Bronx man says he can’t sleep after NYPD mistakes him for murder suspect

The NYPD says they thought they were face to face with a murder suspect, thinking Martell was the man wanted for a homicide back on Dec. 22 but realized he was the wrong person.

News 12 Staff

Jan 27, 2022, 3:30 AM

Updated 830 days ago

Share:

A Bronx man says he can’t sleep, can’t talk on the phone and can’t even think straight after he says guns were stuck in his face and he was yelled at by people who ended up being police officers. 
Martell Niblack is a 34-year-old from Morissania with three kids and no criminal record. He says that Wednesday night, he was driving home from work and talking on the phone with his mom when, out of nowhere, his car was surrounded by unmarked vehicles and multiple people pointed guns at him. 
Martell says he thought he was being robbed. 
He says that as the men yelled at him to get out of the car, he dropped his phone. But it wasn’t until Martell got out of the car that he saw badges and realized he was being surrounded by police officers–who he says never, at any point, identified themselves as NYPD. 
He says he started to record what was happening on his phone and says he heard a call on the radio and the police started to back off and leave him alone. 
The NYPD says they thought they were face to face with a murder suspect, thinking Martell was the man wanted for a homicide back on Dec. 22 but realized he was the wrong person. 
The NYPD emphasized that Martel was never removed from his car, questioned, or taken into custody. 
Now, Martel filed a notice of claim, seeking $1 million. He and his mother say it’s not about the money, but about accountability. 
Martel tells News 12 that as the legal process plays out and he’s forced to relive the night over and over again, he’s looking forward to finding a therapist to help him try to clear his mind.


More from News 12
0:48
Authorities: Construction worker suffers fatal fall into trench at Kenilworth site

Authorities: Construction worker suffers fatal fall into trench at Kenilworth site

1:41
Death of New Jersey state trooper during training incident prompts investigation

Death of New Jersey state trooper during training incident prompts investigation

2:11
Early storms Tuesday followed by partial sun; temps warm to upper-70s

Early storms Tuesday followed by partial sun; temps warm to upper-70s

0:16
Police: Hoboken man facing weapons charges in road rage incident

Police: Hoboken man facing weapons charges in road rage incident

2:42
Jersey Shore surfer whose 20-foot wipeout went viral helps rescue struggling swimmer

Jersey Shore surfer whose 20-foot wipeout went viral helps rescue struggling swimmer

2:11
Seniors learn about potential scams as Rep. Gottheimer introduces legislation to protect them

Seniors learn about potential scams as Rep. Gottheimer introduces legislation to protect them

0:42
New Jersey florists prep orders for Mother’s Day celebrations

New Jersey florists prep orders for Mother’s Day celebrations

0:22
Upgrades underway at Newark Liberty International Airport’s Terminal A

Upgrades underway at Newark Liberty International Airport’s Terminal A

1:32
How to prepare for spotted lanternfly season

How to prepare for spotted lanternfly season

0:25
Officials: 2 firefighters hospitalized; dog dies in Wayne house fire

Officials: 2 firefighters hospitalized; dog dies in Wayne house fire

0:19
Fire officials: Driver extricated from car following Lyndhurst crash

Fire officials: Driver extricated from car following Lyndhurst crash

0:29
Department of Justice: 2 men sentenced for defrauding JetBlue Airways of $10 million

Department of Justice: 2 men sentenced for defrauding JetBlue Airways of $10 million

0:59
Jersey Buzz: Newark's Frankie Valli receives star on Hollywood Walk of Fame

Jersey Buzz: Newark's Frankie Valli receives star on Hollywood Walk of Fame

0:26
Three groups are suing New Jersey to block an offshore wind farm

Three groups are suing New Jersey to block an offshore wind farm

1:59
Asian Pacific American Heritage: News 12 speaks to 1st woman & Asian-American to lead New Jersey National Guard

Asian Pacific American Heritage: News 12 speaks to 1st woman & Asian-American to lead New Jersey National Guard

1:55
'Real Housewives' star Margaret Joseph's Soiree mocktail is Made In New Jersey

'Real Housewives' star Margaret Joseph's Soiree mocktail is Made In New Jersey

1:48
'This was a remarkable recovery': I-95 officially operating at full capacity

'This was a remarkable recovery': I-95 officially operating at full capacity

New Jersey National Teacher Appreciation Week Photos

New Jersey National Teacher Appreciation Week Photos

2:15
Turn To Tara explores how to stay safe from ‘cyber kidnapping’ scams

Turn To Tara explores how to stay safe from ‘cyber kidnapping’ scams

Guide: Deals and freebies for health care workers

Guide: Deals and freebies for health care workers