Dog seller charged with 12 counts of animal cruelty in Sayreville

A pet-selling operation in Sayreville has been shut down and the owner is facing charges of animal cruelty.

News 12 Staff

Aug 3, 2019, 2:40 AM

Updated 1,738 days ago

Share:

A pet-selling operation in Sayreville has been shut down and the owner is facing charges of animal cruelty.
Warren Smith, 32, faces 12 counts of animal cruelty charges after Sayreville police, animal control officers and the Middlesex County Prosecutor’s Office raided his Pet Supplies Plus store on Main Street.
Authorities say that they rescued 12 French bulldog puppies between the ages of 12 weeks and 3 years old. The county prosecutor says that Smith did not have the license to keep the animals.
Middlesex County Prosecutor Andrew Carey says that Smith was “failing to provide necessary care as the owner charged with the care of the animals specifically, adequate food and/or water and/or veterinary care."
Across the street at Mel's Pet Parlor, owner Mel Bellotto says she feared Smith's business was a front from some other criminal activity.
“It looked like a front and seemed like a front. No one ever went there and the store wasn't open,” she says. “If he's not doing the right thing he should get busted."
On Facebook, Smith pitches himself as a seller of French bulldogs, offering individual dogs for as much as $3,500. In a post made on July 11, Smith says “I’ve got four females for sale, three pregnant. I’ll take $50K for the set.”
Investigators say that they were tipped off by someone who heard the puppies inside the building.
"Obviously if you're going to house pets anywhere you need to go there and there need to be people at least checking up on them and it didn't seem that was happening at all,” Bellotto says.
The dogs are now being cared for by the Humane Society in Tinton Falls.
Smith is being held at the Middlesex County Jail.


More from News 12
0:48
Authorities: Construction worker suffers fatal fall into trench at Kenilworth site

Authorities: Construction worker suffers fatal fall into trench at Kenilworth site

1:41
Death of New Jersey state trooper during training incident prompts investigation

Death of New Jersey state trooper during training incident prompts investigation

2:11
Early storms Tuesday followed by partial sun; temps warm to upper-70s

Early storms Tuesday followed by partial sun; temps warm to upper-70s

0:16
Police: Hoboken man facing weapons charges in road rage incident

Police: Hoboken man facing weapons charges in road rage incident

2:42
Jersey Shore surfer whose 20-foot wipeout went viral helps rescue struggling swimmer

Jersey Shore surfer whose 20-foot wipeout went viral helps rescue struggling swimmer

2:11
Seniors learn about potential scams as Rep. Gottheimer introduces legislation to protect them

Seniors learn about potential scams as Rep. Gottheimer introduces legislation to protect them

0:42
New Jersey florists prep orders for Mother’s Day celebrations

New Jersey florists prep orders for Mother’s Day celebrations

0:22
Upgrades underway at Newark Liberty International Airport’s Terminal A

Upgrades underway at Newark Liberty International Airport’s Terminal A

1:32
How to prepare for spotted lanternfly season

How to prepare for spotted lanternfly season

0:25
Officials: 2 firefighters hospitalized; dog dies in Wayne house fire

Officials: 2 firefighters hospitalized; dog dies in Wayne house fire

0:19
Fire officials: Driver extricated from car following Lyndhurst crash

Fire officials: Driver extricated from car following Lyndhurst crash

0:29
Department of Justice: 2 men sentenced for defrauding JetBlue Airways of $10 million

Department of Justice: 2 men sentenced for defrauding JetBlue Airways of $10 million

0:59
Jersey Buzz: Newark's Frankie Valli receives star on Hollywood Walk of Fame

Jersey Buzz: Newark's Frankie Valli receives star on Hollywood Walk of Fame

0:26
Three groups are suing New Jersey to block an offshore wind farm

Three groups are suing New Jersey to block an offshore wind farm

1:59
Asian Pacific American Heritage: News 12 speaks to 1st woman & Asian-American to lead New Jersey National Guard

Asian Pacific American Heritage: News 12 speaks to 1st woman & Asian-American to lead New Jersey National Guard

1:55
'Real Housewives' star Margaret Joseph's Soiree mocktail is Made In New Jersey

'Real Housewives' star Margaret Joseph's Soiree mocktail is Made In New Jersey

1:48
'This was a remarkable recovery': I-95 officially operating at full capacity

'This was a remarkable recovery': I-95 officially operating at full capacity

New Jersey National Teacher Appreciation Week Photos

New Jersey National Teacher Appreciation Week Photos

2:15
Turn To Tara explores how to stay safe from ‘cyber kidnapping’ scams

Turn To Tara explores how to stay safe from ‘cyber kidnapping’ scams

Guide: Deals and freebies for health care workers

Guide: Deals and freebies for health care workers