, those types of things,” says Metuchen school safety coordinator Bill Ortman. “And I've heard really nothing but bad reactions as to how people have responded to that.”
Ortman says that he still believes that schools should have some version of shooter drills. He says that in Metuchen, drills have become routine – something he says is a good thing.
New Jersey state law is vague on how the drills should be conducted. Some schools can use extreme measures and school officials do not need to tell the students or teachers or parents beforehand.
"I don't think it's one particular thing. I don't think it's that particular drill and having it every month that is going to affect them,” says school psychologist Edith Lima.
Lima has been a school psychologist in New Jersey for about 10 years. She says that drills are OK as long as there is mental health support for the students as well.
"That's why there's such a push now to try to have more mental health support to try to be able to get to those students,” Lima says.
But in a report released this week by gun safety group Everytown and several parent, student and teacher organizations, Melissa Reeves, former president of the National Association of School Psychologists, says, "What these drills can really do is potentially trigger either past trauma or trigger such a significant physiological reaction that it actually ends up scaring the individuals instead of better preparing them to respond in these kinds of situations."
This means that it is up to experts like Ortman to decided how best to conduct the drills.
"Regular rehearsal of both fire, evacuating from the building, and emergency drills, seeking sanctuary within the building, is a good mix to be prepared for just about any scenario that can come up,” he says.
But Ortman does say that he wonders if the state should set parameters for the drills more clearly.
A spokesperson for the New Jersey teacher's union tells News 12 New Jersey that they are concerned about creating drills that could cause trauma to the students.


More from News 12
Officials: 1 person killed, 1 injured in house explosion in South River

Officials: 1 person killed, 1 injured in house explosion in South River

1:20
Pro-Palestinian protest that postponed final exams at Rutgers ends peacefully

Pro-Palestinian protest that postponed final exams at Rutgers ends peacefully

2:03
Mostly sunny Friday ahead with cooler temperatures; tracking weekend rain

Mostly sunny Friday ahead with cooler temperatures; tracking weekend rain

10 organizations to donate to in support of the Asian American and Pacific Islander communities

10 organizations to donate to in support of the Asian American and Pacific Islander communities

2:17
Bound Brook starts Lithium Ion Identification Program to help firefighters identify risks

Bound Brook starts Lithium Ion Identification Program to help firefighters identify risks

0:57
Funeral services held in Newark for Rep. Donald Payne, Jr.

Funeral services held in Newark for Rep. Donald Payne, Jr.

0:22
Prosecutor: 61-year-old man dies in Jersey City high-rise fire

Prosecutor: 61-year-old man dies in Jersey City high-rise fire

0:36
Jersey Proud: Police officers gather for town cleanup in memory of fallen officer

Jersey Proud: Police officers gather for town cleanup in memory of fallen officer

1:26
Look up! Annual Eta Aquarid meteor shower peaks early Sunday morning

Look up! Annual Eta Aquarid meteor shower peaks early Sunday morning

NJ Transit teams with BetMGM to provide rail service to MetLife Stadium concerts

NJ Transit teams with BetMGM to provide rail service to MetLife Stadium concerts

0:46
Car crashes into Hasbrouck Heights apartment building; residents evacuate

Car crashes into Hasbrouck Heights apartment building; residents evacuate

Biden says 'order must prevail' during campus protests over Gaza

Biden says 'order must prevail' during campus protests over Gaza

2:13
Police: Explosion, fire at Old Bridge business kills 73-year-old woman, severely injures 4 others

Police: Explosion, fire at Old Bridge business kills 73-year-old woman, severely injures 4 others

0:47
Learn to make candles at Urban Glo in Union

Learn to make candles at Urban Glo in Union

3:52
I-95 in Norwalk closed until at least Monday following tractor-trailer fire

I-95 in Norwalk closed until at least Monday following tractor-trailer fire

0:35
Prosecutors: NJ couple pleads guilty to starting illegal marijuana service and employing their son

Prosecutors: NJ couple pleads guilty to starting illegal marijuana service and employing their son

0:24
Should former inmates be allowed to serve on juries in New Jersey? Gov. Murphy says yes

Should former inmates be allowed to serve on juries in New Jersey? Gov. Murphy says yes

0:29
Unruly passenger ordered to pay over $20,000 for interfering with flight from London to Newark

Unruly passenger ordered to pay over $20,000 for interfering with flight from London to Newark

0:20
Authorities: 2 women, 1 man stabbed in altercation at Newark McDonald's

Authorities: 2 women, 1 man stabbed in altercation at Newark McDonald's

0:19
FBI offering $5,000 reward for info on Paterson bank robbery suspect

FBI offering $5,000 reward for info on Paterson bank robbery suspect